I've a 10+ year old Craftsman 25 gal., oil-less one that still works but is way too loud. I've a max. of $500 to replace it but would like to be under budget if possible! I was going to buy one of the Lowes 30 gal. oil types, but they've seriously cheapened it and the new model has gotten terrible reviews.
In order to stay in budget I seem to need to avoid shipping and buy something in stock somewhere. If I have to go to oil-less to stay in budget, how loud are the newer models (induction motor, etc.) - who has any recommendations or experience?
If you have a Tractor Supply close by, take a look at their Air Compressors. I have this unit, just Tractor Supply label. It is much quieter than my previous 110V lubricated "2HP" model.
These units are heavy, agree with the desire to pick it up.
I have had my unit for a few years. Only maintenance was a couple of months ago. Had a leak causing the unit to run even when not used. I replaced some fittings, which reduced the leak. Turned out the final leak was a rubber O-Ring in the very inexpensive regulator mounted on the compressor/switch. Changed this out and no more leaks. I expect this will need to be replaced in another couple of years.
Just over a year ago I was in exactly the same situation - with a progressively noisier Craftsman direct-drive oil-less compressor (mine is kept in the garage and a 1/2" copper air line plumbed into the basement shop) - to the point that the noise was so bad that my wife suggested (!) that I replace the compressor.
I was going to go the Campbell-Hausfeld route with a piston-type compressor, but didn't want to pay the excessive freight costs. After asking a few local contractors what they use, and visiting one of our local mechanical/industrial suppliers, a majority suggested buying a Castair Compressor which is a piston type/oil lubricated compressor. (link below) After I had a closer look at the compressor that would fit my available space, and taking it for a "test drive" as to noise, etc. in at the store, I decided to buy it. I would not go back to an oil-less compressor given how quiet and efficient the piston type has proven to be.
I paid $509 (plus tax) on 9 December 2010 for the 2HP/20 gallon unit that I bought (Model G212P50) - it has provided flawless, QUIET service over the past year. MUCH quieter than the Craftsman by far - so quiet in fact that my wife once asked me if I still keep the compressor on most of the time. It is made in Minnesota, with replacement parts a phone call away, and just up the road from me.
I don't know if this will help you or not, but you might ask around at some of your local mechanical/industrial suppliers to see what they sell and/or stock. The price was actually better than Campbell-Hausfeld units purchased over the internet when shipping was added. (....plus it supports our local businesses.)
Dont overlook the larger models, 60 gallon and 5/7 HP. They are not that much more expensive and are needed if you get into any air tools like a die grinder or disc sander. They eat up air a lot faster. I would not ever have an oil-less compressor. Not only due to the noise but I got mine 10 years?? ago and it will be the only one I will buy in my lifetime. The other issue is the compressor runs at a lot slower RPM, for longer life.
Well, it seems you want the best of both worlds of course......I have a big one for the shop that does what Lyle was talking about (look at your cfm requirements ) and a 2hp portable, that is virtually inadequate and overworked in the shop, works ok for construction sites using brad nailers or framing nailers...never hurts to have two!! Good Luck
I bought a Emglo DeWalt oil less called a Work shop compressor. It runs at 73dbs. The only thing I would do differently is get the larger one I got the 17 Gal
and I think they made a 30 gal upright.It was only like $348.00. I've had it 4 years and still runs great.
One thing you can do is put it in a quit room I did it to my dust collector and this compressor and hardly hear anything from the low noise compressor and my 1200 cfm Delta dust collector makes more noise with the air going in the hose then the unit itself.