Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

On 'turning air'

Posts

On 'turning air'

#1

BarbS

On 'turning air'

BarbS

Okay, I need further input from you experts. On FB this morning, Melvyn Firmager advised another turner: "for me it is down to gouge tool control - not 'rubbing' the bevel (as to do so when turning 'air' causes tool bounce), offering the tools to the wood not pushing against it, good body movement, relaxing and breathing."

I thanked him for posting his advice, but I'm a bit lost. If not trying to stay on the bevel when turning air, do I just offer the sharpened edge softly, directly on to the surface at as high a speed as I can? I've only tried this twice, and both times my gouge gave me so much bouncing and tear out (chunks-out) when trying to utilize the bevel, that I know I'm doing it wrongly.

Re: On 'turning air'

#2

Re: On 'turning air'

john lucas

Interesting. He is a master at this. If you think about it when you use a parting tool on an edge that has air, such as making a parting cut into a square turning, you are not rubbing the bevel and yet you have some control.

I would be leery of at least having the tool in the same position as rubbing the bevel but I would have to try it and see. Melvin has turned a heck of a lot more air than I ever have. That sounds funny saying that. It would certainly save on wood if you just turned air. :)

I'll be interested in what others have to say. On square turnings I find that I have to be really light on the bevel but I don't believe I've ever done it without actually being on the bevel for control of the shape.

If not using the bevel then wouldn't a scraper or something like the new Hercules tool work better for turning air. I don't think so but then again Melvin is beyond me and I certainly am willing to learn.

Re: On 'turning air'

#3

Re: On 'turning air'

HeatherAinAK

Stewart Batty put it in a way that made sense to me. He said that when he told students to ride or rub the bevel that they used to much pressure. He tells them now to float the bevel. There is bevel contact but not really pressure. I think it is all a matter of degree. I was having a hard time with chatter and bounce that was eliminated once I got this concept. Even with small cuts I was applying too much bevel pressure and once the bounce started it got worse and worse.

Heather

Re: On 'turning air'

#4

What Heather Said.


Re: On 'turning air'

#5

Re: On 'turning air'

Jeff Willaford

I present the gouge as if rubbing the bevel but with a slow and deliberate light touch. Watch the ghost and you'll soon figure it out. You can also watch the other side when working on the inside and you will see your cut. Slow, deliberate and light cut. Works for me anyway.

Re: On 'turning air'

#6

You can hear the difference

john lucas

When turning air you it is quite noisy when you have too much pressure on the bevel. Try to lighten up and listen. when it's as quiet as you can get it you will be cutting about right.

Re: On 'turning air'

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: On 'turning air'

Lyle Jamieson

If you do not have bevel support you are scraping. If you are scraping you need to make sure the tool edge is touching the wood at less then 90 degrees. If you scrape at +90 degrees you get a catch. Thats where the bevel comes into play. The bevel is a supporting the cut so it can not get a catch. Melvin has developed some unconventional grinds to be used without the bevel. Most of our traditional grinds will get into trouble trying that.

The bevel is a protecting and supporting mechinism. It is also a directing mechinism. So when you turn with voids the bevel does not rub but it needs to follow the line of the cut. While the intermittent cut is on the wood, the bevel is there to help, when it is in the air space, the direction must be heading in the right direction with no bouncing. So the force of the cut is not pushing on the handle but pushing with your fingertips of the toolrest hand in the direction of the bevel. We dont ride the bevel we follow it very gently. We can take a large shaving or a small shaving, its no different. Its all about bevel direction not bevel riding. I have my students line up the bevel BEFORE each cut starts. As Bonnie Klein says use the ABC's, Anchor, Bevel and then a Cut.

Even with a solid surface we do not ride the bevel but follow the line the bevel wants to go, very gently. If we ride the bevel on solid wood we can can get burnishing marks from the heel and start some vibration as the heel bounces on the soft and hard annual rings. Use sharp tools and relax and let the tool do all the work.

Re: On 'turning air'

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: You can hear the difference

Lyle Jamieson

Great point John, In solid wood you can hear excessive bevel noise just before it starts to vibrate and bounce. A good cut has a little hissing sound. It is a little harder to hear in intermittent cutting, but sound will help perfect the touch needed. No white knuckling or buldozing required

Re: On 'turning air'

#9

BarbS

Re: On 'turning air'

BarbS

All this is making a Great deal of sense now. I see errors in the way I've treated whole wood as well as partial wood surfaces. Very useful, thank you.

Re: On 'turning air'

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: On 'turning air'

Keith Tompkins

HI Barb, Here's my method..I turn LOTS of air. First, I take a levelling cut, pulling from the center out to the edges. The tool is an Ellsworth style grind, the lower edge is doing the cutting. No bevel rubbing, more of a scraping cut, just to level things out. The tool is presented at almost 90 degrees, no catches that way. Then, with bevel rubbing, I cut from center to the outside edge to clean up the cut. For the final cuts, I cut towards the center, bevel rubbing, just as you would turn a conventional bowl. I've found when cutting air, flute straight up helps prevent bouncing..it's one of the few times I cut flute up.

