Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

piercing

Posts

piercing

#1

piercing

Barry Scotton

I am trying some piercing using my dremel. I am wanting some thing more efficient other than air powered. micro motors that run at 50000 rpm seem likely candidates. Ram, optima, woodcarver pro are some I am considering. Do any of you have experience with these brands or others ? All comments greatly appreciated.

Barry

Re: piercing

#2

Lyle Jamieson

Re: piercing

Lyle Jamieson

The trick is to get the vessel thin, really thin, so you dont need more power in an electric tool but more RPM. Most people that do any volume of piercing use the 400,000-500,000 RPM dental type units. The hand pieces are very small and light. It gets really stressful on your hands and arms if the wall thickness fights you. When you get down to about 3/32 inch it is just like writing with a pencil. Thats the thickness of two playing cards. It can take days and days to do some of the intricate work being done. You would get really frustrated using the larger slower rotary tools.

Re: piercing

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: piercing *LINK*

Rob Wallace

One of the top-of-the-line brands are the micro-motor units from NSK. Wish I could afford one, but not in the cards at present. J. Paul Fennell and Andi Wolfe use them routinely, and say they are excellent units. See the link at Treeline below.

I have a Powercrafter, and it is correct that they don't have a lot of torque but super high rpm only. It is not really good for carving, per se, and it is OK for piercing things that are fairly thin. Excellent for adding detail and engraving. Wish I would have bought an NSK air-powered high-speed tool instead of the Powercrafter - the NSK is what Binh Pho uses, and is a better quality unit. Live and learn.

Rob


NSK Micromotor unit at Treeline

Re: piercing

#4

Re: piercing

John Lucas

Barry My experience is limited with the 50K handpieces but I don't believe they cut the wood any better than the Dremel although they are smaller and more comfortable to hold. The cutter still want to grab the grain and pull itself in.

The 400K handpieces are like writing on paper. The don't follow the grain at all. Lyle is dead on. This is essential. When I helped Binh Pho with his class my first piece was a goblet. I turned the goblet body very thin, maybe 1 1/2 to 2mm. It was easy to pierce with the 400K tool. However I left the foot about 3/16 or maybe 3mm thick. Although the tool didn't try to follow the grain it took 3 or 4 times as long to cut each hole. It tired out your hand where the thin wood was pretty relaxing.

The Walnut piece I posted in the last 2 weeks is about 2mm at the top where the piercing is. It was very tiring trying to pierce it with the Dremel. I also tried a 50K air powered hand piece and it wasn't any better.

One difference in the two is the slower cutters don't burn the wood. The 400 K leaves black edges although I'm told you can run the cutter around the hole cutting in the direction of spin and clean up that edge. I'll have to try that if I ever by one.

Re: piercing

#5

Re: piercing

Wally Dickerman

I tried piercing using the Dremel tool and quickly decided that it wouldn't do the job. I talked to Binh Pho at a symposium and he sold me an NSK Presto unit. That's what he uses. I also bought his DVD which has been a big help. I have also been buying my burrs and drills from Binh. Binh is also very good about sharing advice.

The NSK tool runs at around 350,000 rpm and of course is air driven. I have done a fair amount of piercing and am completely satisfied with the NSK. To do the piercing the piece must be turned to 1/16th in wall thickness. Any more than that and you'll have problems. I found that the learning curve was quite small. I make a lot smoke when piercing so I use a fan setup to carry the smoke away just I do when doing pyrography. At those high speeds the needle or burr is burning the wood.

There are various burrs available to fit the tool so it's very good for certain types of texturing which opens up a lot of possibilities when used along with the piercing.

Re: piercing

#6

Re: piercing

Mike Foster

Barry, I use all of the above in my work and what you use depends on what your desired result is and the effort needed to get the result. I am a dentist, so have all the gear used in our profession. At my carving station I have the following available, high speed dental handpieces that run 300000 rpm or so, low speed dental handpieces (air driven) that run about 50,000 rpm, old belt driven slow speed dental hand piece that runs around 30,000 rpm, dremel and a Foredom. I will use the tool that suits what I am trying to do, but often will use them all on one piece. I usually use the high speed handpieces for piercing, but like others have said, they tend to burn and leave a charred, black wall. If you don't like this (and I often don't) you can remove the char using some dental diamond burs and a very light touch with the hand piece. Often some others will use diamond rifflers to remove the char, but I find this way too slow and not very effective. The slower speed handpieces could do the piercing, but you would find that it would take a heavier hand, and probably would end up burning the wood as well. I will often use diamond burs in the slower speed units (50,000) to clean up the char. That works pretty well. Hope this helps some rather than confuses.

Re: piercing

#7

Re: piercing

Dick Wilson

Barry,

I would love to have a NSK but can't justify the expense simply because I do not do that much piercing. Lyle is spot-on when he says the thinner the wall thickness the easier it is. Personally I use a Dremel with Roto-zip tile cutting bits. It does require that you pre-drill a starter hole AND you will never be able to do really fine piercing work the likes of Wolfe or Fennell.

Re: piercing

#8

Re: piercing

Wally Dickerman

Hey Dick, when you sell your first pierced and textured piece for substantial money that'll pay for the NSK tool.....

Re: piercing

#9

Re: piercing

Dick Wilson

Wally, Of course the big IF and WHEN is if I sell one ;)

Re: piercing

#10

Re: piercing

Hal Taylor

As others have said turning thin is a must for piercing, but a caution - you can too thin. If it's too thin the wood becomes brittle and breaks too easily. Also, I prefer a dental handpiece. I have used others, but I cannot seem to carve in an upright perpendicular position. I get better control and precision with the position of the dental handpiece. Another plus is these are less expensive.