Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

My Blade Bows

Posts

My Blade Bows

#1

My Blade Bows

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

I was cutting some wet cherry bowl blanks on my bandsaw over the weekend and had a problem with the blade bowing making the sides more or less round. The blanks averaged 4-8 inches thick and 10 inches in diameter. I was using a 1/2 inch skip tooth blade on a MiniMax 20. Tension was per the blade manufacterer's instructions regarding flutter test then add a partial turn. Upper guides were set about one inch above the highest point of the wood. This is a common problem for me and thick wet wood.

What am I doing wrong? Is the blade too big, dull or, just the wrong choice for this application?

TIA, Doug

Re: My Blade Bows

#2

Re: My Blade Bows

john lucas

The most common problems for this are dull blade, feeding too fast, and blade tension. If your sure tension is correct then it almost has to be one of the other 2. A saw that size should cut through wood that thick with ease. If a new blade doesn't solve the problem then it almost has to be blade tension. A sharp properly tensioned blade should cut through that with the guides not even in place.

Re: My Blade Bows

#3

Re: My Blade Bows

john lucas

The most common problems for this are dull blade, feeding too fast, and blade tension. If your sure tension is correct then it almost has to be one of the other 2. A saw that size should cut through wood that thick with ease. If a new blade doesn't solve the problem then it almost has to be blade tension. A sharp properly tensioned blade should cut through that with the guides not even in place.

Re: My Blade Bows

#4

Re: My Blade Bows

Lewis Dodd

Well, my experience with cherry or at least our mtn cherry in central Texas, let me correct that my experiences with cherry .......well it sure is purty when ya finnally get er dun, then it splits on ya, then it...then it... then it.....oh well I regress. Wet wood can be a bugger and cherry is right up thar.

Re: My Blade Bows

#5

Walt Bennett

Re: My Blade Bows

Walt Bennett

I've an MM20 also and can second John's comment. One other thing is that the gauge on your saw may be off and you don't have enough tension. I 'calibrated' mine after owning it about a year and finally figuring this out. With about 6" of exposed blade above the table, you should be able to push it sideways not more than 1/4". Not precise, but you may find quite a difference between where you get this movement and where the gauge is on your bandsaw.

Re: My Blade Bows

#6

Re: My Blade Bows

Barry Irby

It sounds like you are describing "Barreling". The blade curves in the cut because it lacks the proper tension and by making its path longer it tensions itself. Dull blades contribute because they get hot and expand, reducing the tension. I woudl suggest a sharp blade and increased tension.

I just bought one of Highland Hardware's wood tuners blades. Its a 3/8" blade with about 3 tpi with deep gullets and a wide set and it is supposed to be excellent for bowl blanks and green wood, Have not tried it yet. I have cut many blanks with the blade you describe, though.

Re: My Blade Bows

#7

how many teeth per inch?

Dick Coers

Gullets loaded with sawdust can cause the barreling as well. So slower feeds, or less teeth.

Re: My Blade Bows

#8

Harry Robinette

Re: My Blade Bows

harry robinette

I started using the flutter tensioning way of tensioning my blades. All these new blades are made from different types of steel or are hardened on one side or the other. The Timber Wolfe has the flutter tensioning way on the back of there package because they recommend it for there blades cause there Low Tension Steel. I'm Using an 18" Rikon band saw and 1/2" X 3 or 4 TPI and having no problems sense I started fluttering the tension. Timber Wolfe blade right now but also use some Olson hard back blades.

Re: My Blade Bows

#9

Re: My Blade Bows

John Lucas

Can you explain the flutter test. I use my version. I have a riser block on my saw and the part that covers the blade on the left side allows me to see the blade. There is about 12" exposed. I watch it flutter and vibrate as I tension the blade. When it stops vibrating I have the tension right for that blade.

Re: My Blade Bows

#10

Re: My Blade Bows

Bob Edwards

I had an opportunity to mentor a club member in his shop recently and while cutting a bowl blank in dry Mesquite the blade bowed and tracked to the right so bad I had to nibble away the corners until I got a shape round enough to mount on the lathe. I tried all the things mentioned above and finally inspected the blade. The 1/2" blade was a skip tooth but as you looked at it head on there was almost no set in the teeth to the left side but lots of set to the right. He didn't have a spare blade and had no explanation as to why the set on the teeth were so bad. Had to give up on it.

