For Darrin Hill (on Sharpening)
steven antonucci
I saw your post below on sharpening and yor concern that you would prematurely wear out your tool. I wanted to share some thoughts with you and start a new thread.
First, everyone knows that a sharp tool is better than a dull tool. John Jordan is infinitely more qualified than I am on the subject, and he has put it rather eloquently. The answer is sharpen.
If you are sharpening properly, and using a repeatable jig set-up, you should be able to get a new edge in 1-2 swipes across the wheel. The steel should not change color at all. If it does, you either need to clean your wheel or stop pressing the tool into the wheel. Probably both. I explain when I teach that if you cannot touch the tip of the tool without burning yourself, you need to revisit the wheel/pressure thing...
Once you have a fresh edge, it is easy to maintain it to cut the number of trips to the wheel with a hone. I use a DMT diamond stick, which sells for $8 at Woodcraft. The hone touches the heel and the edge since the wheel leaves a hollow grind, and usually takes only a few seconds to bring back a serviceable edge without grinding. I can hone 3-4 times instead of regrinding before I need to go back to the wheel. This greatly cuts the wear on my tools.
However, you should consider your tools as "consumable"... the same way that you might consider sandpaper. I will submit that it is probably more economical to get a good edge for a clean finishing cut than it is to sand away the results of a dull tool. If you factor in the time you spend, it becomes a no brainer.
I get sandpaper for $0.50/sheet. On a good day, I can eliminate 2 grits with a fresh edge. That saves me probably 10 minutes and $1 on everything I finish. I have gouges that I have used for years that may have lost 2" of flute length, and made thousands of things using this logic. At $50 for a gouge, I have only used about $15 of the tool (6" flutes).
Steve




