Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

Posts

Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#1

Steven Antonucci

Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

steven antonucci

If you had some time to kill, the demos that Richard Raffan did have been posted on YouTube. Just watching how he cuts a bead in a bowl is worth the price of admission!

Steve


This should get you started...

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#2

Don Leydens

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium

Don Leydens

You're absolutely right, Steve! I was at the demo and couldn't wait to try his beading technique when I got home. It worked like a charm and is easy to do. I'll never make beads any other way now. Certainly worth the price of admission. It was a great show.

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#3

Betty Scarpino

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium

Betty Scarpino

I'm curious as to who posted the videos? Do you know if tere they taken with Richard's permission and posted with his consent?

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#4

Steven Antonucci

I don't know nothing...

steven antonucci

I wasn't at the symposium, and merely posted the link based upon the fact that it was an interesting video. Judging by the camera position, I would suspect that it was someone associated with the symposium as Richard is working with that person to direct the best camera angle, etc.

That said, I am also not privy to what the contract Richard signed allows. Clearly, videography doesn't appear to be an issue, since this was show with his consent and direction. If it was my symposium and my contract, I would think that the content of the video would be my property and that Richard wouldn't have a legal right to allow or disallow posting it online. He may not be a fan of the idea, but I highly doubt that he gets a vote.

I understand that Richard's livelihood comes from this type of work, but I can also assume that he was compensated for his appearance. I personally believe that the world is moving towards a very different knowledge model than "pay for hire" and that professional turners who have made a living selling DVD's and books are going to need to adapt in the "time of YouTube" or risk seeing a portion of their livelihood move to the open source model.

But back to your original question: I don't know who posted it, but they posted lots of videos from the Symposium. I assume that they had some property rights to do so, as they appear to be affiliated with the group that sponsored the event. As the owner of the content, I also assume that they do not need Richard's permission, but i have no direct or indirect knowledge whether or not they asked for his consent.

Steve

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#5

Re: I don't know nothing...

John Lucas

This could go down the wrong path and get nasty pretty quickly so lets be careful. My take is simply this. If you are demonstrating for an organization they should ask up front if you mind being taped and what the rights are. You should have the right to say no. Many organizations use cameras for better viewing and don't record the event. I can see where this gets sticky. If a club is recording the event so members can check it out that's one thing. If the club is making money by renting the tapes then it would seem that you should ask the demonstrator if that is OK.

I am certainly not a even remotely a legal expert but if I'm creating and selling videos I would not want freebie's out on youtube. I think it needs to be something stated up front when signing the contract to do these symposiums.

As a photographer when I shoot something I do own the rights. However when you shoot a person you and intend to sell those images you have to get them to sign a model release. I think this is similar to taping a instructor and should be a common courtesy.

I hope we can discuss this without it going down the tubes. I know this kind of topic can get bad really quick.

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#6

Steven Antonucci

I agree with you (or you agreed with me?)

steven antonucci

I was merely pointing out that the "shooter" owned the video, not the people in it and that it was clear he knew he was being filmed as he was directing the camera.

On the subject of model releases if something is being filmed or photographed for profit, it could get sticky, as there are ways to monetize videos on YouTube. I am pretty sure that you wouldn't make much, but it's like a little bit of speeding... laws are pretty unforgiving.

In any case, it appears that the video has been made private. I tried to watch the bead rolling technique again this AM after failing last night to replicate it at the lathe... I'll just have to do it the old way.

It is a new world out there. There is an opportunity to make money by giving things away... if you are smart. I haven't figured out how to do it yet, so I guess I'm not that smart.

Steve

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#7

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium

Bob Verne

The videos of Richard Raffan's demos at the NC Woodturning Symposium were recorded from the feed projected to the audience at the Symposium. They were posted on YouTube without the permission of either Richard or the Symposium Board of Directors. Once the Board became aware of the posting we contacted the YouTube poster who graciously removed the videos from public access.

The Symposium Board has apologized to Richard for this incident and will take steps to prevent it from happening in the future.

Bob Verne

Director, NC Woodturning Symposium

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#8

Bob   Thanks for the clarification


Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#9

Steve- I haven't figured out how to make money

john lucas

not matter what I do. Giving it away free didn't work. :)

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#10

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium

Craig Daymon

Hey Bob, I have a question. I watched a couple of the videos and learned lots from the nice camera work with the close ups of the tool. The audio on the other hand was not very good at all, aside from the Mark St. Leger video that was very clear. (Same poster, not sure if it was the same event. It was the same shop.)

The question is whether the poster pulled all of the videos. There was a 2 hour video of Ray Key and the one of Mark St. Leger that I already mentioned, which also ran about 2 hours. There were several others as well that were all over an hour in length. Certainly, if any of these are posted WITH permission, they would be worthwhile to view.

Thanks in advance,

Craig

P.S. Looks like your group threw a great event.

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#11

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium

Bob Verne

Craig, the YouTube poster did not have permission from the Symposium to post any videos taken at that event. We asked him to remove them all and I believe he has done so. He has also posted videos of demos from other events, e. g., the Ray Key demo, (Hey, there was even a Bob Verne demo there, of all things!) but we can't comment on those.

Thanks for your nice comment on the Symposium. I had a great time and heard positive comments from a lot of others, too. On to 2013!

Bob Verne

NC Woodturning Symposium

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#12

Steven Antonucci

An interesting aside (legally)...

steven antonucci

To which I do not know the answer. Perhaps you can comment?

Assuming that the person who shot the video was the same person that posted the video, do they actuall require permission to post the video if it was done "on their own?" (i.e. he was not hired to record the video by the group sponsoring)

I have been in the audience where a prominent turner stopped his demo to announce that he would not proceed until a person in the audience stopped recording him. He did it politely, but firmly...explaining that he sold videos as part of his livelihood.

In this "time of YouTube", should conference organizers consider recording the sessions as a threat to their attendance, or a marketing device to drive attendance? Should their be explicit, consistent contract language provided by the AAW about what attendees can and cannot do to avoid a scene like described above? Should that language cover posting videos online?

My view is that if the poster captured that video and there was nothing prohibiting his posting it, then there was no recourse for its removal if the posted had decided to leave it as a public video (BTW- it has not been removed, only made private... so the poster now controls who gets to see it, but it is still there...)

Fine lines...

Steve

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#13

Steven Antonucci

Open Source model

steven antonucci

There are communities of people contributing to open source programming. These folks have existed for years. They write code that does stuff that they believe people need to have done. Some ask for donations, like the guy who created WinZip, but you can use their software license freely. (NicoMak Computing/WinZip got acquired for a ton of money)

Woodturners also operate in an open source model. We answer questions on WoodCentral. We post videos on how to sharpen, make a bowl, or design your own tools. Some woodturners commercialize this stuff into DVD's.

The question becomes can you monitize a higher value service by giving away a commodity? If you made most of your money by teaching, could you get more students by posting videos that showed how to make a bowl? If your goal is to drive attendance to a Symposium, could you get a bigger audience if they saw the quality of product? It's not always black and white.

I know that most turners are older men. If woodturning wants to attract a younger crowd, I think that the open source model is far more attractive. There is a huge difference between attending a Raffan demo and watching a YouTube video of the same demo. Giving access to the video might upsell the higher value product.

Steve

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#14

cannot see it!!

Jorge

Got a "this is private"...

Re: Raffan Demos on YouTube from the NC Symposium *LINK*

#15

Steven Antonucci

Was public, then made private