Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

hollow form speeds

Posts

hollow form speeds

#1

hollow form speeds

darrin hill

trying to figure out safe speeds for turning hollowforms... anyone know of a formula for size of form = speed?

or a website?

tried looking for one, but didnt find one that made sense..

Re: hollow form speeds

#2

Re: hollow form speeds

John Lucas

I turn them the same speed as bowls unless there are a lot of voids then I slow down. That's when I'm hollowing. The outside I do the same as bowls. Since I hollow from the end I'm well out of the lone of fire. The most dangerous time for me is turning the outside or sanding because it's impossible to stay out of the line of fire 100 percent of the time while doing those two operations.

Re: hollow form speeds

#3

Steven Antonucci

A balancing act of speed in hollowing.

steven antonucci

If you turn the speed up to hollow, you cut quicker. If you cut quicker, you fill the inside quicker too, so you have to turn the lathe off sooner. Also the faster the lathe spins, the more it plasters things inside to the wall, making it harder to get that one last cut before blowing out shavings.

I usually hollow out between 700-1400 rpm. Faster when the interior is opened up because I don't fill the space as quickly. Speed doesn't mean you finish any faster because you spend more time with the lathe off removing shavings and less time cutting them, but it's the same amount of stuff that needs to come out no matter how fast you spin it.

Steve

Re: hollow form speeds

#4

Lyle Jamieson

Re: hollow form speeds

Lyle Jamieson

I do not have an RPM indicator on my lathe so Im not sure and it is not an important issue. You are correct it is a moving target because of the diameter of the piece. A small lidded box might be 2,000 to 3,000 rpm and a 10 inch diameter vessel might be 500-1000 rpm. I like to turn faster then most turners. Faster is better, and easier, but you must pay attention to details and be using sound chucking (not with a chuck) methods and not use crappy wood. I do bowls etc and the outside of hollow forms at the highest safe speed I can turn. For the inside hollowing, I slow down a bit. With sound bridges around voids and natural edges, it is better to keep the speed up so the voids go by the tool cutter faster and you dont get into a bouncing cut mode. DIT-DIT-DIT-DIT is better and easier then TUNKA-TUNKA.

Re: hollow form speeds

#5

Re: A balancing act of speed in hollowing.

Craig Daymon

Your logic doesn't quite hold. (Except in the case you mentioned where things stick to the wall more.) There is the same amount of material inside whether spinning fast or slow. If spinning fast allows you to remove the material faster, this is where you will save some time by spinning faster. Removing the waste should take the same amount of time either way. You should not have to turn the lathe off and on more often if spinning fast, only more frequently as it will be filling up faster. Hence, you will complete the form faster if spinning it faster. (Again, aside from the case where things stick to the walls.)

-Craig

Re: hollow form speeds

#6

Re: hollow form speeds

eliot d

I'm probably going to sound high- handed but I hope you won't take it that way. I don't think there are too many serious hollow turners who worry much about a formula for speed. (My mustard monster doesn't even have a RPM readout.) The main idea is to get the wood off and feel safe while doing it. So moderate speed-- perhaps a bit slower than for a similar sized bowl. And a lot depends on whether or not you are holding the tool by hand, with an arm brace, or a constrained system of some kind. Even more so -- what kind of piece are you turning? I mean does it have voids, for example? Also, are you using a kind of scraper(inside), a ring tool, what? Also, how are you holding the piece on the lathe? Chuck, flange with screws,how? Frankly, most of my mishaps have happened while sanding! Oh, yes, I forgot, also watch out when using a constrained system with a laser dot -- if the dot isn't positioned just right( they can vibrate and wander to a new position) -- you can easily cut the inside larger than the outside! Good luck!

Re: hollow form speeds

#7

Re: hollow form speeds

darrin hill

just working on my mimosa hollow form.. it's about a 12" wide and 15" deep... using a jamison hollowing tool...

just when i do the outside first, and if i dont have time to finish i coat with parafin around the endgrain, and i come back the next day, it's warped a bit and when i put on a steady rest it tends to wobble... and i dont want to have to go back and redo the outside every time i return to the piece..

and im using a supernova chuck with 130mm jaws..

Re: hollow form speeds

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: hollow form speeds

Lyle Jamieson

In my opinion thats a no-no. The laser should not move for any reason while hollowing. If you have a laser system that moves on you in use, you should replace it with a good laser measuring system. Life is too short to have the stress of going through the side of a vessel after you have worked hours on it.

Re: hollow form speeds

#9

Re: hollow form speeds

john lucas

Darrin I use a plastic bag over the turning if I'm going to have to leave it, even just long enough to go into the house to go to the bathroom. I have left things overnight without them moving. If you leave it several days it will start to mold so don't do that.

Re: hollow form speeds

#10

Steven Antonucci

I have 1000 data points (vessels) backing me up.

steven antonucci

Assume the following 2 scenarios: Vessel hollowed at 700 RPM and 1400RPM (2X) the RPMs.

You make one cut in either vessel. A certain amount of material is pased over the tool tip. The faster vessel cuts more wood because more wood has been exposed to cutting. There are more shaving inside. The slower vessel takes a second pass with the tool to create "the same" amount of internal shavings.

