Maybe it's not mimosa, but it's still hard as concrete... Was told it was mimosa from the guy who cut it down. Maybe he forgot..
But here are images of my setup... My nice clean shop is full of beehive parts... Trying to get them finished before i shoot something.
ANd i bought the PINK steadyrest from a friend. It was already pink and pink is my girls color, so it doesnt bother me. But it apparantly offended my brother who is an ex police officer... Apparantly tools are not supposed to be pink.
Your setup looks fine. It appears that you've got plenty of access to remove chips, and the tool is set properly. The only thing I can surmise is that you are cutting in from the end grain instead of across the face grain, but even then, it wouldn't take me an hour to clean this out by hand. With the rig, it should be even quicker.
Try cutting from the top to the max diameter on the top half, and the foot to the max diameter on the lower half. You will be cutting with the grain if you do this, and you should get shavings instead of sawdust.
Others are correct, It should take less then an hour to hollow out that scale vessel no matter what the wood is, even without a laser. With the laser, you could do it in about a half hour.
You have not mentioned what your obstivcle was but I have to assume from your set up that you are getting excessive vibration. What else would slow you dowd unless it is dull tools. I see in the photo all the torn out grain. This is an indicator of dull tools. Could this wood have silica in it that dulls your tools too quickly?? Would a Carbide cutter help?? I have cut some Brazilian ipe that would not turn. It dulled the tools so fast I gave up on it and I tossed it.
I observe a number of problems you need to solve. (1) The Chuck is a weak point. I NEVER use a chuck for hollow forms. (2) Because of the chuck weakness, you have a steady rest where it should not be needed for that size vessel. Which means you do not have a good transfer of power from your lathe to the wood. (3)Its great you have a captured boring bar but the handle is set up upsidedown from mine. Set up is critical to get fingertip control and cut effisiently.
Some resources for you:
*Both my DVDs spend a lot of time on tool control and vibration issues. Im sure your club has a copy in the library.
*My web site has set up instructions for my system. Look through them to make sure all is set up correctly. The same dynamics and rules apply no matter what hollowing system you have, even home built systems.
*I have an article about vibration issues and tool control with the boring bar that would help you get efficient cuts.
*Give me a call if you want to trouble shoot your process over the phone.
Exceptionally likely that you'd lose the vessel if you tried to dry it. I cut them all to final thickness and let them gently warp. If you turn them to about 1/8", they don't move much.
Darrin, of course you can rough out HF's to be turned later when they're dry. I've done it hundreds of times. Cracking is very seldom a problem. Right now I have 50 or 60 rough turned HF's in my shop. I'm fairly sure that none of them will crack. You do have to protect them. I heavily coat them with Johnsons paste wax. If I have a wood that's prone to cracking I put it in a brown paper bag for a few weeks. I live in hot dry Arizona where wood will always crack if you don't protect it. I never rough turn wet wood during our hot summers
You mention 1 inch walls in a rough out. Unless it's a wood that'll warp a lot I'd go a bit thinner. Make sure that the thickness is fairly uniform throughout.
If your HF's are end grain, warping usually won't be much of a problem.
Darren I have often roughed out hollow forms, put them on the shelf, let them dry and re- turn them. Rarely a crack. I live in the East; the humidity is much higher than where Wally lives.
There are lots of things that I would say in clarifying my statement. First, I usually turn cross grain, and the wider a vessel is, the more it will want to move. Also, many times, I will hollow through the bark side and sapwood to create contrast (walnut as an example). Having sapwood and heartwood in the same vessel usually creates drying stresses.
Because the inside is contained and the outside is exposed, you get a moisture differential that can also cause a crack. Even if the outside dries, the inside will still be "wet" if you rough to 1" thickness. I have used DNA to speed up this process because I can soak the vessel and have complete satuation, and the DNA will evaporate more readily from the inside.
On end grain vessels, I almost always get a crack at the entry hole.
It is seldom that I once turn a hollow form, especially cross grain. Rough to about 5/8" for an 8" diameter form, bag it and dry it for a couple of months setting on it's foot (in the bag), pull from the bag and let it dry for another couple of months or longer, then return. Ohio is not as dry as Az.
I've turned a couple of bowls from Mimosa. Never noticed it being hard. Actually thought it was a bit softer than Ash or Elm. It could be that your piece has a high silica content, and if so, frequent sharpenings are the only answer.
Darrin, it's a matter of choice. Some turners turn wet to finish and let the piece move as it wants to. Others do as I do and rough turn and let the piece dry before finishing it. Most of my HF's will have a collar or a lid with a finial, so I want as little wood movement as possible. If I have a special piece that's moving a lot I sometimes triple turn it. Before it's completely dry and is still moving I bring it back to round, seal it again with wax and let it finish drying amd moving.
If you're nervous about using just wax, use Anchorseal wood sealer. The piece will take longer to dry.
When applying sealer, apply it only to the outside.
