Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Easy wood tools

Posts

Easy wood tools

#1

Easy wood tools

Dennis Taylor

Anyone have any comments on the EWT? Seen Demo about 2 weeks ago, and think maybe it would be a good tool for the arsenal. I turn mostly small to medium sized items, mirrors/pens/platters. With Santa looking for items, thought maybe a mini tool would fill a need, whether that is a rougher or finisher I am not sure..... any input? Heard you can make the same tooling but not being a tool type maker person, makes it harder.... any input is appreciated and a thanks to all that reply.

Re: Easy wood tools

#2

Re: Easy wood tools

Fred Holder

About three years ago at the Desert Woodturning Roundup in Mesa, Arizona, I first saw the Easy Wood Tools. At that time he had two versions of the Easy Rougher. I purchased both of them after trying them. I subsquently purchased the Easy Finisher when it became available some time later. I've been turning since 1988 and can use any of the tools available. I use the Easy Rougher to make things round and then use a skew for spindles or a bowl gouge for bowls to finish turn.

I consider it a good tool, especially for roughing, although I've turned a complete bowl start to finish with the Easy Rougher and the Easy Finisher (a round cutter) to finish turn the inside. It takes a little bit coarser sandpaper if you use these tools totally.

There is no bevel rubbing. The tool is applied straight in on center line of the turning piece, and you never have to sharpen. You can rotate the cutter four times and then replace it.

I hope this helps you make your decision.

Re: Easy wood tools

#3

Steven Antonucci

What about the Hunters?

steven antonucci

I have seen the EWT and even used them once, and they work. I think that the Hunter's are more versatile because you can engage a bevel if you want, and the cutter is a disc with a small edge that is razor sharp. If you use that tool properly (i.e. bevel rubbing and in shear), you get a superior finish to a scraper. They cut like a micro hook tool.

I don't own either, but I have used both and prefer the Hunter style cutters.

Steve

Re: Easy wood tools

#4

Re: What about the Hunters?

John Lucas

I own both and play with them frequently. I agree with Steve. The new Hunter Hercules handles like a scraper so there is very little learning curve yet it leaves a clean finish. You can then turn it on edge and rub the bevel and get a very very clean surface. This part does take a learning curve but is well worth your time. You can tilt it so the top of the tool is facing the wood and use it like a shear scraper to fined tune your shapes or get rid of tearout. all of this with one tool.

I still like the Hunter #5 as one of my favorite tools.

Re: Easy wood tools

#5

Another player in the market *LINK*

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

These are made by my friend Don Thur. I have not used them yet, but Christmas is coming and I plan to get a couple to try out.

Full disclosure here... Don sell these unhandled and has listed me as one place to buy handles.

I am looking forward to trying them out.

Just another option.

Dave


Kilian tools

Re: Easy wood tools

#6

Don Leydens

Re: What about the Hunters?

Don Leydens

I have both tools also and once I got some Hunter tools I haven't used the other ones since. Steve nailed the description of them. I think the Hunter tools are far more versatile and I keep finding new uses for them. The Mini-Herc works GREAT on pens (wood and acrylic), for instance. As Steve said, riding the bevel produces a ridiculously smooth surface.

Re: Easy wood tools

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Easy wood tools

Lyle Jamieson

I will have an article in the December issue of the AAW Journal that I hope will help explain the differences between carbide.

I agree with Fred here about the Easy Tools, they are designed for roughing. The Easy Finisher is the same tool as the Easy Rougher only a different shape. They are both used in the scraping mode only. And if you have read any of my opinions you remember I don’t use scrapers. I think a slicing cut of a bowl gouge will be easier on my body and leave a better surface on the wood. I don’t like sanding so I don’t use scrapers much.

One of the topics that does not get enough press or thought is grain orientation and cutting/slicing with supported fibers. The direction I cut is ALWAYS dependent on the grain. This is huge, and necessary to get clean cuts and reduce sanding big time. Often the scraping mode requires you to, not only tear up the wood with the scraping action, but requires you to go the wrong way to the grain or get a catch. Now you have double damage to the torn out grain, (1) scraping and (2)going the wrong way against the grain.

