Drozda Finial Analyzed (numercaily)
charlie belden
Probably because of all my training in engineering that sets me looking for Underlying Principles when it comes to design - and other things. I look for reasons why one design works looks right while another very similar design doesn't.
Going through the log of the chat with Cindy Drozda, and the "drozda_finials.pdf" file that the chat linked to, got me analyzing the illustrated example in the pdf file. Copied the illustration into a primitive CAD program that would let me scale values, and used a spreadsheet to play with the scaled values - and relationships between critical dimensions of a Drozda Finial. Not surprising, I found FOURTEEN critical dimensions, and they all can be derived from the finials HEIGHT.
While the Golden Ratio (1:1.618) plays a major role, "3rds", "4ths" and "5ths" are used for the minor details. The "3rds" and "5ths" were expected. The "4ths" was a bit of a surprise.
I've done an Excel spread sheet that lets me specify a finial height and calculates each of the critical dimensions. Found that working in millimeters was easier than working with fractional or decimal inches, but the spread sheet doesn't care what units you start with.
Here's the illustration and the formulas for calculating each critical dimension. If there's interest in the spread sheet, I can put it on my WWing site and post a link to it.







