Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

scary sharp on a lathe?

Posts

scary sharp on a lathe?

#1

scary sharp on a lathe?

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

I was thinking of purchasing the WS3000 sharpening system mostly to sharpen chisels and plane irons. If you think about it, though, the WS3000 is basically a motorized scary sharp idea. So I had a bit of a brainstorm; why not turn some flat disks that I can adhere sanding disks to and use right on the lathe with variable speed, numerous grits,reverse direction for knives, etc. What do you think?

Has anyone done it? Does it work well? What material would you use for the disks?

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#2

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

john lucas

That's exactly how I learned to sharpen when I got my shopsmith. As you noticed you can vary the speed simply by moving the tool closer to the center. When I had high carbon steel tools this was a big advantage because I was less likely to burn tools.

The biggest disadvantage was the wear of the disc but then that was before they came out with the ceramic discs.

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Lyle Jamieson

John, do you sharpen that way now? If no, why not??

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#4

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

john lucas

I don't sharpen that way now for 2 reasons. first is the sandpaper wears out fairly quickly and has to be replaced. The second is simply I don't have a convenient way to mount the disc so it can be used at a moments notice.

On the shopsmith the disc fit on the outboard side which was convenient at the time. today it wouldn't be because I use my hand wheel constantly and would be constantly frustrated with a big disc out there.

I believe the belt sanders are a better choice for sandpaper sharpening than discs. The belts run cooler, you have more surface area to wear out and changing belts takes just seconds. I've looked at this possibility a lot and may change to that some day. Right now the grinder is just too easy although I would like to be able to change grits really quick.

The downside to the belts and discs for sharpening skews, is that I like my bevels concave on my skew so I can just hone the edge with a diamond hone. I think it's easier keeping the skew sharp this way and the 2 point reference of a concave surface makes it easier to keep the edge accurate and sharp. One of the things I'm looking at is building my own knife sander. If I do that I'll have a large wheel and could sharpen on the flat platten or sharpen on the wheel which would give me both possibilities. That new sharpener that Stuart Batty is marketing is very interesting but I'm sure I've bought cars that were less expensive that thing will be. :)

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#5

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

robo hippy

The Work Sharp system will work. Love their motto: A dull chisel is just a screw driver. I would consider that type of set up to be more of a 'sharpens every thing in the shop' tool. I had considered the abrasive disc set up for the lathe, but came to the conclusion that having a dedicates sharpening station was far more efficient. My grinders are for my turning tools. You don't need scary sharp for lathe tools. I don't use a skew much though. I would agree that a belt would be more effective for lathe tools.

robo hippy

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Lyle Jamieson

I agree, thanks for the clarification. I have tried a belt sharpening system that is already on the market at a symposium, and it would not do my grind. The housing got in the way to sweep the grind back the way I like it. I learned how to sharpen before there were jigs but I like the jig systems on a grinder because it is faster and takes off less steel then hand sharpening. With a disk or belt you would have to buitd a jig that would do a variety of shaped tools or resort to hand held sharpening again. Why try to re-invent a better mouse trap.

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#7

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

john lucas

Lyle I have a Delta 2" belt grinder. someone asked if you could use the Oneway Wolverine on it so I gave it a try. I simply made up a V shaped jig that hung down from the original tool rest holes. It worked pretty well.

The knife sander I plan to build would give me complete access to the belt either above the main wheel where it will have a flat platten or down on the wheel where you could hollow grind. I haven't designed any jigs for it yet but was thinking about something similar to the Tormek bar system.

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Lyle Jamieson

I agree that it would be good for knife sharpening, but why mess with it for turning uses. not a queation just my opinion.

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#9

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

eliot d

Actually, I always sharpen lathe tools using the Wolverine.

I'm talking mostly about the large flat part of a chisel, which I find kind of laborious to flatten with water stones.

