Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Finish turning problem

Posts

Finish turning problem

#1

Finish turning problem

Starry S Chan

The major problem I sporadically encountered during finish turning is that the rim thickness is not even. It can be off as much as 2mm.

I used a jamb chuck and tail stock to hold a rough turned bowl and true the outside of the bowl, foot and tenon. I then reverse mounted the bowl and established the final wall thickness at the first 1" of bowl. I then proceeded to hollow out the rest of bowl.

I suspect that there may be at least two causes of this problem.

The first possible cause is the shoulder of the tenon is not 100% perpendicular to the axis of the bowl. The second possible cause is that the unevenness is caused by reworking the rim section after the wall is completed. I always used a scraper to clean up the tool marks to minimize sanding.

I often forgot to check whether the rim thickness is even until the inside is completed so I didn't know at what stage of the turning the rim thickness became uneven. I will have to pay more attention to this from now on.

I would appreciate your sharing on how I can eliminate this frustrating problem.

Starry

Re: Finish turning problem

#2

Re: Finish turning problem

Jorge

Starry,

Fact of life, wood moves and that compounds whatever inaccuracies we have in our procedures.

So we have to learn to let it be or try to be on top of it, meaning finish to desired depth as you go, just as we do when making a goblet. Start at the rim and work your way down.

I am not an artiste, just a craftsman that makes bowls that people use and abuse, my work holds soup so to speak, so take my advice with a grain of salt, I don't turn to impress other turners... So I am not worried about a slight unevenness in thickness and never try to turn very thin because when I do the bowls do not sell.

Jorge

Re: Finish turning problem

#3

Re: Finish turning problem

Doug Turner

If your bowl blank is cross grain I believe 2mm movement is to be expected. Temperature and humidity changes can cause this much movement on cross grain bowls that are years old - especially if there is any figure distorting the grain.

I recently toured some woodturning shops in Japan and the best bowls that were being finished with ururshi lacquer (which can last for millinea and hold hot liquids to 400 degrees centigrade) are made almost exclusively from end grain blanks.

I was given a 3" dia tea cup that is the uniform thickness of a eggshell and a matching super thin saucer and both are made from end grain blanks. You can literally hold each of them up to the light and see through them and they are completely concentric.

BTW they are both unsigned. The turner said everyone recogonized his work by the quality, and besides it was to thin to brand a signature into.

Re: Finish turning problem

#4

Re: Finish turning problem

GaryG in MD

Great story. I'd love to hold one of those.

We just had Mike Kehs do a 'thin' demo for us. He does a pretty good job too!

...Gary

Re: Finish turning problem

#5

Re: Finish turning problem

GaryG in MD

There are many possible reasons depending exactly on the details of how you do it, but just let me make this observation.

It is very important to re-turn the outside after you reverse the tenon into the chuck because it will never be perfectly axial after you do -- because the chuck jaws will squeeze the wood unevenly even if you made a perfect tenon. Speaking of which, it IS necessary to make a nearly-perfect tenon, or the situation will be even worse. So first, study your tenon-making technique and make sure the match of the shoulder with the chuck jaw ends is absolutely tight all the way around. If not, redo the tenon. Make sure the shoulder is slightly concave so the jaw ends contact the shoulder perfectly all the way around with no gaps at all.

The first thing to do after you reverse is to return the outside to make it concentric with the new axis. Then you can hollow and get a rim that has uniform thickness all the way around.

Hope this helps... ...Gary

Re: Finish turning problem

#6

Re: Finish turning problem

Charles B. Watson

Try this:

Place the bowl on the jam chuck, true the tenon only, reverse the bowl holding it in a 4 jaw chuck, true the inside where the jam chuck fits, and then reverse the bowl again and shape the outside. Once that is completed, reverse the bowl and finish the inside.

Re: Finish turning problem

#7

Re: Finish turning problem

Jorge

Love the story, would be nice to locate a source of the ururshi lacquer and learn to finish with it.

Re: Finish turning problem

#8

Re: Finish turning problem

john lucas

Everyone is on the right track. First of it's extremely important to have the outside running true. first off I start my bowls between centers usually with the bowl opening toward the headstock. To help center up the bowl when I reverse it I put my drive center in the tailstock. Then I use the tailstock and drive center to push the bowl in the chuck as I tighten it. Oops almost forgot, put the grain 45 degrees to the chuck jaws. In theory each jaw is then pushing against grain that is in the same direction.

If that fails to center perfectly then true up the outside.

I try my best to turn the first inch or more and never go back, not even to shear scrape. If you use proper cutting technique with a sharp tool you should be able to easily sand out any tool marks but in reality with proper cutting you should not get any. After you have cut down about 2 to 3 inches the rim will probably warp a hair which is why I never go back.

If you really want to learn to turn thin take a class from Johannes Michelson or Binh Pho.

Re: Finish turning problem

#9

Re: Finish turning problem

Starry S Chan

Thank you for your input.

I do use the tail stock to press the bowl against the jamb chuck. In theory, the bowl does not need to perfectly mounted to the jamb chuck in order to properly true the outside and the tenon. However, this does minimize the truing effort.

I will pay more attention to cutting of the tenon and true the rim section after I reverse mount the bowl. I think both of these are the key factors to get uniform rim thickness. I will then do a batch of bowls to see whether I can get uniform rim thickness for all of these bowls.

Thanks again,

Starry