Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Trepidation & Tenacity

Posts

Trepidation & Tenacity

#1

Trepidation & Tenacity

charlie belden

The cracks, checks, voids and inclusions filled madrone burlwood urn I've been struggling to turn continues to test my patience - and self preservation instincts. It's been a Trepidation & Tenacity Exercise.

With the outside profile done, the scary part - hollowing through even a 1 1/4" opening is being done - with a great deal of trepidation. Despite all the epoxy filling and two, 2 oz, bottles of medium CA glue, my hollowing tools keep finding new unepoxied, unCA glued cracks, voids, checks and inclusions. Even at 300+ RPMs, the catches I can't avoid make the hollowing a Jaw Clencher, disaster lurking a fraction of a second away. The natural edged hole in the side complicating things even more - wood, wood, wood - AIR. If the cracks etc. were square to the long axis things would be a little easier - but many run tangent to the axis and tend to tear out rather than be cut. Those are the scary catches because they add a chunk of wood to the inside of the spinning piece.

So it's been pray, turn 1/32 of an inch, blow out the curlies, inspect for voids, cracks, checks and inclusions, CA glue them, wait - turn another 1/32" - repeat.

Had I bought the 18" or 24" handle for my 3/8" and 1/2" John Jordan hollowing tools, this hollowing would be a wee bit calmer. But since I only have the JET Mini - dumb me figured I only needed a 12" handle. That was OK out to about 3" of tool overhang. Not so good when the cutting tip is out 4 1/2" to 5 1/2" - inside a hollow form.

I COULD mount the MiniMonster to finish off the hollowing - but this piece has gotten under my skin - and I want to find out IF I can Old School hollow this deep, in wood this troublesome - just once - and be able to say I CAN hollow without the MiniMonster - but choose to use the MiniMonster. It's now an EGO thing - and probably doomed to disaster because of ego - but . . .

Despite my trepidation, and because I'm tenacious (sounds better than stubborn or bullheaded), I AM going to finish this piece - or it, or I, will die trying. I really want to make my Un-Urned Income Issue piece a reality - and send photos of the finished idea to every Republican congressman & senator and ask "Why is EARNED income taxed at 25% and UNEARNED income is taxed at only 15%?

Have you gotten into a piece and kept going even when it seemed hopeless - and a futile waste of time or became a masochists pursuit? If so, what kept you going - and how did things turn out?

Do YOU subscribe to "Life's too short - to turn crappy wood" - or are you a finish what you started?

Re: Trepidation & Tenacity

#2

Re: Trepidation & Tenacity

Wally Dickerman

Charlie, to answer your last question, now that I'm older and hopefully wiser, I don't turn crappy wood unless it's something really special.

Using a hollowing tool (and with white knuckles) more than 4 inches off the tool rest using a 12 inch handle comes under the heading of "unsafe turning practices". The only safe way to use a hand held hollowing tool is with a long handle that you can tuck under your forearm and against your side. I'm convinced that most big catches start with a small catch resulting in losing control of the tool.

Seems to me that you're living dangerously...on the highway and in the shop.

Re: Trepidation & Tenacity

#3

And the flexing of the shafts of your.....

JamieDonaldson

....smaller hollowing tools, short handle, nervous tension, slow turning speeds, turning at or above centerline(?) are all combining to work against you! Hollowing is a good time to go "strong and long!"

Re: Trepidation & Tenacity

#4

I Can't subscribe to the idea of crappy

mjonesrdg

I can't much get behind the concept of "life is too short to turn crappy wood", partly because I can no longer afford to buy better, and partly because all the wood that I get deserves to be given my best shot at using it. (This is kinda Zen, isn't it?) I'd venture to guess that I have turned a high percentage of my total output from wood that others here might call "crappy".

I think that staying with a piece has reward. Learning to deal with punk, occlusions (sometimes filled with 'nonspecific inorganics') cracks, voids, tension/compression stresses, sap,stink,stringy, loose bark and a myriad other things that might earn the label..."crappy" prpares one for that "almost"perfect piece that comes into our possession.

Mike Jones, Redding, Ca.

Experience with a lot of such "less than "Choice" grade blanks, will exercise your critical eye and train the creative side of your brain.

Re: Trepidation & Tenacity

#5

Re: Trepidation & Tenacity

john lucas

Charlie I hope to have a chance to photograph two of the pieces I brought to work this morning. Both were Crappy wood. They didn't start out that way but things happen and defects appear. I fuss at myself for spending the time it takes to save them but sometimes it's worth it. I've gotten several good compliments on them this morning so maybe it was worth it.

Anyway I'll try to get some shots after my staff meeting and a photo assignment.

Re: Trepidation & Tenacity

#6

Re: Trepidation & Tenacity

bob davis

crappy can sometimes turn beautiful

Re: Trepidation & Tenacity

#7

My saved bowls

john lucas

Here are two that were saved. The small footed bowl was turned at my demo for the Jackson club. I was putting the finishing touches on it when the whole side blew out. I glued it back in successfully but then when I was sanding another chunk fell out. I used black epoxy to fill in this void. Then I painted the top surface black with an ink brayer and added the little red dots called puff paint. It's a small bowl about 4" across.

The other one was large bowl blank I was going to core but I got busy and left it on the shop floor. it started checking really bad. I thought I could cut out the checks but by the time I got through all but one I was almost at this shape. The last one was about 6" long near the rim. I carved away the crack leaving a sort of jagged line. Filled it with dark gray epoxy. It had 2 other cracks in the rim that I was able to patch with sawdust mixed in epoxy. The repair worked so well my friend who is a serious turner came in today and could not find the repairs.