Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

First Lidded Vessel

Posts

First Lidded Vessel

#1

BarbS

First Lidded Vessel

BarbS

This is Spalted Birch with a ring collar and lid/finial of Western Red Cedar. There are several things I would change, but I'd like to hear any comments or critiques from the group here. The vessel is about 6" tall, and the lid/finial another 4".


Re: First Lidded Vessel

#2

Re: First Lidded Vessel

darrin hill

curious.. cedar is much softer than birch.. any issues?

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#3

BarbS

Re: First Lidded Vessel

BarbS

Umm, not yet! The glued-on ring collar would be the only culprit. It has been sitting for over a month so far.

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#4

Steven Antonucci

Crisper details in the finial

steven antonucci

One of the true, best ways to become a better turner is to practice spindle turning. A finial is a great tool for practicing beads and coves, and learning to turn crisp details. I think the proportion of your finial is OK, but it lacks the crispness that really sets off a vessel.

Without going nuts, an easy way to practice spindle turning is to keep an eye out for people discarding old chairs. I simply take them and remove the turned parts. If you put a pre-turned part between centers, you can recut every detail on it a couple of times before discarding it. The legs and stretchers also give you a visual reference for how spindle turnings are organized and what items get grouped together.

Keep at it.

Steve

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#5

Re: First Lidded Vessel *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

Barb, it would be interesting to hear where you feel improvements are needed. It might be the lighting but it looks like you have the vessel, darker collar, smaller collar with a cove, then a darker finial. The four elements don't flow together well in my opinion. Personally I have a terrible time seeing this in my turnings until it's off the lathe, finished, signed and sitting on the kitchen counter.

I've found I can learn a lot by printing out a copy of the photo as large as I can print. Use the golden mean as a base and draw lines representing the proper dimensions for height and width. A set of calipers like I posted are very helpful. Once you have the horizontal lines drawn is the widest part at the correct level, a small french curve will show if you have a nice fair curve. Next check on the size of the vessel top (not finial) and the bottom ratios fit with the width mean. Then check on the size of the finial in relation to the vessel. Other than length I won't even begin on trying to make any suggestions on finial turning. Review Cindy's chat log for help in that area.

Remember the golden mean is a good starting point that is usually pleasant to the eye but that doesn't "mean" it is a set rule that can't be broken. Your vessel is very pleasing and will be a joy to you or whoever is the final owner.

----------------

I was finishing up on today's messages and saw the one Ellis posted on finials. He has posted something similar to what I mean by printing out a copy of the photo to use as a self critique.


Ellis and finials

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#6

BarbS

Re: Crisper details in the finial

BarbS

What a great idea. I'll try that. And I agree. Another time, I won't use something as soft as western red cedar. This finial is a third try, because small beads crumbled with sanding, or tore. Thanks, Steve.

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#7

BarbS

Re: First Lidded Vessel

BarbS

Thanks Stuart. Okay, you mentioned the things that bothered me about it. The ring collar, two-piece lid/finial were all pieces taken from the same red cedar board. I did use two different oils on them, which may account for the color difference. That bothers me a lot. And I saw afterward that I'd missed a fair curve in the shape of the vessel. That doesn't look as bad to my eye in life as it sits on a mantel, as it does in the photo, but it's definitely a miss. And proportion: I made the vessel first, then the low coved lid, then the finial and glued it in. I tried to be very careful about a 3 to 1 ratio on the finial itself, but failed to proportion it to the overall height with the vessel. I've printed out your gauge diagram and will make one in different sizes to use, thanks for that. The spalted birch was quite punky, and I must have used $10 worth of CA glue on it, rubbing in sawdust to fill voids. Then I decided to recut the shape and it all came out. I sanded and sanded, dry and with oil, and repeated the filling, but there are still rough areas I don't like. The shape is a disappointment. I'd heard here, of photographing a shape on the lathe, printing it and flipping it vertical, but I did not do that this time. It may have helped. I'll keep trying. And thanks for the input.

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#8

Re: First Lidded Vessel

Wally Dickerman

Very good first try Barb. Okay, for a critique. I'm a firm believer in the rule of thirds and also on curves, continuing curves. The top half of the form isn't bad, although I'd like to see the top curve work better with the lid. The curve on the lower part of the vessel starts out okay but then flattens out. If that nice curve continued on to the bottom you'd come close to achieving that rule of thirds. Even tucking in a bottom curve would help. The rule of thirds says that for good form, the bottom of a vessel should be one third the diameter of the widest part of the vessel. Doesn't always apply but usually it does.

I won't mention the finial...you've had some good advice on that already.

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#9

That'll do nicely...

Don Orr

...for the first one. You have some good advice here so far and I don't have anything to add really. Just keep turning and learning. No one starts out as an expert. You're off to a great start.

Cedar is very tought to get crisp details on-BTDT-no joy.

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#10

BarbS

Re: First Lidded Vessel

BarbS

Thanks, Wally. With this advice I'm going to put it back on the lathe and recut that base again. I had thought the rule of thirds applied to height, but never heard it applied to the base being one-third of the widest diameter. Thanks.

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#11

BarbS

Thank you, Don.  ;-)


Re: First Lidded Vessel

#12

Re: First Lidded Vessel

Stuart Johnson

Barb, for starters the rule of third pretty well applies through out the vessel. The width and height, the widest part up from the base or down from the top, the base and mouth. For example the mouth being 2/3 of the width and the base 1/3. While the ratios are important they can also make you crazy if you get too focused.

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#13

BarbS

Re: First Lidded Vessel

BarbS

I understand. But for a beginner, it helps to have a guide to train the eye by. Here's an idea. How about this?


Re: First Lidded Vessel

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: That'll do nicely...

Brad Vietje

Nice start, Barb!

I'm with Don on the cedar. I have much better results with a harder, finer-grained wood like hard Maple (that would be Sugar Maple), Yellow Birch, Apple, Lilac (beautiful stuff if you can find some!) and even Beech. Cherry works OK, too, but isn't as easy to "go thin" as the harder stuff.

The furniture spindles you can find at yard sales and consignment shops (or even the local dump) are often pretty good wood -- Maple or Beech here in the East, and you could start a little collection of "finial wood scraps".

If you re-do the base, I hope you'll show us how it "turns" out ;) .

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#15

BarbS

The Final Iteration

BarbS

Thank you all, for your suggestions and critiques. Here is the older photo shown originally, and the vessel with the base slightly re-cut a bit narrower, then the whole thing re-oiled and buffed with carnuba. I hope that helped correct the arc of the curve and even the proportions a little. I'm pleased with it.

Spalted Birch with Western Red Cedar collar, lid and finial, 10" tall:



Re: First Lidded Vessel

#16

Re: The Final Iteration

Stuart Johnson

A little change sure makes a big difference. Good job.

Re: First Lidded Vessel

#17

Re: The Final Iteration

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Much better. Nicely done.