Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OT Thickness Planner Advice

Posts

OT Thickness Planner Advice

#1

OT Thickness Planner Advice

Steve Criscenzo

30 years ago I purchased an INCA joiner/planner. It has served me well but the feed on the thickness planner has died and I cannot find the parts. It may be time to get a new planner.

Does anyone have any experience with portable planners such as the Dewalt.

Thanks

Steve

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#2

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

Fred Holder

I've had a Dewalt 733 (I think that is the number) Planer for about 10 years. I don't do much flat work, but when I need it, it does the trick. Before I purchased it, I managed to look at all of the models this size and the Dewalt won out.

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#3

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

John Lucas

I have the newer Dewalt 735 and I highly recommend it. Everything works very nice. The blade changes are very easy, they have 2 sides and aren't too expensive. It has two speeds for finer cuts but I never use the slower speed. The difference in cut quality is very hard to discern and the fast speed certainly does a good job.

It has very little if any snipe at the ends and that's without the optional extension tables. It really is an improvement over my older Delta 12" model.

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#4

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

Barry Irby

I also have the previous version of the Dewalt and like it. The version John has (735) has 3 knives instead of two. The Tools and Shop Version of Fine Woodworking Just ran a test on the spiral cutter heads. That might be even better. This was the machine they used as the bench mark and changed out the heads in two others to compare. I would love to have one of the spiral heads.

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#5

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

carl civitella

I have the DW 735. You can`t beat the extra boost you get with dust collection. It does an outstanding job in planeing. Carl

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#6

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

John Lucas

I've looked at the spiral heads. They are very expensive. I am getting a really clean cut now so don't see the need. However if you used this tool a lot the longer blade life of the spiral heads might pay off. I have no experience with them but can't help but believe it would cut cleaner in squirly grain, but at almost half the cost of the planer itself it's a pretty major investment.

The dust collection chute is positioned wrong. I purchased a 90 degree section of metal pipe to install on it so my dust collection hose can go off to the side. The fan in the dust collector of the planer is so powerful you could probably get by with running a 4 or 5 foot hose from the chute into a garbage can instead of your dust collector. The hose fell off my planer one time and shavings flew all the way across the room. What a mess.

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#7

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

Grant Wilkinson

I have the Dewalt 735, too. It does a great job with the existing head. John hit the dust collection issue on the nose. Attaching a dust collection hose to it means the hose obstructs the outfeed. A right angle fitting fixes that. I can't agree with John on the knives,though. They are very pricey and don't last long enough. This has been the subject of many threads on other boards. At one time, Dewalt talked about improving the life span of the blades, but I don't think they did. Like others, I complained and Dewalt sent me a couple of free sets. There are now aftermarket blades available. The biggest downside is that the blades cannot be sharpened. They fit onto pins on the head and so, the clearances are very small. You can hone them to get a bit more life out of them, but they are disposable blades. You cannot sharpen them, then move them out on the head to compensate for the lost metal.

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#8

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

Don Evans

I've got the DW735 also and it is a great planer especially for hobby persons. I don't think the spiral head is worth the price unless perhaps you are making money just planing boards with it. The same thing happened to me regarding the fan. I had just got it and wanted to see it work but didn't have it connected to the cyclone so I said to myself "oh one little 3 foot board cannot be that bad" and ran it through. It threw chips about 15 or more feet across the shop! I didn't run it again until I got it connected to the Oneida.

I don't have a jointer anymore so I made a jointer bed to use in the planer to flatten one side of cupped or twisted, warped boards, just got to use it first time last week and it works great.

I took the worse warped board I could find, cupped some also, used it to test the bed and it came out with first side flat after running it through 3 times taking 1/32" off each time. You then set the bed aside and run board through with new flat side down to flatten the other side. It worked great and I still had over 1/2" board, it was a previously dressed 3/4" board, cherry.

This is the size range I use for my stuff 1/2" mostly, cannot handle (physically) the big boards for furniture etc anymore so this works great for me.

The bed sled for doing this was in Fine Woodworking couple of years ago. It can still be found on their wed site.

It was designed by a guy last name of "Rust".

Don

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#9

Walt Bennett

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

Walt Bennett

I've a 7 year old Craftsman bench top that was top rated back then, but that was before the Dewalt 735 came out. It's served me well, but I'm only using occasionally. I'd certainly go with yellow if I were getting one today.

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#10

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

john lucas

I think I paid $38 for my latest set of blades. I don't use the planer a whole lot and get pretty good life out of them. I don't remember the exact price of the spiral head but think it was getting close to $300. If I was using the planer in a business it would easily be worth that because it would pay itself back in a few years. for my limited use I can easily get a year or more out of these blades so it would take a while to equal the cost of the spiral head.

That being said I would love to try one out. I don't plane a lot of figured woods but do get some pretty twisted grain ones that tend to tearout unless you feed the board at an angle. My understanding is the spiral head will eliminate this.

And of course if you have spare cutters you can use them on your EWT when the original cutter gets dull. :)

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#11

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

Grant Wilkinson

That's a great price, John. Up here, they are closer to $80 a set. Like you, I don't believe that it would be cost effective to put the spiral head in it. The last time I looked, it was closer to $400 to get one from the US here, taxes in. Even with high blade prices, it's likely that something else would pack up in the planer before I would break even.

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#12

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

Bob Lalonde

Steve, I have the Delta 13" which was supposed to be a big improvement over the 12" but would not recommend it though. I get tear out on any cut and any species over 1/32", significant snipe on the outfeed side and now the feed is acting up. Like most of the others, I do little flatwork but want my tools to work properly when I need them. Bob.

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

Keith Tompkins

I agree with everyone about the DeWalt. I wouldn't bother with the spiral cutterheads....too much time involved rotating the cutters. I use an Oliver Strait-O-Planer on my day job...one spiral head on top, one on the bottom. It mills both top and bottom at once.... Two 25 HP motors. It takes two days to sharpen the cutters, on the machine with a special attachment. The machine can mill over 40,000 board feet between sharpenings!

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#15

Re: Thanks All

Steve Criscenzo

Thanks for the thoughts everyone. Like many turners, I was heavy into flat work until I started turning six years ago. Do very little flat work now.

I have a load of rough cherry and oak that I still use to the occasional cabinet and I use the planner to clean up resawn wood that I use to make laminated blanks. I am also playing with segmented turning and I figure a new planner would be useful for making stock for that as well. So no really heavy use but I want something that I do not have to fight with.

I was looking hard at the DW735 but the reviews are mixed and at both extremes. Some love it and some hate it, mostly because of blade life and stripped screws while changing blades. From the input here, sounds like most folks are OK with it so I may go that way.

Thanks again for you advice.

Steve

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

#16

Re: OT Thickness Planner Advice

Scott Vanzo

Did you contact Jesse at Eagle Tools in Glendale CA for the Inca parts? He's the man for all things Inca.

Thirty years is a great run, but perhaps you can keep it going...