bevel angle for scraper
James Pittman
I am trying to get all my turning tools sharpen right what is the best angle for my scrapers Thanks Jim
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
bevel angle for scraper
James Pittman
I am trying to get all my turning tools sharpen right what is the best angle for my scrapers Thanks Jim
probably 75 degrees?
steven antonucci
I don't even know what I use to be honest, but it is super important to have a flat, polished top face to get a proper burr. I can see myself in my scrapers.
I usually pull my hook with a 1200 grit diamond hone, and I only use it to finely refine a shape or toolmarks, not stock removal.
Steve
Re: bevel angle for scraper
robo hippy
Mine are about 70 to 75 degrees, which is pretty much how they came. For roughing work, I use them with the burr straight from the grinder. For finish shear cuts, the same thing. I tried the honed burr and didn't find any significant difference or advantage. Same with a burnished burr. I do hone off the old burr on the top side before grinding another one. I also use the D Way 180 grit CBN wheel for my burr. Before that, I used a matrix style CBN wheel. I haven't used standard aluminum oxide wheel for years, and can't remember what that type of burr is like.
On the other side of the pond (UK) I believe they like a sharper bevel on their scrapers. That does tend to make them more grabby.
robo hippy
Re: bevel angle for scraper
Don Evans
I use the Veritas gizmo made to make that bur, this is the one you mount and has the two pins sticking up. The pin that makes the burr is 80 degrees, so if you use this thing you must grind at less of an angle than that or it will not work, so I grind at 75 deg, clean off the top then with 600 grit diamond then use the Veritas.
Why do I do it that way? Cause I can control the amount of burr therefore controlling how aggressive the tool is or isn't. Just de;pends on what I'm doing with it at the time, what type wood etc.
Don
Veritas 5 Degree Rod...
John Kaner
Lee valley carries the 5 degree rod now. This will do 75 - 80 degree angle.
10 degree rod (standard) does 70 - 75 degree angle.
Upgrade for $7.95
I "upgraded" and found it works wonders, for me...
Re: Veritas 5 Degree Rod...
Don Evans
Thanks for the info update John.
Don
Re: Veritas 5 Degree Rod...
robo hippy
I use the triangle burnishing rod for standard card scrapers. Works just fine. You can control the angle easily as well, but you do it by hand rather than on a work bench.
robo hippy
Re: bevel angle for scraper
Peter Hyde
Probably more answers to this than there are turners! Take a look at the Richard Raffan Bowl Turning video from Taunton and watch him rough hollow with a scraper ground at around 50-60º by my estimation. Also note the amount of overhang over the tool rest. I know we are not all Richard Raffans so the answer would seem to be "What ever works for you"
Re: bevel angle for scraper
James Pittman
I thank you all for your advice. I think I will try 75% and see if that works Thanks Jim
Re: bevel angle for scraper
Jesper, Denmark
IMHO, the critical geometry for the scarper is the top surface and the burr. The top surface should be ground and polished so as to get as even a burr as possible. The burr geometry is somewhat haphazard, as it is too small to see and measure.
The bevel angle in general is not too critical for the cut, as in "standard use" there is plenty of clearance as the tool is presented with a negative rake. In shear cuts, it is nice with a little more relief, and you can use it with a rubbing bevel.
It makes no sense to have any less than an 75-80° bevel. Scrapers are generally made thick and heavy to eliminat chattering, so having as much metal under the cutting edge, reinfores this feature. More acute bevel angles will remove more metal under the cutting edge, making the scraper less stable, and without providing any benefit that I can see.