Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Wednesday Turning Chat 12/14

Posts

Wednesday Turning Chat 12/14

#1

Wednesday Turning Chat 12/14

Stuart Johnson

Our topic will be critiques.

What is a critique? It's not just "good job" or "another nice one" said to feed an ego but should be an honest evaluation meant express an opinion and help the turner. What makes up a good critique and when should a piece be critiqued? If a photo of a piece is posted should that imply a request for a critique? We vary from the thin skined that takes personal offense at the slightest negative to those with skin so thick "just bury it with the cat litter" will just bring a grin and be taken as a compliment so how do we critique in a helpful, positive way?

See you Wednesday night at 9:30 eastern.

Re: Wednesday Turning Chat 12/14

#2

Re: Wednesday Turning Chat 12/14

john lucas

For those who are AAW members there was an excellent article in American Woodturner on the art of Critic. It was in the spring 2004 issue pg 52-55. I'm going to print in it out so I can re-read it. I don't know of a way to save the PDF of those pages. If your a member just go to the online journals and do a search for critic or simply look up that issue.

Re: Wednesday Turning Chat 12/14

#3

Jim's Critique *LINK*

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Maybe this is the one John.

Dave


Critique

Re: Wednesday Turning Chat 12/14

#4

Thanks Dave that's it. Good reading