Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Tung Oil Question

Posts

Tung Oil Question

#1

Tung Oil Question

Bernie Weishapl

I have a question for all you who use Tung Oil as a finish. I got some of the Tung Oil and Tung Oil sealer from Lee Valley. They sell it under their name for Sutherland-Welles. Anyway my question is when I called both of them they told me not to sand more than 220 grit or the tung oil won't penetrate very well. I have always sanded bowls, HF, etc at least to 320 or 400 grit. How far do you sand when using Tung Oil? Wasn't really satisfied with the sanding stopping at 220. I mean it doesn't look to bad but you can see a couple sanding lines in small spots and this is a Ash bowl I am finishing. Maybe I am being to picky. Anyway your thoughts would be appreciated.

Re: Tung Oil Question

#2

Ken Vaughan

Re: Tung Oil Question

Ken Vaughan

Bernie --

I think that is a legend from years past for flat work. There was a long standing debate between the fine surface prep and less fine surface prep. More courrently the advise is to use finer abrasives on end grain and seal it with a conditioner to avoid shade difference between grain orientation.

I have used oil finishes a lot and find that a surface conditioner (aka sanding sealer) of a thinned lacquer (1/3 deft and 2/3 lacquer reducer) followed by non woven pad provides a nice oil surface finish.

Burnishing the surface is not desirable, but 600/800 grit seems to work fine.

Russ had some good commentary on oil finishes that I re-read from time to time.

(Went back to Russ's Corner and checked - he used thinned Tung Oil for the first coat and liked to sand to 400 grit)

Re: Tung Oil Question

#3

Re: Tung Oil Question

Bernie Weishapl

Thanks Ken. I hadn't thought of looking at Russ's corner. I have read his stuff a couple of times. Just went back and reread his oil finish part. I appreciate the help.

Re: Tung Oil Question

#4

Re: Tung Oil Question

Bill Howatt

I know a lot of turners that go much higher than 400 with tung oil. I consider the drying products like the polymerized tung oil to be more of surface treatement like a vanish than a penetrating, non-drying oil finish. In other words, I don't care if it doesn't penetrate a lot.

Bill

Re: Tung Oil Question

#5

Walt Bennett

Re: Tung Oil Question

Walt Bennett

I've used tung oil almost exclusively for over six years, and sand at least to 800 grit, usually to 1200. Never had a problem with penetration, but have with curing times. I didn't like the big-box chain versions and obtained a gallon of completely natural from The Real Milk Paint Co. While it is a very light yellow and pleasant to work with, it'll take a week to cure. I settled on a 50/50 mixture of it with Waterlox original. Waterlox has way too much accelerator, but this blend hardens in about an hour and completely cures overnight.

Re: Tung Oil Question

#6

Re: Tung Oil Question

Wally Dickerman

Regarding penetration of the Daly's tung oil finish that I use, well it does. Before applying finish on the outside of a HF I put a generous amount on the inside and turn on the lathe. In a minute or so, some of the oil has penetrated through the wood and is on the outside. Can't penetrate much better than that.

I sand to 600 and sometimes, depending on the wood, to 1500.

Re: Tung Oil Question

#7

Re: Tung Oil Question

Bernie Weishapl

Thanks for the replies. I do appreciate the info. It is very helpful. So Walt you mix pure Tung Oil and Waterlox 50/50 for your finish? I do have some Waterlox and may give that a try. How many coats do you apply?

Re: Tung Oil Question

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Tung Oil Question

Jesper, Denmark

A universal truth about surface preparation before putting on any surface treatment is that any blemishes show up much better AFTER you put on the finish.

The penetration of the surface finish happens at near molecular size level, so no matter how fine you sand, it is not going to interfere with penetration of any liquid into the wood.

So, sand to a level that satisfies your idea of quality before putting on any finish. You can accelerate penetration of tung oil by dilution with a solvent of your choice - I prefer real turpentine - or by adding heat to reduce the tung oil viscosity by holding a rag on the spinning item.

Tung and linseed oils are both oxydation hardening, so rags soaked with those need careful disposal to avoid fire risks. I prefer to soak the used rags in water and dispose in a closed plastic bag.

Re: Tung Oil Question

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tung Oil Question

Keith Tompkins

Hi Bernie, I use tung oil on many pieces, and I sand to very fine grits. I don't use sanding sealer, which is a surface coating. When the sanding sealer begins to flake off, what happens to the tung oil? I wipe the oil on and let it sit a few minutes...then wipe completely dry. It takes several treatments to achieve the finish I want. Sometimes, I'll add a bit of polyurethane to the tung oil, but still wipe dry. Leaving a wet coat just doesn't work for me, and often doesn't dry properly.

Re: Tung Oil Question

#10

Walt Bennett

Re: Tung Oil Question

Walt Bennett

Depends on the wood and the look I desire - usually two or three. Even with thorough wiping after fifteen minutes or so, too many coats will stop penetrating and build up. At a show once, a lady picked up one of my smaller bowls that had a thick finish, tapped her long artificial nails on it, then said: "This is plastic, it's not wood!" My wife about had a laughing fit!

Re: Tung Oil Question

#11

Walt Bennett

Re: Tung Oil Question

Walt Bennett

I just toss used wet rags on a corner of my driveway (separate, not in a pile) and let them cure before putting them in the trash. Never have had to do anything more.

Re: Tung Oil Question

#12

Re: Tung Oil Question

Bernie Weishapl

Thanks again for all the info. I appreciate all the answers. Walt that was one of the things that got me was I had a lady do the same thing. Tapped with her finger nail and asked why I covered that beautiful wood in plastic. That got me to thinking. Dangerous I know. Going to turn a couple more today and will sand to where I normally do then apply the tung oil. Jesper I had another gentleman told me to sit the can of tung oil in some warm water. He said that would warm the tung oil and it would penetrate better. I have a lidded metal trash can a few feet outside the shop I put my finish towels in. When dry I discard them. Keith I will give it a try wiping dry till I achieve what I want for a finish. I normally do that with Antique oil but it still will build a glossy surface finish.

Re: Tung Oil Question

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tung Oil Question

Keith Tompkins

HI Bernie, The thing I like about wiping off the finish is that there are no streaks, dust, etc. in the finish...yes, you can build up a nice polished look if desired as well.

Re: Tung Oil Question

#14

Re: Tung Oil Question

Bernie Weishapl

Thanks again Keith. I did put two coats of the tung oil sealer on first. This morning I just put the lee valley tung oil finish on. I let it sit for about 10 minutes and wiped it down. I just went out and looked at it and I like what I see. Has a warm pick me up look compared to the Antique Oil one sitting next to it. I think two coats and it will be where I want it. I am thinking also instead of buying the sealer and the finish that I will just buy the finish and thin it with mineral spirits if I need it.