Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

Posts

For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#1

Steven Antonucci

For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

steven antonucci

I saw your post below on sharpening and yor concern that you would prematurely wear out your tool. I wanted to share some thoughts with you and start a new thread.

First, everyone knows that a sharp tool is better than a dull tool. John Jordan is infinitely more qualified than I am on the subject, and he has put it rather eloquently. The answer is sharpen.

If you are sharpening properly, and using a repeatable jig set-up, you should be able to get a new edge in 1-2 swipes across the wheel. The steel should not change color at all. If it does, you either need to clean your wheel or stop pressing the tool into the wheel. Probably both. I explain when I teach that if you cannot touch the tip of the tool without burning yourself, you need to revisit the wheel/pressure thing...

Once you have a fresh edge, it is easy to maintain it to cut the number of trips to the wheel with a hone. I use a DMT diamond stick, which sells for $8 at Woodcraft. The hone touches the heel and the edge since the wheel leaves a hollow grind, and usually takes only a few seconds to bring back a serviceable edge without grinding. I can hone 3-4 times instead of regrinding before I need to go back to the wheel. This greatly cuts the wear on my tools.

However, you should consider your tools as "consumable"... the same way that you might consider sandpaper. I will submit that it is probably more economical to get a good edge for a clean finishing cut than it is to sand away the results of a dull tool. If you factor in the time you spend, it becomes a no brainer.

I get sandpaper for $0.50/sheet. On a good day, I can eliminate 2 grits with a fresh edge. That saves me probably 10 minutes and $1 on everything I finish. I have gouges that I have used for years that may have lost 2" of flute length, and made thousands of things using this logic. At $50 for a gouge, I have only used about $15 of the tool (6" flutes).

Steve

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#2

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening) *LINK*

John Lucas

Steve nailed it. The best thing I've ever done is to consider my tools consumables. That way I sharpened often. This did several things. First off it taught me to sharpen better. This made turning much more fun, and faster I might add.

Second, since I sharpened more the edge didn't require as much time at the grinder. That and my skills improving meant I started removing less metal per sharpening.

I did use up my first tool by over grinding but it did take a year or so. The tool cost about $39 back then. Divide that by say 24 and you get about $1.60 a month. That's what made me decide that a tool could be a consumable.

Now many years later using sharpening jigs and sometimes diamond hones my tools last many years even though I probably sharpen more than most people. I mentioned in a post a while back that I had only used 1" off my Thompson Gouge in something like 2 years. I know that because I bought a new gouge and compared the lengths. That is my favorite tool that is used for almost every single turning so it has been sharpened an awful lot. I just checked and a 1/2" V gouge from Doug is $55. I expect to easily get 2 more years and maybe more out of that gouge. So if I do the math that comes down to about $1 a month. That's a good investment. I consider sandpaper a consumable and toss it frequently. I haven't run the numbers but I'll bet I spend more on sandpaper than $1 a month. In fact I'm sure I if you total up the discs and flat sandpaper.

I don't hone my gouges that often. I don't need to for most of the work I do and I remove so little metal when sharpening that the argument over honing vs grinding to save metal doesn't work for me.

Check out my sharpening videos and maybe they will help you.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xbggxj2kgyc

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#3

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

Barry Irby

Maybe I am a slow learner, but it took me a while to figure this out.

The inner surface of the gouge is part of the cutting edge of the tool. The surface you grind or hone converges with the inner surface at some angle and that form the edge. So, if the inner surface is roughly ground that the best edge you are going to get. If it is nicely polished you can get a much smoother/finer edge . If you grind with a course wheel, with a lens or microscope, you can see that the edge is really saw toothed.

Think of the cutting edge in terms of "round over". If you ran a 1/4" round over bit on the edge of a board, you would have to cut away about a 1/4" of wood to get a square edge. If you wanted to cut away a 1/8" round over, you would have to only cut off an 1/8". So, on a microscopic scale, you are rounding over the edge of the tool as you use it and dull it. If a dull tool has 1/1000" round over and the really dull one has 2/1000", whatever it is, you have to grind away twice as much metal to get back to that Sharpe edge. So, if you can grind very careful and only take a very small amount of metal you can sharpen twice as often and get a sharp edge twice as often. Turning is much more fun with a really sharp tool.

