Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

Posts

Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#1

Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

charlie belden

Probably because of all my training in engineering that sets me looking for Underlying Principles when it comes to design - and other things. I look for reasons why one design works looks right while another very similar design doesn't.

Going through the log of the chat with Cindy Drozda, and the "drozda_finials.pdf" file that the chat linked to, got me analyzing the illustrated example in the pdf file. Copied the illustration into a primitive CAD program that would let me scale values, and used a spreadsheet to play with the scaled values - and relationships between critical dimensions of a Drozda Finial. Not surprising, I found FOURTEEN critical dimensions, and they all can be derived from the finials HEIGHT.

While the Golden Ratio (1:1.618) plays a major role, "3rds", "4ths" and "5ths" are used for the minor details. The "3rds" and "5ths" were expected. The "4ths" was a bit of a surprise.

I've done an Excel spread sheet that lets me specify a finial height and calculates each of the critical dimensions. Found that working in millimeters was easier than working with fractional or decimal inches, but the spread sheet doesn't care what units you start with.

Here's the illustration and the formulas for calculating each critical dimension. If there's interest in the spread sheet, I can put it on my WWing site and post a link to it.


Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#2

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

Barbara

Charlie,

You are amazing!!!!

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#3

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

Bill Noce in Northeast Ohio

Unbelievable Charlie....

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#4

What a special talent!  Thank You, Charlie


Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#5

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

Peter Hyde

Mmmmm. How come L4 has 2 different values?

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#6

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

Joe Donohue

Charlie, I for one would appreciate a link to the excel file.

Thanks

Joe Donohue

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#7

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

David Walser

What's really amazing is that Drozda does all those calculations in her head!

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#8

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

gary clarke

It would be interesting to measure several of her finials and see if they all fit the equations. I am not an engineer or math major so I leave it to someone more qualified.

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#9

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

I think Cindy would be thoroughly amused!

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#10

REVISED Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

charlie belden

Peter Hyde asked "Mmmmm. How come L4 has 2 different values? "

Answer: Variables numbering scheme error.

Another example of the benefits of Peer Review

Here's the REVISED (read "corrected") illustration with equations. Note that the number under each varialble is its Scaled Off The Original Example length, in millimeters (mm), rounded to the nearest whole millimeter.

There are 25.4 mm per inch so 1 mm = 0.039". As a reference, 1/32" = 0.03125"


Here's a comparison of the calculated values (calc'd) vs scaled (from the original drawing). As you can see, the calc'd values, with the exception of D1, all are within +/1 one millimeter of the scaled values - for a 7 1/8" tall finial. The shorter the finial the smaller the differences become.

Note that the intent of all this stuff is to get you CLOSE to the proportions Cindy has developed for her finials.


Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#11

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

charlie belden

That's the difference between an engineer and an artist. The artist can see if something "looks right", usually based on a LOT of experience. The engineer can only work out the proportions of something the artist provides. The math is easy. The refined sense of what looks right ain't.

Cindy Drozda has, with a lot of trial and error and a lot of thought, developed a refined sense of what "looks right" and what doesn't. And that's something she stressed in her Chat Session - doing ten or more versions of an idea allows the idea to be refined. Having done probably several hundred of her elegant finials, she has refined them to the Nth degree.

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#12

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

charlie belden

No good deed goes unpunished.

I've started collecting images of different Drozda finials. Finding good profile shots may take some time. I'm betting that the the Golden Ratio will be major factor in the proportions, with 3rds, 4ths and 5ths playing a role in the proportions if the details. The Search For Secrets will use the same approach as used for this first cut at discovering them.

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#13

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

charlie belden

If all this results in just a smile of amusement - it's worth the effort, Anything beyond that is gravy.

If nothing else, I hope this stuff gets a few people to start planning things a bit more rather than chucking up a piece of wood and see where things go as the chips fly. I've been Wingin' It most of the time. But for certain pieces - like lidded vessels with a finial, I'll be doing a bit more planning.

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#14

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Me, too, Charlie. Thanks.

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#15

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

charlie belden

Cindy is the one who worked out the elegant proportions of her finials and I'm certain a lot of time and effort went into developing the fundamentals and then refining the form to the n'th degree.

All I did was find the critical points and work out their numeric relationships to the height of the finial. And I suspect that the finial height is determined by its relationship to the piece it will crown, probably using the Golden Ratio (1:1.61803398874989484820 - though 1: 1.618 is close enough) - the vessel height probably the "1.618" and the finial being "1" - or the other way round.

Interesting little side note

1/1.618 = 0.618

which happens to be what you get when you subtract 1 from 1.618 (1.618 - 1 = 0.618)

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#16

Real vs Ideal

charlie belden

I found a photo of one of Cindy's pieces with a finial and compared that Actual finial with the Ideal finial in her drozda_finials.pdf handout. With a little playing in PhotoShop I got them to the same size, without changing the proportions of the original. Here's a Side By Side comparison and the Ideal overlayed on the Real.

Now the Real finial is from a piece with a "long axis horizontal" hollow form(wider than it is tall) so she may have intentionally "lowered the center of gravity" of the finial and thickened things up a bt to go with the "low center of gravity" of the hollow form. The piece has a more "grounded" look than her taller than wide, more "lighter" pieces.

It would seem that, starting with an "ideal", proportions can be adapted to go with the hollow form, yet still keep the Drozda look. THAT is where the Artist comes in - adapting to the context - and there ain't no equations that hold fast and true for all cases.


So what do you come away from all this with?

Re: Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)

#17

Re: Real vs Ideal

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Fascinating!