Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Paying it forward

Posts

Paying it forward

#1

Ellis Walentine

Paying it forward

Ellis Walentine

Here's a shot of my completed 'Pay it forward" piece. With sublime hindsight, I realize the form isn't as fair as it should be, and neither is the finial, but I can live with the finial now.

There was a major decision point after I sanded the vessel -- what to put on it as a finish. The experiments I did with oil finishes turned some samples very dark and murky; so I opted for a couple thin coats of a water-based finish, followed by fine sanding and wax. This particular piece didn't have any major curls to speak of, so I don't think I missed much in the way of chatoyance. The muted reds and browns and grays are a pretty decent representation of the natural character and hues of the wood, and the swirly grain goes all around the piece.

Thanks again to Charlie Belden for conceiving this project. I haven't decided yet what I will do with it to pay it forward, but I'll let you know. Comments welcome.

Ellis


Re: Paying it forward

#2

Looks excellent to me, and the fact ......

JamieDonaldson

...that you learned along the way adds extra value, as does almost every piece for most of us as well. ;)

Re: Paying it forward

#3

Re: Paying it forward

Royce Wallace

I agree with Jamie. When I looked at the first showing I came away with the thought the finial distracted from the piece itself. In looking at a piece I aways wonder what will first attract the eye--finial or the major priece. I have the same thought now.

Re: Paying it forward

#4

Re: Paying it forward

Wally Dickerman

Ellis, I like this piece a lot. Good curves, good proportions, and the finial came out very well. Fits the piece.

Re: Paying it forward

#5

Re: Paying it forward

Jorge Casta�eda

Nice piece Ellis,

I have not decided yet what I'll do, the wood I got is full of cracks, so while wait for the muse to come, I paid forward to the public library in town... And whatever I create with it will go to fund raisers.

Re: Paying it forward

#6

Ellis Walentine

Interesting point

Ellis Walentine

Why have a finial at all? It's debatable for sure. It's a departure for me, mostly because I'm a pretty lazy turner, content to get a nice form out of a great piece of wood. I don't have a strong theory of finials, but they do add variety at the very least. The trick is to get them to harmonize with the piece they're sitting on, in a way that adds up to more than the sum of the parts. I think Cindy Drozda has set a high bar for us.

Ellis

Re: Paying it forward

#7

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Paying it forward

Barb Siddiqui

Just beautiful, Ellis. I don't know why you say the 'curve could have been fairer?' It looks just right to me. Where do you see the flaw in it?

Re: Paying it forward

#8

I love it...

GaryG in MD

Ellis,

I really like the whole package. I think you've done a wonderful job with it.

Give it a fresh look -- you've been looking at it and fussing over it too much.

Hold your head high and puff out your chest. This is a winner.

I'm not a fan of overly large finials -- I think this is just the right size.

I also think it continues the overall curve of the top of the piece very well and comes to a conclusion at just the right height.

The shape of the body is what I call an "onion", and I like that shape very much. Not all HFs have to look like Southwest forms! I think the collar on the body works very well with the finial, and you've matched it with a corresponding shoulder on the finial base that creates a set of three horizontals which make a nice "feature".

Thanks for the heads up on the finishing. I haven't turned my pieces yet (definitely a design challenge, and I'm busy making holiday gifts), but I feared what oils would do. I'll plan to use a water base finish -- the colors show very nicely in yours.

Great work, Gary

Re: Paying it forward

#9

Ellis Walentine

Well....

Ellis Walentine

... if you can't see it, it isn't there for you, and that's fine with me.

Seriously, though, and I may be hypercritical about this stuff, but I have this abiding preference for fair curves, and this pot has a slight bulge at about 10 o'clock and 2 o'clock in the photo. In my view, a fair curve is one that changes its acceleration perfectly smoothly, as it would if it were defined by a mathematical formula. Parabolas, ovals, and other geometric curves are found throughout nature, and they are unique in that they have no bulges or flat spots. This 'onion' shape, as GaryG called it, may be an exception. Some things in nature don't transition geometrically. (Actually, I think onions do; this one doesn't.) I believe our eyes perceive non-geometric curves, even if you don't recognize them as such. It's just that we're accustomed to seeing smooth transitions in geometry and nature, and anything else has a slight edge of "wrong" in it, if only subliminally.

That said, I can see how the presence of more organic curvatures mixed into a bowl profile has the potential to create interest and emotional responses that make it not better or worse, but different.

Sorry for the geeky answer. Got my Jack Handey hat on tonight. :)

Ellis

Re: Paying it forward

#10

Re: Paying it forward

Philip F. Duffy

Looks to me like a wonderful achievement of your skills, Ellis. It is a beautiful piece of work that shows your dedication and love of the art of turning. Well Done! Philip

Re: Paying it forward

#11

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Well....

Barb Siddiqui

Thank you for that explanation; not 'geeky' at all. I'm still trying to educate myself as to the line of a fair curve in doing a piece, and even at 10 and 2, I just don't see it. If there is anything there amiss, I'd guess the swirling grain of the wood could adequately disguise it.

I had a piece on my lathe when a friend/mentor/artist visited, and he nodded, hesitated, hedged, until I put him on the spot to tell me what he saw. "The curve is wrong." I handed him the gouge, he showed me with his fingers where he'd change it, and proceeded very carefully, over several minutes, to re-cut the outline. He was obsessively precise, and each time he stood back to observe it, when I thought he had it to perfection, then he'd lean forward and redo it. The result was perfection. But all I could see was vast improvement over my original. I'm still trying to train my eye to question and perceive.

Re: Paying it forward

#12

Beautiful !


Re: Paying it forward

#13

Re: Paying it forward

Bernie Weishapl

That is a beautiful piece Ellis.

Re: Paying it forward

#14

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, all

Ellis Walentine

I appreciate the kind words and feedback.

Re: Paying it forward

#15

Re: Interesting point - Sure is purdy Ellis !!!


Re: Paying it forward

#16

Re: Paying it forward

bob davis

it has class, ellis

Re: Paying it forward

#17

Mike Stafford

Re: Paying it forward

Mike Stafford

I think your form is excellent and the finial complements it. I wouldn't change a thing except ownership; from your possession to mine.... :D

Re: Paying it forward

#18

Bob Moffett

Re: Paying it forward

Bob Moffett

I really like this piece. The grain is very striking and I thing the finial compliments the hollow form. I think you did a great job.

Re: Paying it forward

#19

Re: Paying it forward

Jennifer Indy.USA

You make nice stuff Ellis. I love it!

:)