And the others are right. Gouges are consumable. I have been using mine for over ten years only turning occasionally and I am not aware that it is shorter than when I got it. I wish I knew how long it was when I bought it, but in spite of its $60 price, it is not much of a cost per piece turned, Cheaper than sand paper.

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening) *LINK*

Brad Vietje

Good discussion!

I learned a lot about sharpening from Jon Siegel, a master turner in central New Hampshire. He has some good articles on turning-related topics,including sharpening, archived on his web site. A direct link to sharpening info is here:

http://www.bigtreeturnings.com/articles/sharpening1.html

The difference between a sharp tool and one that needs retouching is about half a thousandth or 0.0005". If you can learn to sharpen (maintain the edge) by removing only 0.0005" or 0.001", you'll get 1000 to 2000 sharpenings before an inch of steel is ground away... That means you can sharpen very often, and enjoy better results, without the guilt -- IF -- you can learn to sharpen efficiently.

One way is a jig and a really light touch, and another is to get really, really good at hand-held sharpening. I am squarely in the jig camp, so you get the same grind every time. Since not all grinds can be done this way, there are still times when hand-shaped tools are the way to go.

Sharpen often, and have fun!

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#5

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

The one thing that you have the LEAST of in your turning life is: TIME. Do not let dull tools slow you down. I agree with everything said above.

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#6

Steven Antonucci

Progressive polishing of the flutes

steven antonucci

Barry-

That's a great explanation of what is happening. Two surfaces meeting at an edge. The better the two surfaces are, the better the edge. I take dowels and whatever else I can find to progressively polish an inch or so of flute at a time to remove any mill marks or imperfections. I have no doubt that this makes for a sharper edge, and I also suspect that it makes for a longer wearing edge.

At a microscopic level, the edge is small particles of steel that break off. This is what "dull" means- that you've broken off enough of the smaller bits and you're no longer using the smaller particles in one plane. By honing the edge, the edge becomes more consistent and polished. At a microscopic level, it basically means that you have more uniform particle sizes supporting each other, which gives you a much longer use time.

There are few things greater in this world than a freshly sharpened gouge on freshly cut green wood...

Steve

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#7

i feel special...

darrin hill

A thread with my name... Im touched..

and i guess im cheap... I just see me taking a gouge and removing 1/2 inch (not really) every time i sharpen it.... and they aint cheap... gonna try to LIGHTLY sharpen.. And i have honeing tools...

i asked about making tools earlier, and i meant that some of our local guys buy the gouge steel, and make their own long handles... But someone mentioned metalergy... I have a forge and i used to make knife blades years ago.. We used to take old car springs, heat them hot, let them cool, and they would loose their temper... and repeat.. eventually we could straighten a coil of steel, and then heat and quench to restore the temper... only thing i was never able to do was forge weld.. I think u need two people..

But i dont think i could make bowl gouges... dont know how to make the flute..

d

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#8

Re: Progressive polishing of the flutes

Barry Irby

Another way to look at it is the polished surface inside flute IS the cutting edge. You grind away the rest of the steel to reveal the edge.

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#9

Re: i feel special...

Barry Irby

Have blasted the idea of making tools, I confess I made a gouge. Took a piece of tool steel rod and mounted it on my radial arm saw perpendicular to the fence. Has two abrasive cut-off wheel on the saw. Put a stop block on the arm to limit forward travel. Pulled the saw forward and pushed it back. Lowered it slightly and repeated, again and again. Tempered it in the oven. The inside was not as polished as it should have been, but I used it for a while until I got a real one made by somebody who actually knew what they were doing. Their's was better.

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#10

Steven Antonucci

one person can forge weld...i have at least

steven antonucci

All it takes is a little planning...i am not going to be a forfe in the blacksmithing world any time soon,but small welds are easy and bigger ones are manageable with a power hammer

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#11

Re: i feel special...

darrin hill

wow..

My gosh.. someone who does scarier things than I do...

I took a piece of long generic rebar and made a small notch in it to pretend it was a flute, and sharpened it on a basic grinder... used the tool rest but didnt have another rig at the back end for support.. very vibraty... ( i just made up a word..) used it for about a month for hollow forms.. kinda worked... now i use my rig in my photos.. much faster...

