Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Further to finials...

Posts

Further to finials...

#1

Ellis Walentine

Further to finials...

Ellis Walentine

I've been really intrigued with finial design since our chat with Cindy last week, so I thought I'd try a few ideas out. One was to start with a blank of wood and make a finial, for no particular vessel or object, and then design the object to complement the finial, using Cindy's concept of the "implied line" (red dashed lines in this sketch) to make the shapes flow visually.

Last night, I turned this finial, then photographed it and used it to make this layout sheet for designing the vessel. You can draw multiple sketches on the sheet to try to visualize different shapes. I tried making the finial about 2/5 of the total height of the composition, and I tried combining those proportions with ideal proportions within the elements themselves. I still find that drawing the curves by eyeball yields the most pleasing (to me at least) proportions.

Next I'll try making the vessel shape first, then designing the finial to match. Regardless of where you start, the sum of the two parts has to equal a visually pleasing whole; and that's not so easy when you're turning the parts separately. I think the drawing sheet helps.

Ellis


Re: Further to finials...

#2

Re: Further to finials...

Dale Miner

I missed the chat, but read through it afterwards.

From your line/s, it looks like you have flattened the line a bit just below the base of the finial to match with the form #1. Form #2 would create a slight break in the flow of the line from the finial to the form. My eye finds form #2 more pleasing that form #1. Perhaps a form #3 somewhere between #1 and #2?

The text of the chat and the accompanying .pdf are very informative. Thanks for putting it together.

Re: Further to finials...

#3

Re: Further to finials...

matt overton

Good exercise. I have done a few finials trying to emulate Cindy's style with some success. However, I was just winging it. What Cindy showed in the chat, and you have done here is what I need to do in order to take it to the next level. I think either vessel you have drawn will work, because you are taking the time in advance to self critique your design. This works just as well in the opposite direction...vessel first then design the finial in this fashion.

Re: Further to finials...

#4

Ellis Walentine

Re: Further to finials...

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Dale. There are a lot of variables here, including the heights of the elements, their relative widths, and how you draw the implied line. My #3 curve represents the height and visual mass of the vessel that is most pleasing to me; the others look too small relative to this particular finial.

The transition from the implied line of the finial to the curve of the vessel is an open question. It seems to me that some kind of break is acceptable; they don't have to flow seamlessly together. Maybe it all comes down to your subjective judgment of how it all looks.

At any rate, the design of these things is challenging and rewarding to me. I realize that much of my turning design over the years has been based on getting the best form out of a given piece of wood, developing the shape as I turn. Planning and sketching the form in advance seems to offer more control of the design.

Ellis

Re: Further to finials...

#5

Re: Further to finials...

john lucas

Ellis I think there is an implied line that isn't drawn. Trace a line from the outside of #1 shape follow it up the center line of the spindle instead of the outside of the spindle. I kept looking at your two box drawing and thought something kind of inbetween works better.

by running my eye from the center of the spindle down to the flowing bottom section of the spindle I flow nicely out to the #1 shape.

Looking the spindle itself there are two implied lines to me. One is the red line you drew going from the upper part of the final and down. In this case the smaller bowl of the box looks too small.

The other line is the bottom element of the finial and you drew he box to match. On this one the box seems a little too large. I'm wondering what it would look like if you start that curve to flow from the bottom element but then let it drop into the outside curve of the box faster.

I do agree 100 percent that we often make a form fit the wood instead of the other way around. I'm as guilty as anyone on that.

Re: Further to finials...

#6

Re: Further to finials...

R Henrickson

Where are the chat text or PDF?

Re: Further to finials...

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Further to finials...

Lyle Jamieson

You nailed the trick to design. The more I plan the luckier I get.

Re: Further to finials...

#9

Ellis Walentine

Whew! 

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for the input John. I'm trying hard to understand your descriptions...

Ellis I think there is an implied line that isn't drawn. Trace a line from the outside of #1 shape follow it up the center line of the spindle instead of the outside of the spindle.

I'm not seeing how to do that, John. If I draw up the center line of the finial, it becomes a straight line from that point upward.

I kept looking at your two box drawing and thought something kind of in between works better.

I wish I understood this...

by running my eye from the center of the spindle down to the flowing bottom section of the spindle I flow nicely out to the #1 shape.

Yes, I do, too. But that shape looks a bit small for the heft of this particular finial, which is why I tried #2.

Looking the spindle itself there are two implied lines to me. One is the red line you drew going from the upper part of the final and down. In this case the smaller bowl of the box looks too small.

I think that's what we just discussed above.

The other line is the bottom element of the finial and you drew he box to match. On this one the box seems a little too large. I'm wondering what it would look like if you start that curve to flow from the bottom element but then let it drop into the outside curve of the box faster.

Hmmm... all I can say is a picture is worth a thousand words. How about if I post a blank form and have you illustrate your thoughts for me?