Re: Easy wood tools

#8

Don't Forget *LINK*

Barbara Gill

The new Kelton Multi Axis Scraper.


Kelton

Re: Easy wood tools

#9

Mike Stafford

Re: What about the Hunters?

Mike Stafford

I have found the Herc to be even more versatile if you ride the bevel. You can rough out the exterior of a bowl and as you approach the finished shape you can drop the handle and start riding the bevel to get wispy thin shavings that will remove all of the tearout. Mike Hunter and I turned a lot of soft European birch that was very prone to tear out but we could clean up the tearout to a point where the wood almost looked polished.

I was also amazed at how thin I could turn pieces with the Herc. Sanding was greatly reduced using the bevel riding technique. Another technique which I learned from Terry Scott was to turn the cutter upside down and shear scrape with the bottom edge. It is not unlike using the bowl gouge to shear scrape a surface. The frog's hair curlies that came off the wood were proof of how smooth the surface was.

The mini-Herc is da bomb!!! I am finding more and more uses for this tool. One of the problem areas for me is the shaping of the end grain in the lid. Using a gouge I can push or pull the jam fitted lid off the box when I am shaping it. I can also burnish the end grain with the heel of the gouge if I am not careful. However with the mini-Herc I can cleanly slice the end grain and greatly reduce sanding which is another thing end grain does not necessarily like.

Is there a learning curve associated with the Hunter tools? Absolutely; but their versatility and extremely sharp edges make the effort to learn 100% worthwhile. If you want to reduce your sanding learn to use the surgically sharp edges of a Hunter cutter.

Re: Easy wood tools

#10

Dick Hines

Re: Don't Forget

dick hines

I am not much of a scraper user. That being said I will use one on the inside of a box and when all else fales I have a big one I use in the bottom of bowls when I can't seem to get the bottom just right.

When I first started turning, in the 60's scrapers were the tool to use for bowls. After I started turning again in the mid 90's I found the bowl gouge. If some one took my bowl and detail gouges away from me I would just start fishing more and truning way less.

Re: Easy wood tools

#11

Re: Don't Forget

Carole Valentine

I was never much of a scraper user either and I had tried a lot of them and I found them pretty useless. I will have to say that I am a convert now with this tool, especially on larger bowls and platters where no matter how careful I am with a gouge, on those long continuous cuts I always seem to end up with with some sort of little undulation somewhere along the line. No more. One or two passes with that scraper and it's perfectly smooth all the way. I always use it in a shearing mode with a tiny bit of negative rake and just a tiny burr. I have found that if I can actually feel the burr it's too much, but it should easily take a shaving off my thumbnail. I can usually start sanding at 220, which for me is great since I do not consider sanding to be fun part of the process.

Oh, and that detail gouge? Remember when you first got yours, Dick? ;) As much as I love it, that little dude still gets me and goes on a skate around the rink once in a while! LOL

Re: Easy wood tools

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: Don't Forget

Mike Stafford

Carole, you really have to see Richard Raffan use a scraper to appreciate the finish that can be obtained with one.

Having had the opportunity to see him turn at length this year I am amazed at how wonderful a scraper can be. I have been dragging my scrapers out and applying what I have learned.

Richard says, "I feel sorry for people who don't know how to use scrapers."

Re: Easy wood tools

#13

Dick Hines

Re: Don't Forget

dick hines

Caorle, it you are not rubbing the bevel the detail gouge will take off where IT wants to go.

Re: Easy wood tools

#14

Re: What about the Hunters?

John Leonard

John, where do you get the hercules tool. I didn't find it in either the Craft Supplies or the Packerd catalog? Thanks John L.

Re: Easy wood tools

#15

Re: What about the Hunters?

Chuck Bjorgen

You can get the Hercules directly from Mike Hunter. Click on the Marketplace link, upper left, and go to Hunter Tool Systems. It's the first tool in the products list.