I use a steady rest a lot cause i'm freaked out by pieces that explode and knock holes in my ceiling.

I use a chuck to hold hollowforms cause i dont like using glued up waste blocks... takes too long to dry.. when i want to turn, i want to turn NOW...

am i the only one who makes hf using a chuck?

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#12

Re: one person can forge weld...i have at least

darrin hill

dont have a power hammer..just a ferriers forge, anvil, and a ball peen hammer..

if i could get coal locally i would possibly get a bigger forge... I think it would be cool to make hf or stuff with maybe a coil of steel coiled around the piece with leaves and tendrils... I've seen them do it on ships mast where they take a loop of red hot steel and shove a mast through it and pour wateron to shrink the steel... but the mast usually catches on fire...

still working on that... dont think it's feasable at this time. :)

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#13

Re: one person can forge weld...i have at least

John Lucas

Darrin I also have trouble forge welding. It just has to be done quickly. I've succeeded but need lots more practice.

I've also made some gouges or at least the tips. I use a 3" piece of round stock and mill a groove. Then I turn a tenon on the other end to go into mild steel to hold it. These are made from high carbon steel and don't hold an edge anywhere near as long as High Speed Steel but I don't have a way to heat treat HSS.

I have also made a spindle gouge out of flat stock. Just hammer it over a round bar to form the flute. It's fast and easy but again it's made from Carbon Steel.

I do hold my hollow forms in a chuck most of the time. They aren't very large. For work that is over about 8" I use a faceplate screwed directly to the work. I rough turn the piece between centers and turn a that matches my faceplate size. This tenon is only 1/16" or so and is there just to make aligning the faceplate easier. In the old days I would completely turn the outside and turn a recess for the faceplate so it aligns exactly but eventually went to the rough out stage because it was more relieable to do the final shaping with the faceplate applied.

If your throwing work it's probably your turning skills but there are other problems. Tighten your chuck often, they crush the fibers of green wood and work there way loose. Use a shoulder on the tenon, this helps keep the piece from rocking in the chuck which speeds up the problem mentioned above. Use larger jaws and a bigger tenon, especially if the tenon itself is breaking.

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#14

Steven Antonucci

Having a forge opens possibilities

steven antonucci

I have a piece I am working on that combines my forge and turning. I am not ready to show it yet, but when I do, I'll point it out...

My forge is an old brake rotor with a hairdryer and some black pipe under it...

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#15

Don't inhale.....

Barry Irby

unless you thoroughly cleaned the asbestos off that brake rotor. Did you mean brake drum? (I'm not a car guy but I can't visualise using a rotor or at least what I thought a rotor was.) I am not considering a forge, but I like the idea.

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#16

Lyle Jamieson

Re: i feel special...

Lyle Jamieson

I dont use a chuck because it has limitations. If you want to keep the scale small then a chuck is fine. If you get vibration problems where you need a steady rest, then the chuck might be the weak point. My process roughs out the blank to round between centers. Make a concave flat where the faceplate seats around the rim. This takes the same amount of time that you would take to make a chuck tenon. I dont fuss with a method of centering the faceplate, just come close is good enough cause the blank is just roughed out at this stage. Use lots of screws, you might have to drill more holes in your faceplate. Leave the base where the faceplate sits as large as possible for support for your hollowing and do the top half or 2/3 outside and inside with the base to support it without the need of a steady rest. Then do the lower stage last and you can now take the bottom foot diameter to the final size and hollow out the lower section. The difference in wasted wood is very small from the faceplate method compared to the tendon for a chuck. The advantages are huge in the stability and strength to do larger vessels or pour the coal to it without as much vibration.

Re: For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)

#17

Steven Antonucci

I think it is a rotor

steven antonucci

I think the rotors are the ones with a central well for mounting, but the braking surface is the flat outer rim. A drum is usually something that the brake expands out against...or so I've been told.

I have a small one from a passenger sized vehicle, and a larger drum from some truck like vehicle. The big guy is 80#, and I haven't gotten around to cutting it down to a forge yet, but i have used it as a beach fire pit. My neighbors think I am crazy, but they still huddle around it at the campout.

Steve

P.S. I didn't think at all about asbestos, but if there was any, it's long gone.