Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Wobble after turning foot???

Posts

Wobble after turning foot???

#1

Wobble after turning foot???

Ron Bauer

Sorry, that may not explain my question. Are there any good ways to ensure that a turning will run true after reversing? I typically turn the outside of a vessel to final form then create a spigot at the tail end. When I reverse it and chuck it for the interior hollowing there invariably is wobble. Sometimes not to bad and others pretty bad. I think I use good chucks (Vicmarcs) and take care in truing the foot O.D. as the last operation but it still drives me nuts. Thanks in advance for your thoughts.

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

#2

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

john lucas

Ron there are several things that cause this. Are you turning a flat area at the top of the tenon so the top of the jaws have a place to register. This not only helps the bowl run true but also makes it less likely to rock and come out of the chuck.

wood compresses when you tighten the jaws. It also compresses differently on the end grain than the side grain. If you grab the wood with 2 jaws on the end grain and 2 jaws on the side grain it can easily pull out of alignment. What I try to do is to make the grain run 45 degrees through the chuck jaws. this means each jaw has a little side and a little end grain. It still doesn't guarantee perfect alignment but it sure helps.

Another thing that helps. I start my bowls between centers. this way I can adjust if the grain doesn't align or if some defect needs to be moved. anyway, it leaves a center mark in the open side of the bowl. when I chuck it up I tighten the jaws until they are snug but can still be moved. I bring up the tailstock and put it in the center mark. then I tighten the jaws. this really works well.

Last but not least, wood moves when you take away wood. sometimes no matter how much you try it just won't center. If it's really bad I just return the outside. If I can live with it I proceed as normal.

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

#3

Walt Bennett

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

Walt Bennett

Ditto what John said. Although I almost always use a recess instead of a tennon, I still encounter this issue that's just what wood is. Sometimes rotating the piece a bit will help. What helps is not turning all the way to what you want for finish. That way you've some 'wiggle room' to accommodate what can't be helped.

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

#4

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

Lyle Jamieson

I do two things much differently. It would be a radical change for you but I believe it is the best way to turn anything. I never use a chuck, the limitations drive me crazy so I dont have to deal with it. Second, I always do the entire piece on the same axis. I start between centers like john L suggested to get the grain and color balanced. I do not finish the bottom or outside shape, but only rough it out at this point. I make a slightly concave surface on the tailstock side to seat a faceplate or glue block. When I mount the faceplate now, in this manner, I can do both the outside and inside on the same axis. Never a wobble and the wall thickness is true for the entire circumference.

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

#5

And it's more solid  good suggestion


Re: Wobble after turning foot???

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

Brad Vietje

I do what John does (and Lyle) by turning the outer profile between centers, etc... Keeping the indentation from the tail center and using it to hold the piece with the tailstock while tightening the jaws will help eliminate almost all wobble.

For heavier or taller pieces, I'd use a faceplate, and for most of the small -med. pieces, I use a chuck. In addition to leaving a flat against which the tops of the jaws will register, you need to consider which particular set of jaws you are using.

For best results using your scroll chuck, you need to shape the tenon for the particular jaws in use. The common Vicmarc standard 2" jaws are much like the Supernova jaws -- the tenon needs to be a cylinder with a 1/8" 15-degree dovetail to match the inside of the jaws in compression. With other jaws, there would be other profiles.

Chuck jaws with "teeth" can be a different challenge, as each little ridge can crush or even tear the wood fibers a little differently. You may get better grip, but re-chucking something to run true is a major PITA. You can consider using "dovetail" or "smooth" jaws to eliminate most of this problem.

If you rough-turn the outside, like Lyle suggests, then hollow the vessel, and then go back to finish the outside, you can carefully approach final thickness from the outside, ideally with tail center support to keep it running true as you refine, sand, and finish the outer surface. You might be wise to retract the tailstock occasionally to make sure you're not getting too thin, or leave only the sanding and finishing till the end.

I start every piece between centers, which is where it is finished -- usually including turning away any chucking evidence, and turning details into the base of the foot.

Safe spinning and good luck,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

#7

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

Doc Green

Ron, if you are using a faceplate for the initial turning instead of turning between centers, leave the faceplate in place when you reverse it. Then use a cone center on the tailstock to engage the opening in the faceplate and force it against the chuck jaws while tightening.

After the blank is firmly mounted in the chuck, you can remove the faceplate. ~Doc

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

#8

BarbS

Aha!

BarbS

That is something I'd not thought of. And I needed it, just today. Thanks, Doc.

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

#9

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

robo hippy

There will almost always be some wobble. If your run out is 1/16 of an inch, that is + or - 1/32 of an inch. The only way this is noticeable without calipers is if you are turning down to 1/8 inch or so.

A couple of things I do. One is make sure there are no shavings or dust particles in the recess, tenon, or chuck jaws. A 1/32 inch thick shaving can make for a 1/8 inch wobble in a 12 inch bowl. Two is for the final cut on the seating surface, let the scraper (I use a dove tail scraper) rest just barely touching the wood. There is always a tiny bit of bump in the wood from the difference in how end grain and side grain cut. This feather light cut helps even some of that out.

Some times it is the chuck jaws. The screws do loosen up from time to time. Mostly you will notice this when you start getting a lot more wobble than normal.

I never use face plates. Just drill the proper sized recess in the top with a forstner bit.

robo hippy

Re: Wobble after turning foot???

#10

Ellis Walentine

Ditto