Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Is this a really bad idea?

Posts

Is this a really bad idea?

#1

Is this a really bad idea?

arthur in LA

What I want to do is this:

I have a 3/4 hp single stage dust collector. From PSI, gotten when I bought a bunch of other tools used. I want to connect this to a collector port mounted right behind the lathe. Because of placement and other considerations, I want to put it about 12’ from the lathe. I am proposing getting a 4” to 3” rubber reducer from Lowes and then running about 10’ of plastic 3” pipe, then jumping back up to 4” to fit the port that fits behind the lathe, with some of the flexible 4” dust collector hose.

What do you all think? Will this put too much of a restriction on the air movement and lead to premature motor failure or other disastrous consequences which I have not foreseen?

I know the plastic pvc needs to be grounded because of the potential of static electric spark, but is there anything else? Does anyone have this kind of arrangement in their shop? The dust collector would not be used for anything else except the lathe area. And I would not be using it to collect the long shavings that come from turning, mostly trying to collect sanding dust and other small airborne particles. This is partially a result of seeing the sanding hood that robohippy posted a month or so ago.

If the consensus is that the pvc is an ok idea, then what of the idea of turning a wood “plug” that would fit in the 4” port hole that reduced down to a 2’” inlet pipe for the hose for my shop vac, so I could use it to help clean up around the lathe area.

Is this just a really bad idea?

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

#2

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

Don Orr

Maybe not a bad idea, but probably not a great one either. Why not just run the 4" PVC all the way from collector to lathe and not have any restrictions? I did not ground mine and can't get enough static to make a spark. I get more from my shopvac. Putting an extra port for vac hose sounds like a good thing to me. I have a similar collector from PSI and it works pretty well. Try not to have 90 degree bends in your line-use 45's as much as possible. Hope it works out well for you.

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: Is this a really bad idea? *LINK*

Rob Wallace

Hello Arthur!

I don't understand the logic of using a 3" PVC pipe when a 4" pipe would be far more efficient over the same distance. One of the first rules of designing dust collection systems is to maintain high air flow volumes - reducing duct diameter from 4" down to 3" and then back to 4" doesn't make any sense. To answer your question directly - Yes, it is a bad idea. Maybe not a REALLY bad idea, but bad nonetheless.

A 3" pipe (assuming this is the inside diameter) has a cross-sectional area of about 7 square inches, whereas a 4" diameter pipe has a cross sectional area of over 12.5 square inches - about 78% more than a 3" pipe. For the same length of run, the smaller diameter pipe will have considerably more resistance to air flow, and will be far less efficient. Try to maintain uniform pipe diameters throughout the system with no major changes in diameter (larger or smaller) and use gradual curves when they are needed (e.g. the bends in standard DWV 90 degree PVC ells are too abrupt - better to use two 45 degree street ells instead). When connecting the pipe to your hood and collector unit, do not have any abrupt curves in the system, particularly as the hose enters the impeller unit of the dust collector. You are striving for as much air flow as possible while creating and maintaining laminar air flow throughout the ducts and hoses of the system. Good laminar flow maintains high flow volumes at high rates (air velocity) which does the the job of carrying dust, etc. away - any reduction in the efficiency of the system means that less dust is capable of being removed with a given rated air flow volume produced by the dust collector.

You are proposing to install a fairly simple system, but the same rules and physical properties of moving air apply to a one duct line or a multiple-branched system. You might want to have a quick read about some of the practical theory of dust collection (link below) to understand why duct diameter is important.

Whatever you wind up doing for your DC system, be happy in knowing that any effort to remove and contain wood dust is a very positive improvement in the enjoyment of your woodturning, and will result in improving the long term health condition of your woodturning station. I'll be talking about this during my demonstration on 'Setting up a safe and efficient woodturning station' at the AAW Symposium in San Jose next June.

If you have additional, more specific questions, just ask!

Good luck!

Rob Wallace


Ductwork Tutorial at Oneida Air Systems

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

#4

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

Barry Irby

Locally Lowes carries S&D or Sewer and Drain PVC Pipe that has thinner walls and is much cheaper than the plumbing pipe. They only stock 4" and 6". You could use that.

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

#5

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

Bill McWhirter

According to Poiseuille's law, flow through a tube is proportional to the fourth power of the radius. Theoretically, you should get over three time the flow through a 4" pipe compared to a 3" pipe of the same length. This just theory, but a slight change in the diameter can really change the flow.

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

#6

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

Roger Chandler

This is how I handled the issue of dust collection at my lathe


Re: Is this a really bad idea?

#7

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

arthur in LA

thanks to everyone for their response.

I am very glad to be able to use this site to ask a question and have informed people give me answers.

I will go and buy 4" and go that route.

Thanks to everyone.

Arthur

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

#8

INDEPENDENT source for all things Dust Collector *LINK*

charlie belden

Probably more info than you'd ever want - but probably the most objective, quantitative info on all things Dust Collector - done by a guy with a vested interest in getting it right - because he has a lung condition and is very sensitive to sawdust ( puts him in the hospital and then on oxygen for months)


Objective Quantitative Info On Dust Collection

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Is this a really bad idea?

Jesper, Denmark

Only one comment: To catch the fine sanding dust, you need as much airflow as possibel - so us the 4" hose all the way - no reducers and as few bends as possible.