I have made a couple of Jamison style deep hollowing tools, my largest is 1" diameter solid steel round bar...Is there a formula for bar diameter to depth of hollowing capability? I seem to be pushing the limit of the 1" diameter bar at about 11"-12"..I want to get to 28"-34" hollowing. What size bar is necessary before harmonic distortion causes loss of control over the tool rest?
I've gone 12+" deep with a 3/4" bar. I'm curious about what you describe as pushing the limits? I just slow down at that depth. It does vibrate, but with easy cuts and taking my time, I can keep a nice wall thickness. I do sharpen more at that depth, maybe that makes the difference. I also don't worried much about surface finish at that depth. Are you going to pierce so you can see the inside? What material did you use for the boring bar? I use drill rod, but don't harden it. I think it works better than cold rolled.
Sorry, no formula here, but my thinking is you should be able to go 16" at least with a 1" bar.
A lot depends upon the size of the cutter you are using. You can go deeper if you use a smaller cutter. I believe the experts suggest using a cutter ground from 3/16" square steel. Definitely no larger than 1/4" square.
To go way deeper, you will need a Big bar. I'll let someone else make suggestions along those lines. ~Doc
Take a look at the boring bar selection on The Sanding Glove website. They claim 33 inches over the tool rest but their design is a bit different than most. No affiliation.
I asked this question to a well known turner awhile back. He said that safely you can go to 6" with a 1/2" bar, 12" with a 3/4" bar, 18" with a 1" bar, 24" with a
1 1/4" bar as a general rule of thumb. He went on to say this varies somewhat with experience, application, type of wood, & form (shape of piece) but if you can error on a thicker bar.
I agree with Doc. I've done 14" with 3/4" bar but it was really slow going with small bites. I think 10 to 12" is reasonable. I took a 1 day class with Frank Sudol an we used 1 1/2" bars that weighted a ton. I hollowed to 12" with that without even breathing hard.
You might as Lyle Jameson about how far his big bar will hollow. It's pretty good size.
The Advanced Lathe Tools boring bars were developed by Steve Sinner and Jerry ("Sarge") Sargeant, specifically for very deep hollowing - their system is sold by Bruce Hoover at the Sanding Glove. The key to their system is that there are TWO 1-1/4" solid steel bars welded together which adds a lot of stability to the cutter that can achieve cuts well in excess of 24" over the rest. Because two thick bars are welded together, they provide sufficient resistance to vibration and good captive bar restraint from rotational torque of the cutter, and behave very well when doing deep hollowing without the need of the much wider Jamieson-style (D-handle) outrigger.
One of Steve's signature forms is a deeply-hollowed, amphora style vessel. He uses a Rolly Munro cutter at the end of the boring bar, and this hollowing method is safe and effortless - I have done it myself with this system (They were demonstrating their system at the Trade Show during the AAW Symposium in St. Paul last June).
The ratio I've heard and apply is 15 to 1. Not sure where that came from but as others have said it's typically necessary to go much slower at the limits.
Thanks for all your insights. I typically work with hardwoods, mesquite mostlyand central Texas walnut, and nearly always end grain. Don't know why I didn't think of "slowing down" a bit and "sharpening up" on the carbide cutters more often....always the simplest that escapes first! Sure do appreciate all the forums help
The stresses multiply themselves going that big. My Giant bar system (1 1/2 dia) will do close to 2 feet deep. To do 30+ inches will almost take a fork lift to handle the bar. Thats what Frank Sudol had. A 3 inch diameter 10 foot long bar. My jumbo bar (1 1/8 dia.) on my standard system will reach 16-17 inches over the tool rest without vibration under perfect circumstances.
I always suggest you stay within the tools capabilities. My caution is to sneek up on the scale in small incriments. I never, never go past the vibration point. Bad things can happen, its not worth the risk. It can get a bit dangerous. A huge chunk of wood that weighs over 100-200 pounds will not stop in a heart beat if something goes wrong. Bad things can happen with smaller pieces too, forcing a 3/4 bar past its limitations, past the vibration point. And its not fun!!
Also, the type and style of the cutter tip makes a big difference. If you have as small cutter coming right out of a 1" bar wit less than a 1/2" protrusion, you will get less chatter than a 1" bar with a swivel mounted 3/8" bar with a cutter on it.
Post a picture of the cutter end.
I have gone 22" off the toolrest with a 1" bar, but it takes more patience. And a steady rest on the turning piece will help immensely.
Rob is correct. I turn with Steve in his studio on a regular basis. I have personally hollowed several pieces 31" deep with no problems using his ( Advanced Lathe Tools LLC ) 1 1/4" dia. boring bars. We do use the Rolly Munro cutter in it which is easy to adjust the depth of cut on. We do take lighter cuts at those depths.
We also do use a steady rest every piece we hollow regardless of the size of the piece.
I have often wondered about the form stiffness of a square tube boring bar versus the traditional round bar. The cross section area, and presumably stiffness, in the direction of the stresses would be significantly higher than round. Adaptors from square to all the various cutter holders we use would be simple enough. If any one has tried square tubing I would like to hear your thoughts. I have this on my "bucket" list for future experiments. Ron.
I have used some (way back in the "beginning") might get ahold of James Johnson in Kerrvile, he has kinda been my mentor...he had some up to two inches by6-7 feet long;
James has some boring bars a lot bigger then that. The biggest bar I saw James use was 12 feet long if my memory serves me correctly.
From my unscientific experience (and remember I never hollow with vibration, and I have tested the limits of many tools for reach over the tool rest without vibration) I believe a solid round boring bar has the same reach capability as a square, thick walled, tubing of the same outside diameter, ie 1" to 1". I use the 1 1/2 inch, thick sided, square wall tubing for my "Giant" sytem because it has the same strength over the tool rest, but is lighter then, 1 1/2 inch diameter solid round. Square tubing comes in two varieties, thick walled and thin walled. My giant bar is constructed with a thick walled boring bar and a thin walled "D" shaped outrigger, again to keep the weight down and still have the reach I need.