I really appreciate the input.

Ellis


Re: Further to finials...

#10

Ellis Walentine

Go here... *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

There's a banner at the top of this page that changes every couple screens, that takes you to the transcript of our chat with Cindy Drozda. The link to her PDF is there in the archive.

Ellis Walentine, Host


Cindy Drozda Chat Log

Re: Further to finials...

#11

Re: Whew!

Stuart Johnson

Ellis, why don't you see if Cindy will do a critique of the finial for you? Without a vessel attached the size and placement of the elements can be reviewed by themselves.

Re: Further to finials...

#12

Ellis Walentine

Already on it, Stuart

Ellis Walentine

Cindy is a busy person. We'll see if she has the time or inclination to add her thoughts to this discussion.

Ellis

Re: Further to finials...

#13

Brad Vietje

Re: Whew!

Brad Vietje

Hey Ellis -- nice finial, and a nice discussion, too.

I think people get in trouble by turning the finial first, then trying to make a vessel to match. Maybe I'm the only one, but it just doesn't work so well for me. I see pieces with an awkward transition between the vessel form and the finial which doesn't quite give that aaaaah! feeling.

I also like to see a little more verve in the curve at the base of the finial (as well as the top of the vessel form). Looking at the finial in isolation, I'd aim for a more concave curve as the base widens out. I'll go out on an unpopular limb here, and suggest that even Cindy's vessel up on the banner would be better if the base of that finial were less conical, and a wee bit more concave. I aim for the reverse of the curve in the upper portion of the vessel. Just a little bit makes a big difference to my eye.

On the top of the vessel, I'd make the curve tighter and tighter toward the top, which tends to shorten and fatten the look somewhat, but leads to a richer, fuller profile IMHO. I usually try to avoid a more lenticular shape, though I've seen some that are very pleasing.

I don't know how to create drawings on the computer, so I can't easily diagram what I'm describing, and I've been camera-less for some time now, so I'll have to search for a photo that does the trick. I know how to DO it, but don't currently have a photo to show what I mean.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Further to finials...

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: Whew!

Brad Vietje

Hey Ellis,

I'll just use Cindy's PDF as the illustrations... Slide #19 shows the curve, and #33 is excellent. On # 23 I think she could have hollowed that curve just a wee bit more, and it would be even better. For a tall form like yours, # 27 has a curve like I'm suggesting, and #34 is even better. The curve on the Sea Urchin ornament is Bingo! right on the money.

I consider the piece on slide # 32 to be absolutely beautiful, but again -- going out into left field here or maybe behind the dog house -- looking at the finial and its relation to the piece below it, I think it would be it would be perfectly stunning if t had a little more concavity in the base.

The ones I really don't like are the the ones that change direction, or seem too conical. Cindy's accepted as the master of finials, but probably not for those designs.

My (probably controversial) 2 cents,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Further to finials...

#15

Re: Further to finials...

Jorge

Good exercise!

I like the 2 line and to my eye the detail at he foot wants to be a little further out so it looks "stable"

When the snow flies and I am trap in here I will play...

Thanks for sharing

Jorge

Re: Further to finials...

#16

Re: Go here...

R Henrickson

Thanks

Re: Further to finials...

#17

Ellis-here's my thoughts

John Lucas

I'm simply saying the implied line doesn't have to be on the outside of the piece. I think the implied line can travel up the finial. The vessel shape flows into the base element of the finial and then on upward. It's just another way of looking at it.

Re: Further to finials...

#18

Ellis Walentine

Ah, yes

Ellis Walentine

Now I see where you're going with this, John. I like the way you've drawn it. It now occurs to me that Cindy's implied lines have mostly to do with determining the diameters of the major finial elements. When it comes to visualizing the overall flow of the piece, the line up through the finial probably describes the flow even better.

Thanks,

Ellis

Re: Further to finials...

#19

Ellis Walentine

Good suggestions

Ellis Walentine

I see what you mean about deepening the cove, Brad. You lost me with the talk about reverse curves and tighter near the top. And what the heck is lenticular? (I know, google it.:)

Thanks for the input.

Ellis

Re: Further to finials...

#20

Ellis Walentine

Thanks again

Ellis Walentine

Good thinking to refer to Cindy's slides. I don't know if she'd agree with you -- or whether there is any absolute correctness to any finial shape, even vis a vis the vessel it's married to -- but I do see what you're talking about. Some pretty nuanced stuff there, and further proof that the devil of finials is in the details.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Further to finials...

#21

Re: Ah, yes

Dan Oliphant

Ellis, this has been one of the better discussions that have surfaced in quite some time. Is there some way to merge this discussion and Cindy's PDF file??

Re: Further to finials...

#22

Ellis Walentine

PDF file of this discussion *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

I have saved this discussion as a PDF which you may download if you like.

Ellis


PDF archive of this discussion