Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Slow degradation in the shop...

Posts

Slow degradation in the shop...

#1

Steven Antonucci

Slow degradation in the shop...

steven antonucci

Based upon my last post, I wonder how often the little things that are wrong in our shops go unnoticed. If it isn't broken, don't fix it? Right?

My lathe was probably losing that bearing for the past month or longer, and because it was only infinitesimally worse than it was yesterday, I didn't take notice...until the lathe was SCREAMING at me.

I turn a lot. I always remarked that I was a 220 turner in my shop, and a 400 turner on the Oneways at both of my clubs. I attributed it to the Oneway's bearing being a lot smoother than the Nova's...and they are, but now I wonder how much of that was because the bearings were failing? My first cuts on the Nova with the new headstock were 400's. (starting grit of sandpaper...)

With the recent thread of a shop fire, I wonder if left untouched if the bearing may have been a silent threat to start a fire? (Ok, not so silent...) Anyone that has ever stood in my shop knows that I only clean it... well, never.

I urge everyone as the New year approaches to "go over" your equipment carefully. If you have the opportunity to visit other shops, take it. Listen to how the machines sound there, and compare them to your own. An annual tune-up is probably a new tradition in my shop...

Steve

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

#2

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

Lewis Dodd

Sound Advice!

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

#3

Send me your Sand Paper ......

jake Niedling

under 400 grit. I usually never take anything I turn past 320 grit. I always finish sanding with the grain of the wood by hand at 220 and 320 grits before going to the next grit. If everything you turn is a 400 grit off the tool finish, I am over the top impressed.

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

#4

Re: Send me your Sand Paper ......

bill Crommett

I wish that the physical degradation of the turner in my shop was as slow as the shop degradation .

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

#5

Steven Antonucci

That's part of what I was thinking

steven antonucci

when I posted this.

I tore a rotator cuff a couple of years back. It was fairly minor, but I retore it in an awful way a few months ago. Painful is an understatement. (It's why I am posting at 3:48 AM...waiting for the Advil to kick in...)

Unlike machinery, we have built in mechanisms that start to let us know when something is wrong. Pain, fever, crackling joints all tells us that our own machinery is in need of some maintenance. I bet that we ignore the little things in ourselves the same way we miss the little things in the machines.

Preventative maintenance is a good thing in the shop as it is in our personal lives. Like sharp tools, a well tuned lathe with a well tuned turner make the overall experience something too much fun to deny! (I turned a handful of tops last night at 10PM because it was like having a new lathe delivered!)

Steve

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Send me your Sand Paper ......

Lyle Jamieson

Jake, 220 grit is fine if you are doing a table top with multiple coats of surface finishes. Try sanding up to 600 grit on one of your turnings and look at the difference. The grain character will pop, and the color will be brilliant. The 220 surface will look cloudy and masked. You will be eliminating much of the blotchiness from the end grain. This assumes of course that you use sharp sandpaper and dont skip grits.

Tool technique and tool control can eliminate much of the courser sanding effort. Grain orientation is a key to starting with 220-320 grit, not ending there.

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

#7

Re: Send me your Sand Paper ......

john lucas

Lyle I did a test years ago using about 4 different woods and 4 different finishes, both Oil and lacquer and a few others. I sanded each piece in 2" sections up to 1200 grit and the applied the finishes. I passed these around to the club and asked where the line was that they could no longer see a change in finish. they didn't know what grits were where. Only on one oil finish could anyone see a difference beyond 400 grit. there was a very thin oil finish you could make out the 600 grit line.

this was flat wood although I did pick woods with curl and things I thought would show a difference. Before the finish you can see the sanding lines but after the finish you can't. With lacquer anything beyond 220 was very difficult if not impossible to see the difference.

I do plan to do the same test one of these days with turned pieces and I haven't run a test yet but Mahoney's Walnut oil seems to need higher grit sanding to look good.

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

#8

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

Don at Central Illinois

I am retiring at the end of this year ( 5 days and 7 hours, but who'se counting) and I haven't been able to turn much lately. One of my first objectives to to CLEAN MY SHOP. I, like you, only clean, never. May take me a week or two but I plan to get er done.

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Send me your Sand Paper ......

Lyle Jamieson

I use a wiping varnish so I dont let a buildup of finish of any kind. The shine I get is from the buffed on wax. So it is important for me to have a good surface on the wood showing.

I do believe you can see the differences between 220 and 600 with almost any finish. Its not the finish that will change but the background quality of the wood coming through will change. I agree with you that over 600 is overkill with no benefit unless you are into exoctics, or bone, or plastics, then polishing to a higher level might be noticable.

Re: Slow degradation in the shop...

#10

Re: Send me your Sand Paper ......

John Lucas

I have found that you need to polish things like some epoxy fillers and brass and copper fillers to higher than 600 if you want the shine of that metal. I usually go to 1200 grit or 4/0 and that's often enough for these fillers but sometimes it requires really polishing the metal.