Rob Wallace posted a comment about my video that I shot while roughing out one handed about safety. However, not a single comment posted about safety for the guy turning in Marrakesh with a skew and his foot.
(I'm not picking on you Rob )
Interesting topic, this safety is... (in my Yoda voice)
I didn't see much about the Marrakesh turning video that was a safety issue, except maybe eye protection... or back problems! The guy had his tool well-anchored and wasn't dealing with two or three horsepower of unthinking/indifferent machinery.
On the other hand, I thought you made it clear enough that you didn't routinely turn one-handed, and weren't recommending that others do so.
I've seen, and after seeing how it is done, tried, one hand inside bowl cuts. If the bevel's rubbing and there are no voids, checks or cracks to lose the "bevel rubbing" in, AND the right area of the cutting edge is doing the cutting, it's almost anticlimactic. Of course getting the cut STARTED from the rim is best done with two hands since that's where things can go wrong in a hurry BEFORE the bevel has a surface to ride on.
One handing an outside cut seems a bit riskier - but then I've not seen it done or tried it. Cerrtainly wouldn't try coves or beads or ogees one handed . . .
BTW - there's this camera holder thing that frees up both hands. Think it's called a "tri - pod" - three adjustable legs and a platform with a screw that screws into the bottom of most cameras. The platform to which a camera can be mounted can also be rotated horizontally as well as vertically (swung left or right and tilted forward or backward). Some also permit the camera to be rotated from "landscape" to "portrait" orientation as well as raising and lowering the camera's height using a rack and pinion mechanism. This tripod device is really quite complex yet simple to use - and surprisingly - relatively inexpensive : )
and therein lies the rub. "Somewhere" isn't obvious or easy to get to...
I foresee a spelunking trip in the near future, just so people focus on content, not video quality.
Moreover, I think the point is that the missing left hand = Marrakesh guy's foot = only along for the ride (and not really doing anything)... I don't advocate turning one handed or right footed, but both videos illustrate that the proper presentation of the tool is far more critical than whose name is on it, what kind of steel it is, and yes, even the safety of the turner.
Most of the time, my left hand is on top of the tool just because I have to put it somewhere...
I just want to be sure that while people take the time and effort of making on-line woodturning videos available, they should keep in mind that they need to be done and presented in such a way to make them "recommendable" to woodturners as techniques that can be emulated ("copied") as far as methods and safety are concerned. As I said before, the message & content are great. Whether or not you need it, that left hand on the tool/toolrest to provide stability etc. IS important to a new woodturner to show how it's done correctly and safely.
I want to be able to send links to various new woodturning video clips to all of our chapter members as a "You should watch this....!!" video. I can only do so when what is being shown can be emulated by newcomers (and even veteran turners) as an acceptable method.
Definitely find that tripod! (BTW - I am undergoing a similar "archaeological dig" for a lost piece of ham radio equipment that I KNOW I have around here somewhere....).