Re: On 'turning air'

#11

Flute straight up Keith!!?? That's too....

JamieDonaldson

..scary, and I would rather make a shearing cut with the diagonal wing of my big gouges, the method I frequently use when turning my square pieces. Using the wider slicing/shearing edge of the gouge also helps level and smooth the surface, just as we often do on the exterior of a bowl.

Re: On 'turning air'

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Flute straight up Keith!!?? That's too....

Keith Tompkins

Hey Jamie, Yes, it sounds scary, and I won't suggest a newbie try it right off, but it works. Normally, I roll the tool over in the direction of the cut, but I've found straight up (or nearly so) doesn't remove more wood at the trailing edge of the wood than at the leading edge...because the tool's not bouncing. I've found that when turning multi-axis work, the straight-up flute gives more control, less bounce as well. When I reach solid wood, I rotate the tool in the usual manner.

Re: On 'turning air'

#13

Re: Flute straight up Keith!!?? That's too....

John Lucas

I use the same cut for really thin bowls. It's like rubbing the bevel on the lower part of the edge. What I do is touch the lower part of the bevel. Then I rotate the flute up until the edge starts to cut. What is actually cutting is the front edge that is a pretty steep shear angle. It cuts really clean and you have almost no pressure on the bevel.

Like Keith said I don't teach this to new turners. It is a subtle move that needs to be done precisely. Too much and you get a nasty catch. Too little and it doesn't cut.

I believe the pressure on the bevel is less because the bevel is at a really steep angle so your pushing forward and not into the wood at all.

Re: On 'turning air'

#14

Re: On 'turning air'

Bob Edwards

Wow, Talk about different strokes....

I was in agreement with everyone until Kieth's comment. I don't have near his experience but I have much better luck with the flute rolled over to the right so that the right wing, near the tip of the tool is presented to the wood. There is some bevel involved but very little The tool is sharp and the cuts are lite and clean. As I run out of air and have solid wood I can roll the tool back to the left and continue to the bottom of the piece. This is not unlike using a skew to make a v cut in square stock. As Melvyn suggests there is a lot of body involved and I hook my left thumb on top of the tool rest and the gouge rests against it as my right hand, anchored to my hip controls the cut.

Like they say "What ever works for ya!

Re: On 'turning air'

#15

the key is not pushing

GaryG in MD

I was just going to say what Heather said...

What Melvyn is saying applies to all turning.

He isn't saying that we shouldn't have the bevel at the correct angle.

He's saying, what Stu Batty teaches, that you don't want to PUSH the tool against the wood. You hold the tool with fingers on both sides and "float" the edge (properly bevel aligned) up to the surface of the wood and control the cut. The cut will happen at the correct speed for the wood if you don't push. If you have to push, the tool needs sharpening. ...Gary

Re: On 'turning air'

#16

Re: On 'turning air'

robo hippy

I had an understanding about this in general, but really came to understand it this summer after watching Stuart and Mike Mahoney do their two ways to turn a bowl demo at the AAW Symposium. They turned a bowl that was about 14 inch diameter and 8 or so inches deep, down to 1/8 inch thick, and didn't use a steady rest, or even their hand on the outside to steady the bowl. After thinking about that for a few months it really dawned on me some of the things I was doing.

I seldom have my hand on the tool rest. You will be feeling and following the tool rest, and not feeling the wood.

You can get away with just about any cut when roughing, but the finish cuts need finesse.

You really can hear the difference. If you are pushing against the bevel too hard, the walls of the bowl will flex (well, not on the outside of a solid blank, but for sure on the inside), and the sound is rough and coarse. When just brushing the bevel, you get a hiss.

When you start to fight the bounce, you increase the bounce. Come back, nibble off a bit to take off the high spots, and start again.

robo hippy

Re: On 'turning air'

#17

Re: On 'turning air', Firmager tools *LINK*

Ronnyeelen

"Melvin has developed some unconventional grinds to be used without the bevel."

I know this is not the main subject of the thread, but I think I have to disagree with this statement. At least, partly. Agreed, Melvyn has unconventional grinds but I don't think they are used without using the bevel. Ok, except for 1, the scrapy gouge, but the name already explains it :)

With (supposed) permission you can check out the below link for an explanation of the Firmager tools. Very informational.

It is true that he doesn't teach to ride the bevel, but to offer the bevel to the wood, and no pushing against it.

And it works :D

have fun

Ronny


http://www.channelislandswoodturners.org/Firmager-Demo2007.htm

Re: On 'turning air'

#18

Lyle Jamieson

Agree, thanks for the clarification