Re: scary sharp on a lathe?
Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV
In the past I built a powered version of a scary sharp. It work extremely well. I used 3/8" plastic acrylic disks. If it is cast acrylic, you are fine for flatness. If it is extruded acrylic, it likely is not flat due to the stretching of the extrusion process.
FWIW, my plastic disk sat in a 'dish' as it was mounted horizontally. I have 10-12 disks, each with a different grit, including brown paper and felt with rouge. The dish was made of HDPE (because I had some) with the matting used in RV's to keep dishes from sliding around. The dish was driven by the motor shaft. A dish turned out of MDF with 120 grit sandpaper glued in the bottom would work as well.
Had never thought about making it vertical for the lathe. Presents new problems. Might make the dish vacuum mounted... hmmm.... not! I have enough to do.
I took the system apart because I wanted it to also be reversable. Then started the moves over the last seven years, from CA to AZ to a half dozen different places during seminary, then back to AZ and now to NV where I hope to get my shop back running. And now I also have several other sharpening options, including the Home Depot WorkSharp debacle, which is still in the box!