Re: Easy wood tools

#16

Re: What about the Hunters?

John Leonard

Thanks. John L.

Re: Easy wood tools

#17

Re: Don't Forget

Carole Valentine

Mike,

I would love to see Richard and many other demonstrators. One of these days, maybe! I will have to agree that there are times when nothing but a good scraper like the MA, properly applied, will accomplish what's needed. And it is often the easiest and quickest way for me to take off those "angel hair" finish shavings on the inside of a bowl or platter.

Dick,

Yeah, I am well aware of what causes my detail gouge to go off on a trip of it's own, but that doesn't mean that I don't still have to "redesign" a bead once in a while! LOL

Re: Easy wood tools

#18

Re: What about the Hunters?

Ron Bauer

I am curious to hear Lyle's explanation of how a "surgically" sharp edge is formed on cemented carbide cutters. I was not aware that it was possible to get that sharp.

Re: Easy wood tools

#19

Re: What about the Hunters?

steve worcester

I am not Lyle, and I would say surgically sharp is subjective here. Carbides don't have a burr, as you could get with a HSS tool. But, a Hunter tool is sharper than any other carbide tools I have used, it will cut you if poked or mishandled.

I have used Craigs tools and by his own admittance, they are designed for people who want to learn to turn with a shorter learning curve. The tools do scrape and leave a surface the same as a really sharp scraper, more tear out than a tool that cuts vs scrapes, but you can poke it and remove wood, that simple.

The Hunter tools do cut, the insert has a gullet (chip breaker in metal working terms) and presents a very sharp and polished edge to the wood. In most situations you are not riding a bevel, but because of the shear angle, you are cutting, not scraping, like an unsupported bevel in a gouge, maybe.

In the spirit of full disclosure, I am a Hunter Tools dealer (at least the #1s and Hercules) but only sell them unhandled.

Steve Worcester

WWW.TURNINGWOOD.COM

Re: Easy wood tools

#20

Lyle Jamieson

Re: What about the Hunters?

Lyle Jamieson

The Hunter, nanograin carbide tools are manufactured under high heat and high pressure. The sharpness is superior due to the finer particulate that it is made out of. This manufacturing process is why they can not be re-sharpened. They will never get back to the factory produced degree of sharpness. It is necessary to discard when they wear out or get chipped. They are very economical to use, as a disposable, because they will last so long and I have a way to get use of all 360 degrees.

Re: Easy wood tools

#21

Re: What about the Hunters?

Ron Bauer

Steve, Thank you. That is exactly the explanation I was looking for. The Hunters and a similar cutter found at The Carbide Depot (mentioned elsewhere) do cut and shear vs scrape. Lyles explanation that the Hunters are from nanograin carbide explains how they approach "surgically" sharp. I am experimenting with making holders that safely present the round cutters at various angles to the piece. This permits taking a very aggressive cut when desired or presenting the same tool in a differant way and cutting "angels hair". I have had very good success "deep" hollowing.

Re: Easy wood tools

#22

Re: What about the Hunters?

steve worcester

The other thing about a carbide insert for woodturning is that it must have a fine edge and polished all the way across the top. This is primarily for chip ejection, but "fine" is part of the part# break down in the ANSI insert designation.

I was doing some research last year to make a carbide shear scraper for woodturning and went through a whole lot of different inserts in my attempt. I never found anything suitable and went to Thompson and had them made instead, but did end up doing some work with Hunter and became a dealer.

One of the items often overlooked is the pocket and the screw that the insert is fastened down with. Use the wrong screw or a pocket that doesn't match the profile and you can end up shattering the insert

Re: Easy wood tools

#23

Lyle Jamieson

Re: What about the Hunters?

Lyle Jamieson

Good point, Steve. That is why these cutters are so expensive. (But its worth it!!) They take a highly machined pocket and the tapered torx screw is pricy. This is necessary for proper use. It is not something most home built techniques can handle. I certainly would not want the cutter to come loose or break under the load of cutting. That could be nasty.