Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Bowl sanding problem

Posts

Bowl sanding problem

#1

Bowl sanding problem

Starry S Chan

I finish turned a 10-year old rough turned bowl given to me by a fellow turner. The wood is Russian Olive. I ran into some serious sanding problem.

The grain of this wood is much harder than the wood between grains. I have yet to find a way to sand the surface smooth. I did have success in some areas but I was not able to get the entire surface totally smooth. When I ran my finger across the surface, I can feel the ridges. I tried sanding cross grain and with the grain. The result is the same.

I would appreciate your tips or comments regarding sanding difficult wood.

Starry

Re: Bowl sanding problem

#2

Steve Kubien

Re: Bowl sanding problem

Steve Kubien

I have no experience with Russian Olive but I've encountered what you speak of in some (red) elm and occassionally ash. I don't worry about it and instead, I let it happen. I think it really adds something to the texture of the piece. Just my opinion.

Try a card scraper?

Re: Bowl sanding problem

#3

Re: Bowl sanding problem

Barry Irby

Use fresh really sharp sandpaper and step through the grits quickly.

When sanding oak floors the tendency is to use the sandpaper too long and dull sandpaper tends to cut the soft grain better/faster. The "cure" is to use sharp sandpaper.

I'm guessing the premise would apply to bowls also.

Re: Bowl sanding problem

#4

Re: Bowl sanding problem

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hi Starry,

Are you hand sanding or power sanding?

Dave

Re: Bowl sanding problem

#5

Re: Bowl sanding problem

John Lucas

in my experience it's excessive sanding and too much pressure on the sandpaper that seems to cause the problem. In the last few years I have spent much more time learning to cut clean so that less sanding is required. This usually means less pressure on the bevel, freshly sharpened tools, and either a slower feed rate of the tool, higher speed on the lathe or both.

When you have to start with 120 grit on woods that have widely space summer winter grain it's very difficult not to have the problem you mention. Fresh sandpaper with very light pressure on the paper helps. I like Vince's interface pads because they are fairly firm. Then I use them on mandrels that have a softer 1st layer. The firm pads doesn't dip into the voids as easily and the soft 1st layer helps me reduce the pressure. However if you can start with 180 or 220 the bumps you get will be less from the very start.

Re: Bowl sanding problem

#6

Re: Bowl sanding problem

Starry S Chan

The surface is actually smoother before I sanded it to get rid of tool marks. I also noticed that using light pressure with fresh 320 paper did bring the surface smoother. I am doing hand sanding off the lathe so using 320 grit takes a lot of effort. I probably spent a few hours on sanding this bowl and the surface still has ridges.

I am going to keep this bowl and rework it sometime in the future.

Thanks for your input.

Starry

Re: Bowl sanding problem

#8

Re: Bowl sanding problem

John Lucas

One thing a lot of turners do, and I'm no exception, is to stay with the same grit and fight the wood. Your much better off when you have problems to go back a grit or two, solve the problem and then go up with the finer grits. I fuss at myself every time I see some sanding scratches or a carving defect and sit there with 220 grit or whatever and sand and sand and sand. If I would just go back to 180 or 150 it would only take a few passes and that defect would be gone. Then it just takes a few seconds to step through the grits and clean up those sanding marks. I'm getting better but I have to make myself do it.

I see the same thing with beginners. They have tearout on the bowl and only notice it when they get to 180 or 220. They will sand and sand. If they would simply go back to 120 they could solve the tearout pretty quickly and step back through the grits.