Hold the presses!! I agree with Steve...I usually turn to final thickness in one setting. I see no reason to double turn unless you want it perfectly round and are putting a lid on it or something. If the pith is gone and you are doing end grain vessel with half the tree, it will shrink slightly oval but the distortion will not be noticeable. Its more fun to turn green, I dont have to wait months to finish it, I dont have to hollow out dusty dry wood, it takes half the time. If you do a hollow form with a small foot how are you going to put it back on the lathe?? the vibration of hollowing would be a nightmare. so you resort to a steadyrest?? That is a last resort, I hate steady rests. Are you haveiong fun yet?? As Steve said the benefits from hollowing green to finish is even more dramatic for cross grain vessels.
i really do remember sharpening the bit before starting.. how often do you guys sharpen? I wasnt thinking i would have to sharpen 2-3 times per hf... but...
So how long are my gouges and such going to last if i have to sharpen them daily?
I'm wanting to know where to get bigger or longer tools, cause doing a 25 inch bowl with a 14" gouge is interesting... what do you guys do? buy the steel and make your own handles?
and how does silica get into trees? Are there trees with more silica than others?
can u take a bit of shavings and look in a microscope and see sand grains?
Sand does not get into trees, only onto the outer surface of trees. Grains of sand are far too large to be transported in the capillaries of trees. Wood that dulls tools is hard dense wood, not sandy wood. Another old woodturners' tale.
Wally, I have to address your attempt to start a fight. I cant understand how I stepped on your toe. Did I say anything about the right or wrong way to turn!!!!!!!!! I used the word "I" six times in the paragraph and I explained very clearly that it was what "I" prefer to do. My sentence clearly states . " I see no reason to double turn UNLESS you want it perfectly round and are putting a lid on it or something" So whats your beef with valuing the character that is the result of the drying process?? If it is more fun for you to double turn...go for it. Just dont force it down everybody elses throat.
Some of us have produced our own tools, in many different varieties, but that is not exactly the same thing as turning wood. Sort of a subset with very different skills and equipment needed. You have to develop knowledge of metallurgy, metal working, tempering, shaping and sharpening. You can do that if you like, but it would be very difficult to come close to matching the quality of modern manufactured tools. Check out Doug Thompson tools. He has access to steel you probably can buy and the technology to temper it properly. (There are Many other manufacturers also.)
And yes some wood is much more abrasive than others. Some turns like butter and some like concrete. Bradford pear is a joy to turn, pecan, not so much. Some woods seem to be pretty harmless and some will make you itch, break out, cough, and there are a few that are worse. It is sade the silicis drawn up into the tree through the roots. I don't actually know if that's true or if you can see it in the wood, but take it for a fact that some woods will dull your tools quickly.
Sharpening is discussed here often. One of my crumby home made tools might need to be sharpened after a few seconds. An excellent gouge out of one of the top of the line steels might last 100 times longer. You sharpen when the tool is dull, whether that's minutes or hours. Sharpening is another subset of skills related to but not exactly wood turning. A necessary part and something you need to be efficient at in order to be productive as a turner. There are about as many ways to sharpen as there are turners and we seldom precisely agree on how to do it, but there are some basics. Some grind the tools free hand ans many use jigs to produce repeatable shapes. Some use hand held stones or diamond hones to touch up the edges and many don't.
Turning essentially involves mounting a piece of wood on a machine that spins it and then poking it with a sharp piece of metal. The range of work that can be accomplishes is truly amazing. Keep coming here and reading. There is much to know.
Re: Good enough for Wally then good enough for me!
John Jordan
Start with a FRESHLY sharpened tool always-no exceptions. Finish cuts use a FRESHLY sharpened tool-no exceptions. Sharpen as often as needed in between. That may be once or twice, or a dozen times. When a sharp tools touches wood, it should cut easily. If it doesn't, then its not sharp. Simple really.
EVERY problem is wood tuning is related to sharpness of the tool, really. Says so on the blackboard.
That's my friend Mark Gardner at Arrowmont, but the handwriting is mine.
That's really woodturning in a nutshell. When the tool cuts, things become much simpler. It amazes me the lengths some go to to avoid it. If its hard work, and not much fun, something's wrong. See above^^^
Mimosa is a very abrasive wood, and will always require more frequent sharpening than many other woods.
There are a couple of articles on basic hollowing techniques on my website that might be of use.
I do both. I'm one of those people that likes perfectly round. I'm trying to ween myself away from it so I do turn hollow vessels in one sitting but I still lean toward the round as I can get it version.
I have at least 3 or 4 on my shelf right now that are dry. Green turned pieces are fun and easy to turn. If cut from the blank in the right way they stay round enough that most people don't notice. See John Jordan's video on The Aesthetics and Properties of wood.
When twice turning you have to deal with dry wood when finishing the hollowing which is much slower but like I said, I lean toward perfectly round because I may add lids sometimes contrasting woods and it better be dry to do this. The dry wood doesn't clog up as fast since it tends to break into smaller chips. I can usually blow it out where the wet wood often has to be pulled out with a tool due to the larger shavings. If you stop often you can blow out either one.
I have less problems with drying cracks on my hollow vessels than on my bowls. Don't know why exactly. I probably go to more extremes than necessary but having time to turn is such a critical factor for me and losing a piece to cracks is hard to swallow.
I generally coat all end grain areas, the lip and the foot with endgrain sealer. Then I put it in a paper sack for the first few weeks to a month. It just depends on when I remember to remove it. Haven't had a failure now in a couple of years but have only twice turned 8 or 10 hollow vessels. They just aren't my thing. Still I really hate to lose one so I go the extra distance.