Re: My Blade Bows

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: My Blade Bows *LINK*

Keith Tompkins

Hi Doug, Without seeing the machine, I have a good idea what's going on here. First, with the saw running, how far is the rear bearing from the back of the blade? It should be almost touching, yet not spinning until pressure is applied to the blade. Now, check the LOWER guide as well...it should be adjusted the same. My bet is you have too much clearance there, maybe 1/4" or so. If that's the case, your set has been removed by the side guides. Without proper set, the blade won't turn properly....not enough side clearance. Your symptom is a curved, rather than straight side. It's doing that because too much stress on the blade is putting pressure on the BACK of the blade, which allows the front, which is now under less tension than the rear of the blade, to wander. It will naturally wander towards the outside, due to the side load being applied to it. The more you try to turn the blade, the more the blade curves to the outside. YOU HAVE A POTENTIALLY VERY DANGEROUS SITUATION...THE PROBLEM YOU DESCRIBE IS ONE OF THE MAIN CAUSES OF BANDSAW ACCIDENTS, AND THE PROBLEM MUST BE REMEDIED. The blade can easily exit the blank because the blade is running to the outside of the cut...I've provided a link to an article I recently wrote for the AAW Journal, which should help.


http://www.keithptompkins.com/storage/bandsawsafety.pdf

Re: My Blade Bows

#12

Walt Bennett

Re: My Blade Bows

Walt Bennett

Good point, Keith. Since I've the same saw, I assumed he'd had the rear bearings adjusted correctly. The bottom one is easy to forget about though.

Re: My Blade Bows

#13

Re: My Blade Bows

Charles B. Watson

Have you checked for side movement when pushing against the blade after you have tensioned it using your flutter method?

I can't imagine that being enough tension for cutting large green wood blanks even though that is a tensioning method advocated by a least one manufacturer. I have lots of Lenox bandsaw blade stock on hand so I doubt I will ever experiment with a low tension blade. My saw requires a custom blade due to it's blade length.

Re: My Blade Bows

#14

Re: My Blade Bows

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Hi Keith,

Thanks for your note. This is good information.

Mike

1 more Christmas item to turn in Apex, NC!!

Re: My Blade Bows

#15

Re: My Blade Bows

robo hippy

I have been using the Lennox Diemaster blades for years, and have never had that problem, except with really dull blades. Keep your blades, like your turning tools, sharp. There are different thicknesses of blades. The thicker ones will flex less, and are better for rough cuts on uneven blanks.

Most tension guides on bandsaws are junk. Generally way under weight as in if it says you are at proper tension for a 1/2 inch blade, crank it up to 3/4 or 1 inch blade size. There is a fancy gadget that you can buy that will measure tension, but unless you have a shop full of bandsaws, not worth the money ($500 plus).

The thrust bearings need to be checked just about every time you use your saw. Mine, especially on my Laguna, seem to loosen up from time to time.

robo hippy

Re: My Blade Bows

#16

Harry Robinette

Re: My Blade Bows

harry robinette

The flutter tensioning is on the timber wolfe packaging.

I have used this way to tension on Carter,Olson ,Timber W, and the old Woodcraft blades on my Jet 14 w/riser and now my 18" Rikon . I can't remember were I read about it first but I've used it for at least 8 or 10 years. It seams to me that I read it in one of the wood working magz specials on bandsaws.

I cut large blanks from green wood all the time with no problem most around 18" to 20". On the 18" and did 14" or so with my old jet. I think it works better then the marks on the machine telling me every blade is made the same. I use it,it works, I like it .

Install blade as usual and tension to machine marks for that size blade also set the tracking.

Blade guard should be at least 6" up and the side guides loose so the blade can move.

SLOWLY start to detension the blade ( saw running ) when the blade starts to flutter STOP.

Now SLOWLY start to retension just till the flutter Stops.

When the fluter stops, go 1/2 to 3/4 turn tighter.

The blade should be set right.

Some blades will end up at the marks on the saw but not many.

Re: My Blade Bows

#17

Re: My Blade Bows

Bill Noce in Northeast Ohio

Harry,

I learn this way of tensioning blades when I bought my Timber Wolf Blades at the Woodworking shows when they held them at the Summit County Fair Grounds in Ohio years ago. I use to buy all my Timber Wolf Blades from Timber Wolf Vendor every year.

Re: My Blade Bows

#18

Re: My Blade Bows

Bill Noce in Northeast Ohio

Forgot this check out www.suffolkmachinery.com good info on tensiong these blades.