I have something called the Jool Tool, which some people think is a toy. but it's not. It's actually a lot like the WS3000 in that you hold the tool below the surface of the rotating "Ninja" sanding disk and look down through the rotating disk. The problem with it is that it's very difficult to get the flat part of the chisel exactly flat on the rotating disk; so you can easily round over the sharp edge. I thought I would have more control on my lathe. I can't see that things would be any worse as far as wear, etc. goes than the WS 3000, since I could presumably use whatever they use.

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#10

Harry Robinette

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

harry robinette

Sorby made the system your talking about maybe 7 or 8 years ago,I was told that the English still use it.

They work pretty good I used one when I demo'd at somewhere that wasn't a turning club. I don't care for the flat grind much but it's a lot easier to carry then a grinder.

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#11

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Don Evans

I tryed that many years ago, long before all the systems that are available today. Thing I didn't like most was I prefer a hollow grind on lathe tools. I also carve, hand and power, so it worked ok for carving tools.

One thing is you have to look at this subject in 2 ways.

One is shaping a new tool or a damaged tool

the other is SHARPENING a tool.

For chisels and carving tools the sharpest system I have I made myself, it is a variable speed motor (not really necessary a 1725 rpm will work) with a hard felt wheel and green chromium oxide. After truing the wheel round wet a paper towel with mineral oil and dab it on the felt wheel to just get it damp. Then dress it with the oxide. Nothing works better for keeping tools sharp. I've never used a stone since!

My pocket knive is sharper than a new razor blade and it only takes 3 to 4 seconds.

For shaping, I use the grinder, then straight to the honing wheel. A tool off the grinder of course takes longer than 3 seconds to get all the marks out, but the honing wheel is still much faster than any other system.

Back to the sandpaper on dish on lathe, when I did it that way, I used plywood with the little 1/4" diameter mandrels. These where held in lathe with a drawbar and 1/4" collet. I had several disk each with different grit paper. PSA worked best for ease of changing, with variable lathe you don't have to concern yourself with disk size but optimum speed would be about 1400 rpm at point on disk you are using.

Don

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#12

want to try all the sharpening options? *LINK*

john lucas

The Nova Comet 11 has outboard accessories. I had the original Nova comet and it was a spectacular lathe. the new one has more power and variable speed plus all these outboard accessories to help you sharpen or sand work. I saw this machine earlier this year and love the attachments.


http://www.teknatool.com/products/lathes/CometII/Nova_CometII.htm

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#13

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

eliot d

Don, How interesting! I have exactly the hard felt wheel I think you're describing( but I use stainless steel grey honing stuff instead of the green.) I agree there is nothing faster and better for honing. Everything comes off shiny as a mirror! BUT -- I don't see a good way to use it on the large flat part of a chisel. Especially if it's kind of worn or even new but not really flat. For that it would seem I'm back to the stones or some version of scary sharp. Do you think it would be possible to somehow use the flat part of the hard felt wheel?

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#14

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Don Evans

Well Eliot, we are back to my other message, there is shaping and there is sharpening.

Your question about "not flat" is a shaping step and cannot be done with the honing method.

Afraid you have no chose in your example but to grind or stone or sandpaper (scary sharp at lest the first steps) then jump to the honing.

As far as using the felt wheel, I don't have problem with running the wide blade back and forth on the front edge of the wheel. Don't have to use the side of it.

I do this with a jig that uses a round bar (just like the Tormek) to rest the blade on while I run it on the felt wheel. I made it this way:

Attach a metal plate in front and to the side of the wheel. Take one of the magnetic stands that you use with a machinist gauge (those round ones that measure in thousands of inch) Take the gauge off and use the magnet stand with round bar in front of wheel. This stand allows you up and down in and out adjustment to make it parallel with the wheel.

If you are not familiar with these gauges let me know and I'll point you to one with a link and or post a picture of my setup.

