Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

flat vs hollow ground

Posts

flat vs hollow ground

#1

flat vs hollow ground

eliot d

I read on some sharpening link recently that the really best way to sharpen lathe turning tools was with a flat bevel. The reasoning was that the slight hollow will somehow try to make the tool wander slightly causing small, but significant, movements, vibrations, whatever. I've never noticed any such thing, but I'm wondering if I just haven't been paying sufficient attention. I hope there's nothing to it; otherwise all of us sharpening on a wheel are on the wrong track! No one cares about it for scraping tools, clearly; and I have read about different opinions for skew chisels. But this was the first time I heard anything about it for gauges.

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#2

Re: flat vs hollow ground

john lucas

Well I've tried both flat, hollow and concave. Still trying to learn the differences. I don't see any difference in flat vs concave. The story is still out for some tools on convex. Maybe someone sharper than me can show me the difference but I haven't been able to tell it myself.

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#3

Re: flat vs hollow ground

Jorge

I don't know about gouges, but a skew with a slight convex works very well for me.

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#4

Steven Antonucci

It's all the same when you get down to it

steven antonucci

If you think about the issue at a geometric level, the goal is to have the edge be a tangent to a circle. If the bevel is flat, it is easier to illustrate this in a drawing, but meaningless in reality as the tip is the only part that have to be tangential. As for the hollow grind, I find a shorter bevel much more manueverable, so I am grinding away the heels of all of my gouges. A hollow grind essentially creates that short bevel for me and is easier to rehone than a full flat.

Not sure if that's clear...?

Steve

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#5

Re: flat vs hollow ground *LINK*

Doc Green

Jon Siegel published two articles on sharpening in which he says a bevel should be flat. Here is a quote from the first article:

"If you want your chisel to go in a straight line, you need a straight bevel. If the bevel is curved in a hollow shape (concave), then the chisel is always trying to follow this curve, and it is a struggle to keep it going straight."

http://www.bigtreeturnings.com/articles/sharpening1.html

http://www.bigtreeturnings.com/articles/sharpening2.html

An issue that he does not address is that if you are working a concave surface with a gouge with a concave bevel (like on the inside of a bowl), you are more likely to get compression rings from the heel of the bevel, and they are rather difficult to sand away once they are created.

For skews: definitely flat or slightly convex, but not significantly convex near the cutting edge. If a skew is fully concave, it will tend to go deeper into the cut, and you will have to continually lever it out.

For parting tools: slightly concave may be better because you are actually working on a (convex) surface that will match (to some extent) the concave surface of the tool.


Jon Siegel's first article

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#6

Re: flat vs hollow ground

John Lucas

On skews I really have a flat edge. It's very tiny because I start with a concave surface and then hone the edge. However my bowl gouges are all concave with the exception of a Johannes Michelson grind that I'm still experimenting with.

On my gouges I don't have any trouble keeping them from pulling into the wood, flat such as platters or round like bowls. I think it's the heel of the bevel that controls the cut, at least on concave and flat bevels. I guess that works similar on convex bevels except the area of control is probably closer to the cutting edge.

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#7

"Too much ado about very little of ......

JamieDonaldson

..consequence" would be my reply to this topic. Some tools like skews may benefit more or less from concave bevels, but for gouges I also shorten bevels, most often to allow the radius of a curve to be transitioned without compression rings. In most cases I would be more concerned with the sharpness of the cutting edge than the tiny bevel variation in curvature as a result of grinding on an 8" grinder wheel. :b

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: "Too much ado about very little of ......

Mike Stafford

Me, too Jamie.

I kept getting these marks on the end grain of some of my boxes the cause of which I could not identify. Turned out it was from the heel of the gouge burnishing the end grain as I was shaping the crown on the lid of my box. Once I ground the heel off the gouge the burnish marks and the problem went away.....

Trying to sand out the burnish marks resulted in one thing....heat check in end grain.....

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#9

Re: "Too much ado about very little of ......

GaryG in MD

Jamie, You took the words right out of my mouth. Thanks for saving me the time. ...Gary

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: flat vs hollow ground

Brad Vietje

Doc,

I'm a Jon Siegel protege, so I'll admit my views may be biased. I've sharpened all my tools with hollow grinds, all with flat bevels, and most recently some of each!

It all comes down to speed, accuracy, and ease of sharpening, as well as honing.

Turners who want to hone the edge favor a hollow grind, as it is easier to keep the hone properly aligned by resting it on the edge and heel of the bevel. Jon's sharpening method involves not only an inverted belt sander, but also a buffing wheel. If you maintain the edge with a well-worn 150 grit belt (and a really light touch!), and buff very briefly with Tripoli on the buffing wheel (flute as well as bevel) you won't need to hone most of your tools.

Geometrically, a hollow grind will be best for spindles and the outer (convex) shapes of bowls and other forms, while a convex grind should, in theory, work best for bowl interiors. A flat bevel is a good middle ground, and is remarkably easy, fast, reproducible, and CHEAP to accomplish, so it's a good compromise for any tool you don't need to hone.

My current compromise is a mixed bag --I rough turn bowls inside and out with hollow ground gouges, but almost always finish turn the inside with a flat-bevel tool. I want to experiment with a convex grind on my favorite finish-turning go-to gouge, but that will have to wait for the new shop to come on-line.

I reserve honing (and hollow grinds) for skews, detail gouges, and one Ellsworth bowl gouge I use for bowl exteriors, vertical sheer scraping, etc.... When I get into my new shop, I have plans to "hollow out" some time to go "flat out" and "dig in" to this "catchy" topic with some simple tests, and then ask my entire turning club to try out the various grinds on a variety of standard cuts, and record their experiences.... more later!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#11

Re: "Too much ado about very little of ......

Steve Mushinski

Cherry was the worst for this type of turning error. I didn't ask anyone why I just figured it was something in the wood - couldn't have been me - LOL.

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#12

Joe Fleming

Re: flat vs hollow ground

Joe Fleming

Doc mentioned the compression rings. If you watch Mike Mahoney's bowl turning video, you can see them created as he goes. The shorter the bevel, the closer the spacing and the lower the ring/scallop is. Short means easier to sand away.

I hollow grind everything and grind away the heels as needed.

Joe

Re: flat vs hollow ground

#13

Brad Vietje

Re: flat vs hollow ground

Brad Vietje

Joe -- you're right. If we take a little care to remove and smooth over the edge at the heel of the tool, the wood fibers may be burnished a bit, but they won't be torn or separated, and sanding will go much more quickly.

That's anther benefit of a tool that's buffed -- you can polish that heel occasionally, and it gets touched up every time the tool goes through the sand-buff sequence.

Safe holiday,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT