Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

I can do it but can't explain it.....

Posts

I can do it but can't explain it.....

#1

I can do it but can't explain it.....

robo hippy

I had a mentoring session today, and encountered one of those things I do automatically, but can't explain exactly what, why, and how I fix some thing. You know, going down the outside of the bowl, finish cut with a gouge, and you start to bounce/get run out. It isn't from run out in the lathe. It isn't from a loose chuck or attachment, it comes from the difference in how the gouge cuts through end grain and side grain. The more you fight it, the worse it gets.

I know I come back and nibble away at the high spot to get a fresh start.

I know I don't use a death grip on the tool.

I know I gently 'rub' the bevel, not ride the bevel.

I know I drive with my body movement, and steer with body rotation.

I know I keep very light pressure with my left hand on the gouge metal, and almost no pressure/contact with the tool rest.

I just can't figure out how to explain how it all works to get rid of the run out in the bowl.

robo hippy

Re: I can do it but can't explain it.....

#2

Re: I can do it but can't explain it.....

John Lucas

That makes 2 of us. I think you just described it. It seems like it's a combination of light pressure on the tool on the tool rest, light pressure on the bevel and careful control of the handle by moving your body to control both the feed rate and the shape of the bowl. The problem is describing it isn't hard. Doing it is tough because you have to feel it. There is kind of a feel when it's right.

did you mention sound. There is a difference in sound when it's cutting right without the chatter.

Re: I can do it but can't explain it.....

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: It brings up all the discussions about ....

Jesper, Denmark

Tool grinds and presentation. Isn't the fact that noone can see what the tool is doing to the wood? Don't we all look at the other side of the bowl to see the result and use feel to determine when the tool is doing OK and when not?

Re: I can do it but can't explain it.....

#4

But you just did explain it.

Don Orr

Print your post and show it to them. Then show them how you do it-slowly and deliberately. Then have them try it. If it's about the feel then they need to feel it for themselves.

Re: I can do it but can't explain it.....

#5

Re: I can do it but can't explain it.....

GaryG in MD

What you're describing also comes up as "waves" in spindle turning. It's a result of pushing the tool against the wood, or a tool that needs sharpening, or both.

The key, with a sharp tool, is tool control.

Stuart Batty calls it "floating the bevel".

He doesn't "push" the cutting edge against the wood at all.

He controls the tool steel between two fingers, applying equal pressure on both sides, and places the tip 'near' the wood. Then he does all the gentle, body-controlled sideways movement over a well-dressed tool rest, etc.

I've worked to achieve it, and once in a while, I actually get it. Feels great when you're in the zone. ...Gary

Re: I can do it but can't explain it.....

#6

This reminds me of a recent search.

Keith Newton

I was wondering about what causes washboard gravel roads, so I googled the

Physics of washboard roads, and was a bit surprised.

http://throughthesandglass.typepad.com/through_the_sandglass/