Don

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#15

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

eliot d

Even though I do have a hard felt wheel, I couldn't resist fooling around a bit. So I turned a MDF disk really flat and treated the surface with oil and the green rouge- like stuff. I then put the lathe in reverse and held the flat wide part of the chisel at about 12 o'clock against the flat part of the spinning disk.(So the sharp edge is facing away from me.) It woks ALMOST perfectly: the problem is that I always manage to get a tiny bit of round over. The chisel is still incredibly sharp and works fine. But, I suppose to be a stickler, I would like the flat face of the chisel to be totally flat. There has to be some sort of jig that would prevent ANY round over. Can you think of something? My next try will be to fasten an emery abrasive to such a disk and see if I can't shape it totally flat before I hone. I guess , if all fails, I'm back to water stones!

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#16

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Please point and post, Don. For us lurkers.

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#17

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Don Evans

Hi Eliot & Carol:

I do the same experimenting too. Cannot help it!

First the round over you are concerned about, THAT IS ACTUALLY a good thing!!

That bit of round over will eliminate the necessity of honing the inside of a gouge..

How about that? I learned this from a world famous carver who is now in her 80's named Needra Hall. It doesn't dull the edge because there is no pressure there from the wheel.

Relish the roll over, don't try to eliminate it.

I didn't understand until now that you had switched to talking about the "back" of the blade on a chisel, missing that somewhere. Anyway, I do that with a 1/4" thick glass plate and psa sandpaper and honing oil. I don't use stones for anything except one on grinder for turning tools and repair of damage edges. I don't really have much problem with damaged edges cause I treat my tools with great respect, you only drop one and stick it in your foot one time per life!

MDF makes a great wheel also. If you want to improve it a bit true up a clean one then flock it with felt. You can actually buy these made that way from Needra's web site but they are expensive and us woodturners can make them where carvers don't have the equipment so they buy them.

Woodturners don't generally know how to sharpen things to the degree that carvers do. In carving you learn how to really make something sharp or you give up the hobby from flustration. (did I miss spell that, doesn't look right?)

One final word, the sharpest edge isn't always a good thing. I know, sounds crazy right?

But a really sharp edge gets dull really fast so in woodturning you don't need that sharpness that you do on blades that are driven by hand. If you do have that edge and keep it, you'll end up honing more than cutting wood and you don't need it on turning.

My turning tools go from the grinder straight to the lathe but I do have tools that seldom if ever see the grinder. They are my 1/16" wide parting tool and my bedan. These two tools only see a hand held diamond 600 grit hone. The bedan is one from Escoulon from France and it is forged like Ninji swords are made, different metals forged and folded over and over, it cut like nothing else I've ever seen. This particular bedan never gained the respect here in USA that it deserves. Unfortunately most turners who have them don't know how to use them correctly. They are used similiar to a skew but tool rest position etc are very important for it.

Think I covered your question, if you have more, let me know. Hope I have learned something in almost 35 years turning, 10 carving. I'm not close to Wally though in time.

Don

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#18

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

eliot d

Don, I never dreamed that that slight rollover could be a good thing! By the way, all along I have only been talking about wood chisels -- not turning tools. These I simply sharpen on a regular grinder using the Wolverine. Well, not quite: I sometimes use a Tormec. but I found it too slow. What I did was to purchase a second Tormec tool bar and set it up at the regular 1750 grinder so I could do most of the work there using the same Tormec jigs and then finish up at the Tormec. ( I once asked a rather famous turner[can't remember his name - from England] if he ever sharpened with a Tormec. He said he would do it only if serving a five year stretch!) I also have a Bedan, and I must say that I, too, don't sharpen it on anything that would result in a hollow grind. For some reason, I can't get it out of my head that the bevel on a Bedan has to be flat. I'll have to try fastening felt to the face of MDF. Do you just glue it on? There's probably a preferred way. Do you know it? By the way I just happen to have a really thick piece of heavy Plexiglass lying around. Do you think it would be better that MDF for what we're talking about? Certainly do enjoy your posts!

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#19

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

In the past I built a powered version of a scary sharp. It work extremely well. I used 3/8" plastic acrylic disks. If it is cast acrylic, you are fine for flatness. If it is extruded acrylic, it likely is not flat due to the stretching of the extrusion process.

