Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

Posts

Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#1

Aage Rendalen

Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

Aage Rendalen

I use tung oil cut with mineral oil for my usual finish. On cherry I have of late had a problem with spots that have not absorbed the oil well. Does this indicate that I've mixed in too much mineral oil, or is it caused by uneven sanding?

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#2

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

John Jordan

Mineral oil is not really a finish and does not harden. If the tung oil is too thick, and its not old, thin it with a little mineral spirits.

John

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#3

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

GaryG in MD

What John said...

Plus, you'll generally get less variation (splotching) between end and side grain if you put on a thin coat of shellac (sanding sealer) first.

...Gary

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#4

JL

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

JL

What John said.

In addition to cutting with a little mineral spirits (you don't need much) - you may want to gently heat your oil. I have a small crock pot that I picked up a thrift store. I fill it with water and turn it on low. I place a glass jar with tung oil (or BLO).

The heated oil penetrates more evenly and easier.

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#5

Aage Rendalen

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

Aage Rendalen

Sorry, it's mineral SPIRITS I use, not mineral oil.

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#6

Walt Bennett

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

Walt Bennett

There's also the possibility you've crushed the ends of some of the wood pores while turning and didn't sand through this. I can't recall who it was that I saw demonstrate this problem with cherry years back, but cherry is one of very few woods that has this problem. If you're turning 'down hill' or with even a slightly dull tool it's especially easy to cause this and you'll not actually see a problem until you apply a finish - it won't be able to enter the crushed pore ends, but will everywhere else. Only recourse is to sand all over again, starting with something like 80 grit. Spindle turned items will tend to have a ring of discoloration while bowls get streaks or splotches.

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#7

That's interesting, Walt...

GaryG in MD

I hadn't heard that one. Thanks for the tip. ...Gary

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#8

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

John Lucas

I learned of this problem from the late Charles Alvis. It's not just cherry and is usually caused by having a sharp edge at the bottom of your bevel. He called it burnishing or bruising. It goes very deep and will often to sand out unless you go to very course grits.

It's easy to identify because the lines that are usually darker (similar to end grain absorbing too much finish) will run parallel to the rotation of the piece while you were turning. Cherry is certainly not the only wood that will show this although it seems to show it worse.

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#9

Aage Rendalen

Bruising makes sense: What about secondary bevels?

Aage Rendalen

I have not tried grinding over my bottom bevel so as to reduce its sharpness and the possibility for unwanted bruising. Will a secondary bevel help? And what about controlling a gouge that's as rounded over as Michelsen's grind?

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#10

Re: Bruising makes sense: What about secondary bev

GaryG in MD

Aage, I have relieved the bevels on all my gouges. It makes them much easier to use, and the results are much better. They go around inside curves now with ease, and I have no more problems with bruising. (Bradford pear is a wood that bruises very easily -- after leaving "rings" on the inside of a Bradford bowl is when I made the change.) You bevel doesn't have to be tiny but that's all you really need. I use about 1/8" on my smaller gouges, and maybe 3/16" on the larger ones. Some of the pros use as little as 1-mm. It's just a matter of practice in presenting the tool edge to the wood at the proper angle. Check out online videos by the likes of Hannes, Cindy, Trent, etc. ...Gary

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#11

Re: Bruising makes sense: What about secondary bev

John Lucas

I too have been shortening my primary bevel by grinding a secondary bevel. Then I grind the bottom of this bevel off as well so really I sort of have 3 bevels. I like the short primary bevel. It seems to have less friction and as mentioned above seems to track inside a bowl better.

Re: Uneven absorption of oil finish on cherry

#12

Re: Bruising makes sense: What about secondary bev

Carol Reed

When I tok the class with Cindy, her primary bevel was in the neighorhood of a mm or so. Took some getting used to but it is sweet once you get there. Tool control!