Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Drozda-esque Lidded Box

Posts

Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#1

Drozda-esque Lidded Box

charlie belden

Been playing with the proportions of Cindy Drozda's "Onion Finial". Having drawn several - to scale - using the proportions I worked out from an example in her drozda_fiinals.pdf handout, finials must've been floating around in my head.

Around 2 AM, my Muse woke me up with an idea for a piece. Why do a lidded box and put a finial ON it - when - you can have a finial - with a box IN it?

The idea rattled around in my head and wouldn't go away. So I got up, got on my Mac Mini and opened up the Drozda Proportions spreadsheet. With all the proportions worked out as equations it was easy to derive the necessary height required for a 3" diameter "box" in the "bulb" of the "onion". Came out to be 15".

Opened up SketchUp and , using 15" as the height, constructed the profile from the spread sheet derived values for the control points, added the "top to bottom fit" details, spun the top and bottom profiles to create the two parts, then colored each - black outside, gold foil inside.

Here's the Sketch Up construction. The hollow in the base is for adding molten lead - to weight the "box" so it won't tip over


And here's the Finial Box, again from a screenshot of the SketchUp model.


Now all I need is to work our the Between Centers and Chucking sequence - and find a piece of dry wood that's 3 3/4" square and 16" tall.

A variation of Thinking Outside The Box - Thinking INSIDE The Finial.

Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#2

BarbS

Ah Charlie, you are Wonderful!


Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#3

Charlie...You Do Have Fun at 2 AM!!


Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#4

Why Not 2 Boxes In A Finial?

charlie belden

A 3" O.D. box requires a 15" tall "Finial" for it. At that scale, a second "box", 1" I.D., can be done in the "tip" of the finial, perfect for a pearl or two - or maybe a few loose diamonds ; )


Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#5

Ellis Walentine

Now I'm thinking Christmas presents

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for the inspiration, Charlie. Remind me to learn how to use Sketch-Up, too.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Why Not THREE Boxes In A Finial?

Brad Vietje

Hey Charlie,

Great ideas -- as always! So why not 3 boxes, one might ask? I've seen a conical box form in Raffan's book, as well as a few examples of decorated conical jewelry boxes in Michael & Liz O'Donnell's book, Decorating Turned Wood. I can't locate an image just now, but maybe someone can post that.

Maybe a "Jewelry Tower" of some sort...?

I think you're onto something here, Charlie.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#7

Aage Rendalen

Your generosity appreciated

Aage Rendalen

Thanks for sharing this with us. There are some turners who view everything they do as trade secrets to be guarded jealously for maximum personal glory and gain. I greatly appreciate that you're willing to share so unselfishly your own ideas with us.

Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#8

Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

gary clarke

Great idea, thanks for sharing, you the man. 8 )

Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#9

Re: Why Not 2 Boxes In A Finial?

Bernie Weishapl

Charlie wish you would keep your idea's to yourself now I gotta go try one. Charlie those would be pretty cool.

Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#10

very cool, Charlie...

GaryG in MD

Great idea.

I get a lot of mine at 0200 too! ...GG

Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#11

Re: Why Not THREE Boxes In A Finial?

charlie belden

Lidded boxes are interesting design problems. If the lid fits too snug, two hands are required to open the box and may take some tugging and twisting. If the lid fits too loose, the parts can come out of alignment and the joint may be too obvious. Having the lid fall off when someone picks up the piece to examine the bottom can be a problem as well.

Stacked lidded boxes aren't anything new. And if they're cylindrical, holding the parts in order to turn them is no big deal, though it does require some planning for the sequence of chucking.

Stacked lidded boxes that are tapered are a bit trickier because each "box & lid set" must be turned together in order to "blend" them together. And that's where the fun comes in. The more boxes in the stack, the trickier it can become.

With this boxes in a finial form idea, doing multiple boxes can be even trickier since chucking thin walled parts can result in crushing - or splitting. There's also the matter of thin areas being torqued too much and twisting off while turning things - hollowing or thinning.

But since you mentioned space for a third box in this finial thing . . .


I've included a cross section,which, in SketchUp, is "spun" around a circular path created below the profile and it's Center Line to create the 3D finial.

Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#12

wrong photo Charlie 


Re: Drozda-esque Lidded Box

#13

Re: wrong photo Charlie 

charlie belden

I previewed my message to make sure I got the 3 Boxes Finia image. Apparently, WC's server hiccupped.

Here's the RIGHT image (I hope_