Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

Posts

Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

steven antonucci


Lathe is steady and solid, but the noise is actually way, way worse than the video portrays. I would have thought a bad bearing would generate heat or vibration?

Anyone?

Steve

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#2

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

Bill Howatt

If there is no belt involved, I think that certainly could be a bad bearing but if it isn't, it is something rubbing on something and the machine or motor needs to be disassembled and examined.

If there is a belt make sure it isn't slipping. If you remove the belt, if present, can you spin the motor and spindle freely?

Bill

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#3

Steven Antonucci

It is belt driven

steven antonucci

When I pulled the belt off last night, there is no obvious noise or vibration from the motor pulley or the spindle. I thought it might be a bad belt, but I am not sure how to isolate it. I have a buddy who owns a Nova, and I may just ask him to pull his belt and come over to test it.

It is a new problem, and it is related to the speed (sound changes at higher speed) and sometimes fades in or out...

It is deafening.

Steve

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#4

Re: It is belt driven

Rich Egan

Find a way to attach a shaft to the spindle you can spin fast, like with a drill, and crank it up to speed to see if you can duplicate the noise without the motor or drive belt.

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

Mike Stafford

Sounds like the belt is slipping...

Try some belt dressing or go to a linked belt.

Of course it could be something else entirely.....gremlins?

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#6

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

john lucas

I agree it sound like either the belt slipping or rubbing the side of the pulley. On those lathes it's not uncommom for the top pulley to come loose. Check the alignment of the two pulleys and then tighten the set screws.

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#7

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

Mike Gibson

l will give you $10 cash for the lathe and take a chance l am not getting robbed. :-)

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#8

Mike Stafford

I'll offer $11!


Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#9

Steven Antonucci

Your generosity is overwhelming

steven antonucci

I will be pulling the whole lathe apart tonite to test a few things out. If I can't put it back together, you guys can fight it out.

Make sure you video tape it. I own the rights to the Nova Cage Match.

Steve

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#10

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

Stuart Johnson

What's wrong with you guys? It's a good lathe. I'll offer $35 delivered or $45 if a hook tool lesson is included.

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#11

Re: Your generosity is overwhelming

Stuart Johnson

Steve, I've got an extra belt I'll send you if you need to give it a try.

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#12

Steven Antonucci

What nobody remembers is that I have another...

steven antonucci

headstock!

S

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#13

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

Bob Salvetti

Hey Steven,

I haven't had that noise from my Nova - yet. But, I did have some similar sound from my Jet mini. It was the pulley on the headstock spindle rubbing against the housing (?). The set-screw in the pulley came loose somehow and the pulley shifted up against the housing. Re-align, re-tighten, done job.

Good luck.

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#14

Steven Antonucci

It is a bad bearing.

steven antonucci

No question about it. I pulled it apart and isolated the spindle. One of the bearings is toast.

The good news is that I have that other headstock...so, a few choice words about getting the pivot pin out (90% of the time spent) and I am back in business. I won't say that it's a brand new lathe, but the difference is night and day.

Thanks for all who listened in. I can only do this trick once, but it should last me another 10 years and 10,000 hours.

Steve

P.S. no you cannot have my spare parts drawer for the lathe...

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#15

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

D. Hansen

Steve sounds like the pulley has come loose and is rubbing inside the housing. I think yours looks like a Nova 3000 right. Check the pulley it might have come loose and slipped inside the unit.

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#16

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

To check most any bearing: Use the biggest screw driver that you own as a stethoscope. Place the blade on the housing near the bearing. Put the handle butt against your ear and push your ear flap closed. The overall noise will filter out. If you hear any scrapes, pops, knocks, grinding,screaming, etc then that bearing is bad. Always replace bearings as sets. This will isolate the problem to the spindle or motor. Sc drivers of about 18" are best. BE CAREFUL! Use an assistant to cycle the motor if there is any chance of sticking driver into moving parts. You will be surprised at what you will hear out of the general noise.

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#17

Steven Antonucci

That's what Wil told me too?

steven antonucci

I assumed it had merit, because Wil was the first person I called when I had a question. I tried dressing the belt first, and it did nothing. It was obvious when I had the spindle isolate, but Wil also suggested a screwdriver as a stethoscope.

Thanks for publishing the tip!

Steve

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#18

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

I have no knowledge of your lathe but as a retired agricultural engineer I would ask myself this question first: Does the sound increase or decrease with the change of speed?

Then I would take a long screwdriver and place the blade end on the bearing housings in turn and put my ear against the other end. Any loud grating noises at a lower speed would indicate to me which bearing is likely to be suffering. If the sound is almost the same on all bearings I would then release the tension on the belt or remove it and test again spinning by hand to eliminate motor noise, it could be a motor bearing!

I may be talking to an engineer but it is the only way I can offer to help!

Regards Peter.

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#19

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

My apologies, I failed to read the previous messages.

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#20

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

Roger Courtney

Hi I have the earlier model tecknatool 1500 the belt is a poly v and what could have happened it has jumped out of one of the groves. Another possibility is the pullys are not lined up. If it is the pully grub screws it will make a tiking noise if bearing a screeching sound use srewdriver as said by a previouse answer it works. Regards Roger in Pretoria RSA

Re: Is this what a bad bearing sounds like?

#21

Re: spindle lock?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

Steve: I have the same lathe. I expect you would have noticed this, but I'll say it anyways.

On my lathe when I keep the spindle lock in the "unlock" position, the locking pin is makes contact with the drive pulley. When I park the spindle lock in the unlock position, it will screech just like the video file you posted. So I keep the spindle lock in any position except the locked or the specific unlock position.

Check this out. I could not quite tell what position your spindle lock was in the video. It's a long shot, but worth mentioning (and as I said, I expect you would have already noticed this).

Henry