At 1400rpm, you make one less cut, but you spend 2x the time cleaning out the shavings because the centripital force has plastered them against the walls 4x as hard (it's a square function). The slower speed doesn't pack the shavings as tightly, so they shavings are removed more easily.

In addition, the ball of shavings at a higher speed can easily "coagulate" inside the vessel and push your tool backwards, smashing that opening that you worked so hard to perfect. Or so I have ben told...

I can't say that it's an exact science, but the faster I spin a hollowform, the more time I spend in ejecting shavings. There is a direct correllation. The time I make in cutting faster is lost to clean out. Wet wood makes it worse. Using a bowl gouge to cut the bottom inside of a vessel might take 5 seconds of cutting and 2 minutes of pulling out noodles...

Steve

Re: hollow form speeds

#11

Steven Antonucci

Dunk it in a bucket of water if you cannot finish


Re: hollow form speeds

#12

Re: I have 1000 data points (vessels) backing me u

Craig Daymon

So you're saying that wet or dry, your experience has been that it will stick to the walls. Well,...if you read what I wrote, sticking to the walls was the one issue where I said it might cause a faster speed to slow the process.

This has not been my experience. I have also seen Lyle demonstrate, using the Hunter tip on his hollowing tool, hollow at a very quick rate without any delay that could be tied to speed.

Re: hollow form speeds

#13

Steven Antonucci

It's more than just wet/dry

steven antonucci

The interior cavity is only big enough to hold so much material. If I cut it 2X as fast, I fill it 2X as fast, but I only cut for a second or two. It is not a zero sum game.

If I think about the two activities:

Time spent cutting is a function of the size of the interior cavity, the amount of stuff I can "eject" while cutting, and the type of shaving I am creating. I may be able to cut for as little as 10 seconds or as long as 30 seconds depending upn the tool I am using and the shaving it produces.

Time spent clearing is a function of how much material I cut, how densely packed it is, how big the interior cavity is, and how wide my opening is. I have made vessels where the mouth was wide enough to put your hand inside to grab a handful of shavings, but a compressor couldn't eject them until you did that, so you had to wait for the lathe to spin down. (I count that as clearing time, not cutting time).

I would estimate that 80% of the time in hollowing is spent clearing shavings and not cutting. I doubt that it's 50/50 or even close, so reducing the 20% to 10% most likely makes the 80% grow to 90%...

Short version: I turn the insides faster to get a better cut, not to speed up the process...

Steve

Re: hollow form speeds

#14

Re: Dunk it in a bucket of water if you cannot fin

john lucas

Steve I don't agree with that although I have not tried it. the wood is usually not that wet and I would think that dunking it in water would change the Moisture content and may make it move in other ways. the plastic bag sort of keeps it in a state on suspended animation, at least for a day or so.

Re: hollow form speeds

#15

Steven Antonucci

Works like the bag, without the mold

steven antonucci

the trade-off is that you get soaked if you take it out of the bucket and put it right on the lathe. I've also used Saran Wrap and the bag, but it's been a very long time since I couldn't get something on and off the lathe in one sitting.

Steve

Re: hollow form speeds

#16

Re: Works like the bag, without the mold

darrin hill

well.. apparantly mimosa not only makes me sneeze, but its harder than concrete...

i've spent 2 days hollowing (about 9pm-2am.. ) and it's still only about half done.. and the bits are sharp... so i dunno...

usually i can do something in the same day.. just not this..

Re: hollow form speeds

#17

Steven Antonucci

Something is wrong...

steven antonucci

I suspect there is something odd going on? It's pretty hard for me to digest that you turned it for 5 hours for each of the past 2 days and you are still not done? I've turned lots of things, all freehand, and I can't recall the last project that I took 10 hours to hollow and still wasn't done?

Can you post a picture?

Steve

Re: hollow form speeds

#18

Re: Something is wrong...

John Lucas

I agree with Steve. I've turned Mimosa and found it to be easy to turn. Certainly not in the same category as things like Pecan and Locust. We need to work on your tool techniques if it's that hard to turn.

Re: hollow form speeds

#19

Brad Vietje

Re: Something is wrong...

Brad Vietje

Darrin,

I agree that this shouldn't be so slow; even though I've never used Mimosa, I have turned a lot of hollow forms, usually hand-held, but also with a stabilized rig like yours.

Make sure you are not cutting with the tip too low. That would expose very little cutting edge to the spinning wood, or possibly just rub the inside curve against the base of the bevel. Cutting below the center is dangerous, especially if the inner curve starts to match the angle of the bevel on the tips... I thing BANG! explains it pretty well.

I tend to cut with the tip a little higher than most -- a little above center -- and only try to cut at the center line (widest part) when approaching final wall thickness. I'm only talking 3/8" above center or so, and never, NEVER below center. You can also draw a sketch of the inside curve roughly to scale, and look at the angle of the bevel ground on your cutting tips -- if too steep (blunt?) the bevel may be banging on the wood more than the cutting edge.

I'm experienced at this stuff, but Lyle is the real master, so do what he says! 8)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT