Roughing technique video
steven antonucci
Here is a quick video that I shot showing how I rough turn face grain work to round. I used the same cutting technique to finish cut, but with a lot less of the edge engaged.
Steve
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Roughing technique video
steven antonucci
Here is a quick video that I shot showing how I rough turn face grain work to round. I used the same cutting technique to finish cut, but with a lot less of the edge engaged.
Steve
Re: Roughing technique video
robo hippy
I get to be the first to comment? Just luck.
I know that cut works, and it is bevel rubbing, but it makes me nervous. Mostly because you are cutting a bit high on the wing, and it wouldn't take much to have it roll too far and come off the bevel, and roll into the cut with a catch. Has that ever happened to you, or is it more of a problem than I imagine? I tend to roll the flutes over at 90 degrees or so in more of a scraping cut, and no chance of a catch. I really need to practice it. I have used it on twice turned bowls when truing up the outside.
I do like the 1 handed cut. I find myself cutting a lot more with one hand doing all the work, and the second hand doing almost nothing, and not being on the tool rest at all.
I went back and looked at it again. The tool is balanced in that the part that is cutting is directly over the tool rest. Hmmm. Now it makes me wonder why I had a catch once upon a time doing that type of cut.
robo hippy
Re: Roughing technique video
robo hippy
Just went out to the shop and gave it a whirl. Works fine. Can't understand why I had problems with it before. Hmmmmmmm..... Must go lighter pressure, getting burnishing marks.....
robo hippy
Re: Roughing technique video
Jorge
Steve,
That is my technique as well! Great minds, blah, blah, blah.
Re: Roughing technique video
Keith Tompkins
Here's a sketch of two grinds, looking down on both. On the left grind, you can see the grind (highlighted in yellow) is visible, and seems to curl inward. On the right grind, you cannot see any part of the grind, it approaches the flute abrubtly, in a straight line. A tool ground similar to my left image will be controllable using Steve's method, while a grind similar to the one on the right will tend to pull into the cut aggressively without warning. The secret is in the angle the jig's arm is set at. I learned about this years ago from David Ellsworth.
Re: Roughing technique video
Keith Tompkins
Oops, I forgot to mention, look at Steve's grind, you will notice it curls in as I described above!
Re: Roughing technique video
Jorge
Keith,
My grind is like the one in the right, and yes it is very aggressive, but it's great to remove a lot in a hurry, but always with the handle down. And pulling swaying your whole body.
Where you set your jigs arm?
Re: Roughing technique video
Keith Tompkins
HI Jorge, my wolverine jig is set almost in the center of the adjustment, this gives me long wings, yet they still curl inward.
Re: Roughing technique video
john lopez
Good readable discussion and video
thanks for posting .
Bandsaw Blade ? ? ?
Doc Green
Good video! I think I saw something, . . . and it puzzles me.
At 3:29, on the side of the blank, there is what appears to be the imprint of a bandsaw blade. This appears on more than one location on the blank.
What's going on? What made the imprint?
~Doc
Thanks Keith!
Re: Roughing technique video
Lyle Jamieson
Keith, you have it exactly correct the grind that has the wing grind tilted in, will be more controlable...but you have the sharpening description backwards. The jig arm controls the TIP angle, and the sliding arm moving the pivot point in and out will control the SIDE angle. Test it yourself by putting the jig on the gouge and with the grinder off. Put it in place to grind the side wing. Now move the jig arm back and forth, and the side grind changes little. Now in the same position move the basket position closer and now move it away from the grinding wheel. NOW the side grind is changing. The bottom line if you want to change your wings to be more friendly move your sliding arm basket position away from the grinding wheel and you will tilt the wing grind in, like Steve, Keith, David E. or Lyle Jamieson grinds.
This grind is why Steve could hog off with one hand. If you want to white knuckle or bulldoze your way through the wood with brute force without the bevel support, dont change your grind. The trade off is the surface left behind will be much better with the bevel supported slicing cut over the unsuported (actually scraping) brute force method. Once you twist the tool so the bevel no longer is supporting the cut you better be hanging on tightly, you are at the brink of a catch.
Re: Bandsaw Blade ? ? ?
robo hippy
Doc,
Just guessing here, but I have had the same marks on some of my blanks.
Cherry does tend to burn a bit. Having a slightly dull blade can make it burn. Cutting with a blade that is a bit wide for the radius can also get some burn marks. If the kerf closes up at all, you can get some burn marks.
The blade cut marks are similar to the radial stars you can get in the bottom of a bowl, vibration. This could be from a slightly slack blade. The blade could be on the thin side, which would tend to make it vibrate. The blade guide post could be too high. Any, the blade vibration makes for the angles tooth marks instead of being straight up and down. I once saw a turner use a detail/small spindle gouge, on its side to texture the top of a box lid, like a chatter tool.
robo hippy
Re: Roughing technique video
Keith Tompkins
HI Lyle, I'll have to think about that for a while...I'm so used to my set-up, and it works so well, I never change it. I use a grind with very long wings, with a nose angle about 35 degrees, the tool extending 2 1/8" from my jig. So even on an unfamiliar set-up, say a demo, I'll slide the pocket up until my angle matches, and grind the tool; the only difference I find is the wheel diameter affects the amount of curl, but not enough to make much of a difference. I know the distance the tool extends from the jig makes a difference...I'll have to experiment a bit. Thanks.
Re: Roughing technique video Photos?
Stuart Johnson
I'm having a hard time visualizing the edge curl from just seeing the drawing. A few photos showing gouges side by side with the two different grinds as well as the actual Wolverine set up would be a great help.
Re: Roughing technique video
Keith Tompkins
Lyle, Thinking about it, if the angle of my jig's arm remains constant,(which gives me a very long wing) and the angle of the nose is always the same, the only variable is the distance of the pocket from the wheel. So you may be right 
Steve - I think it's time to invest....
Rob Wallace
......in either a tripod or videographer!
Even though you can do it, I don't think one handed turning teaches correct technique, no matter how you can control the gouge, ride the bevel, etc. I couldn't necessarily recommend this to a beginning woodturner as an example of a good "how to" video segment. Being able to suggest (or not) that a newcomer watch a particular video is one of the criteria I use to decide whether an on-line video is "good" or "not so good". WHAT you are showing is great, and is a help to explain the technique - but HOW you are showing it isn't so good as to the value of the video as a teaching tool, IMHO. I don't think you can simply write-off "I'm doing one handed turning because I have to shoot the video" as an acceptable reason for not showing good (and safe) technique. A well placed tripod to support your camera, or a videographer assistant, would allow you to show what you are doing, in a manner that is safe and one that can be emulated by new woodturners. Just my suggestion for improvement (.....and maybe slow down the scrolling text a bit at the end!).
Rob
Re: Roughing technique video
Dennis in Southern Oregon
There are several ways of looking at the effect of the arm angle, depending on what you want to hold constant. If you re-adjust the basket position to keep the same tip angle for every value of arm angle and grind a long side grind, you will find that for any given arm angle the sides will start out "open" near the tip and gradually turn in as you progress outward on the sides. The larger the arm angle, the further out you have to go before the side starts to roll in. What is the correct amount of roll-in is a matter of personal preference. However, too much will leave the outer part of the wings too blunt to cut.
You can observe this effect even on a long fingernail grind on a spindle gouge. If you set the arm angle at the minimum setting you will find that that the wings of a long fingernail grind will curl in so much as to be useless.
Re: Roughing technique video
Lyle Jamieson
Its a little confusing because the set up of the tip grind and the side grind angle needs to be independently set, but one influences the other. In a cold set up, like at a outside demo site, line up the tip angle with with the jig arm, then line up the side angle by moving the basket. Now that you moved the basket the tip angle has to be re-set with the jig arm. Check the basket position again and you will be close. You need to do both the tip and side angles twice to get it right.
Re: Roughing technique video
Lyle Jamieson
There are so many variables it can be really confusing. All influence the grind angles slightly but the adjustment set up I discribe takes all other variables out of the equasion. The tip angle I use is 60+ degrees. It does not matter. I use 2 inch extension. It does not matter. The jig set up will not give you a shorter or longer wing. The long wing is achieved by grinding it back as far as you want it.
So much inconsistant and misleading information has been spread for years its no wonder there is no consensus. Using this foundation you can grind any gouge you have at any tip or side angle you want. The confusion comes when people package together the set up and grinding. They are two independant things. Separate also, in your thinking, the tip angle from the side angle set up positions and it all becomes clear.
I can not repeat this enough. (1) the tip angle is set by moving the jig arm. (2) the side angle is set by moving the basket position.
this should be a thread by itself so everyone can
see it
Re: Roughing technique video
Keith Tompkins
The problem there Lyle is that many turners don't line up the arm with the tip angle...some turners move the arm all the way to the front, some all the way to the rear, without even thinking about why, or what effect it may have on the cutting edge. Invariably, those having trouble with catches have edges that are too abrupt.
My image is of a spindle gouge, You can see how far back I grind the wings, yet the grind curls in. I cannot achieve this grind if the arm setting is moved back too far, no matter what the other settings are. Why, some may ask, do I want such a long grind? I use the long grind like a skew on spindle work, and also for end-grain hollowing.
Re: Roughing technique video
Jorge
Lyle,
Thanks for this bit of info, understanding what every change in the grinding set up has not been easy, when I did arrive at a clean grind, I did stop experimenting and have kept that setting. I will grind a gouge as you say and see what it does.
Thank you
Jorge
Re: Roughing technique video
robo hippy
Well, maybe I should get a platform sharpening video up next. All you have to do is set the angle. Wing sweep and angles are controlled by rolling the tool. So much faster than a jig, so much more versatile, and if you have basic bowl turning tool/gouge techniques, it is really simple.
robo hippy