FWIW, my plastic disk sat in a 'dish' as it was mounted horizontally. I have 10-12 disks, each with a different grit, including brown paper and felt with rouge. The dish was made of HDPE (because I had some) with the matting used in RV's to keep dishes from sliding around. The dish was driven by the motor shaft. A dish turned out of MDF with 120 grit sandpaper glued in the bottom would work as well.

Had never thought about making it vertical for the lathe. Presents new problems. Might make the dish vacuum mounted... hmmm.... not! I have enough to do.

I took the system apart because I wanted it to also be reversable. Then started the moves over the last seven years, from CA to AZ to a half dozen different places during seminary, then back to AZ and now to NV where I hope to get my shop back running. And now I also have several other sharpening options, including the Home Depot WorkSharp debacle, which is still in the box!

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#20

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Don Evans

Eliot;

I don't like the idea of trying to use plexi on it's edge if that is way you are asking about.

Fortunately Carol chimed in with a good way to use it though. Using the flat side of it isn't a problem in my opinion the way she is doing it.

I think the MDF on edge would be much better & safer.

I hate to say it, but I really goofed up on my other message. I DID NOT mean to say the flocked wheel is better. I would rate it equal with bare wood surface. I need to proof read better and not do this when in a hurry.

Sorry I gave you wrong idea. I bought one of the flocked wheels from Nedra and it worked good but when I wore it out I turned my own wheels out of balsa. Took 2, 3/4th thick pieces glue them back to back and turned them, one with flat edge and another with concave edge for carving tools. Learned that I didn't really need the concave one as I can roll the tool on flat edge without any problem. It doesn't cut as deep nor as fast as a grinding wheel so you don't end up with the facets.

By the way, on the Bedan, the angled side goes UP, sounds like you are calling that the bevel and using it down? The tool rest is set even with the top of the turning wood. If you are using it angle down that's ok but not the way I learned how from the Frenchman and they are the one's that came up with this tool I'm told. What works for you I say is correct as long as it is safe. I really like the bedan for spindle work as you can turn anything with it and never change tools. You can also turn it on it's side and use it is a scraping mode. Do that and get a half V flip it 180 deg and form a complete V. Back on the rest with angle up rotate handle to right, lift right side of point slightly and slide down wood with left side of point touch and you have a skew and extremely smooth cut surface. There isn't anything it will not do in spindle mode except make the coffee.

Don

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#21

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Don Evans

Carol that horizontal scary sharp sounds interesting, how fast did you have it turning?

Why, if you have it do you want the Workshop? What debatical?

Don

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#22

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

Gosh, I would have to remember something from over 7 years ago, Don. Likely the slowest motor I had at the time and I 'geared' it down with pulleys. What the final RPM was I do not remember. I still have most of the system boxed up. The motor has been repurposed though. I just need a reversible motor to rebuild it.

I got the Worksharp because it was a deal I could not pass up. Still haven't used it, but then I have done very little woodworking since. I use a 1" belt sander with LV's blue ziconian belts for the lathe tools. I m happy with that arrangement, but will use the Worksharp for straight cutting edges.

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#23

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

eliot d

Turns out that what I thought was plexiglas is lucite -- about two inches thick.

I do use the bedan with the bevel up, but I still call that part of the tool the bevel.

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#24

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

eliot d

Well, I keep going. Can't stop! I turned another disk really flat and glued on a fairly course grit of emery cloth. Just used ordinary yellow woodworkers glue overnight. I find that it flattens the face of a bench chisel like nobody's business! Then I move on to the honing disk I made earlier and I don't see any reason to use water stones ever again! I might anyhow because I have them and they were expensive(Norton up to 8000) -- perhaps when I'm in a kind of Zen mood. I got into all this because I picked up a set of old Craftsman bench chisels at an antique store in Connecticut and just had to try making them look and work like fine tools. They do!

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

#25

Re: scary sharp on a lathe?

Don Evans

Congrat! Love it when a plan comes together ( A Team, Hannabil always said)