Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

"Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

Posts

"Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

#1

George Taylor

"Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

George Taylor

I thought this was discussed before but my search came up empty. I used the word "straightforward" rather than "simple" because I am not trying to take shortcuts; I just do not have a HVLP (or other sophisticated spraying apparatus) nor the space to house that set up.

So with that said, what is the best finish for FBE that may retain the color longer than the oil finish I used on some salad bowls? I have no issue on buying aerosol cans of lacquer (or whatever), I am not a production facility; I just have a dozen or so nice blanks roughed and drying in the garage and I want to do justice the absolute beauty of the wood. I have used wipe-on poly finishes in the past and do use the Beall system for buffing a lot of my turnings.

Thanks in advance and Happy New Year to all!

George

Re: "Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

#2

Re: "Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

John Lucas

No finish that I can find will keep the red from changing color if you let it get a lot of UV light. So you can simply use whatever finish you like because it won't protect it. I would recommend any finish that has a High UV inhibitor but unfortunately the ones that do tend to yellow the wood a lot. I like to use wipe on poly or lacquer simply because it makes the wood look good and is easy to apply.

Keep it out of direct sunlight and the color will last for many years. Put it in direct sunlight and the red will turn to brown in a couple of days. I tried special UV sprays designed to keep photos from fading and just about everything else people recommended. Then I put the samples in the sun and all of them changed color in just one day.

If you truly want the color to be permanent spray directly over it with metallic non fading dyes that are the same color. That's the only method I've heard of that really works.

Re: "Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

#3

Re: "Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

John Jordan

Krylon UV Resistant Clear, in the "matte" version (that's my preference). If you want a little more shine, you can steel wool and buff it up. It will help some, but as John said, nothing will stop it. Having said that, I have pieces that are 15 years old that are still red, but they don't get much daylight.

John

Re: "Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

#4

Re: "Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

John Lucas

That is one of the finishes I tried and it's a wonderful finish. It just doesn't stop the red from changing color. My oldest box elder piece was about 5 years old and still looked great. I sold it just recently. The only one I have left it 2 years old and it's been in a cabinet most of the time and still looks brand new.

I have some fresh box elder. If anyone has a finish that I haven't tried and I can get it conveniently I'll give it a go. If you live in the area and want some of the wood come buy. I have the week off and will be in the shop most of the time. I'll cut you a slice.

Re: "Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

#5

Some Extra Info

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I had a piece of BE analyzed by a friend who is a PHD biochemist. The red we love is composed of phenol compounds (mostly "phenol red"). Phenol chemical bonds are actually pretty fragile so it doesn't take much energy to break them down to brown. Thus high energy light, both UV and IR will quickly reduce them. Regardless of what finish you use, you'll want to keep your pieces away from both heat and UV light. Don't forget blacklites and daylight-type fluorescent bulbs.

Pho uses his air brush to substitute metalized dyes for the original staining as mentioned by John.

Re: "Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

#6

Many years ago, at least 30, which is....

JamieDonaldson

.. a lifetime to many, a turner named John Dodge Meyer used photo retouching oil paints to paint over the original red in his BE pieces. With a fine brush the results were completely undetectable to the viewer, and I have a piece in my collection that has not changed since purchase in 1992. The Marshall oil based pigment paint was used for many years to tint B&W photos to color, and they are much more archival than most any other color photo process. Application of archival dyes or pigments to a turning with an airbrush would be very similar, another example that there is little new that hasn't been attempted before!

Re: "Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

#7

Closest

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I get to painting is a 6" brush when sealing my decks. With my handwriting, I don't stand a chance using an air brush! :D

I just have to watch the red fade. Ah well . . . .

Re: "Straightforward" finish for Flaming Box Elder

#8

Better than watching grass grow