A good safety video (sort of...?)
steven antonucci
Here is a good video of why you don't use a conventional SRG on faceplate work. He makes the point pretty well... (too well)
Steve
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
A good safety video (sort of...?)
steven antonucci
Here is a good video of why you don't use a conventional SRG on faceplate work. He makes the point pretty well... (too well)
Steve
Let's just go with WOW...
Re: A good safety video (sort of...?)
Dale Bonertz
Steven,
I don't know where you got this but I think you should post it on the AAW site. Not only for additional coverage for people to see but also because there is someone on that site that condones and preaches the use of the SRG for bowls. It would be good for him and those he has preached to to see the dangers of using the SRG on bowls. A good explanation in the video.
Dale
Youtube, of course.
steven antonucci
I think that he's showing that it can be done, right up until the point where he shows why it shouldn't be done. I think it was the wood that cut him, and it was his hand being drawn into the spinning piece by the ever increasing down force as he extended over the tool rest.
I know who you mean, and it won't help. It's not that he's wrong, but there are consequences when you do it wrong. This video explains them well.
Steve
Re: A good safety video (sort of...?)
robo hippy
This came up on the Australian Woodworking forums (don't know if I can post a link or not, but you can google it), and was part of a rather long thread.
Basically, he does everything wrong that is possible with that tool.
The first cut, he is pointing the tool up into a square corner, which is like sticking your fingers into the spinning fan the wrong direction. Catch guaranteed!
He is basically scraping, with the cutting action at 90 degrees to the wood rotation. Instead of having the tool pointing down like you are supposed to do with a scraper, he has it angled up. Of course, with this type of SRG, if you angled it down, the corners of the wings would hit first, and you could not cut with it. Scraper angled up, catch guaranteed!
When the catch happens, he is extended pretty far out off of the tool rest. Simply, the longer lever is more than he can hand on to.
Just how would you present a bowl gouge to that spinning wood? Most certainly not the way he presented the SRG. With a level handle, you would have the flutes rolled over about 45 degrees. This gives you a very nice shear cut, and leaves a very clean surface. If you are doing it with a dropped handle, you roll the flutes over slightly, and take a shear cut, and some times you rub the bevel, some times not. You can do the same cut with a SRG. When rolled on its side, there is no chance of the corners catching, and you are riding the bevel for good tool control. If you try to make a shear cut with the SRG and the flutes are pointing up, the part of the tool that is cutting is the wing, which is not balanced over the tool rest, and it will roll into the wood.
Simply, you use the tool differently on bowls than you do on spindles. The two techniques do not work the same. You can however roll the flutes on the side for shear cuts on a spindle.
He also should have used a much slower speed to demonstrate what he was doing. That is one advantage of the variable speed, you can slow things down during a demonstration so those watching can actually see what is happening. There was no need to donate blood to the turning gods.
As to Michael Mouse on the AAW forum, he uses a continental style SRG which has a ) shaped flute. He does a shear cut, not a scraping cut. The gouge is rolled on its side.
robo hippy
Re: A good safety video (sort of...?)
Bill Neddow
I agree. If you used a bowl gouge the way he used the spindle roughing gouge, you would get the same results. The techniques he used should be studied and avoided like a plague. Robot Hippy is right.
There is a good reason for not using a spindle roughing gouge on bowls. A regular SRG has a fatal built-in flaw in its design. The tang is not meant to withstand any sort of torque and the tool can bend or break at the tang, just beyond the handle. I have seen it done several times when the spindle roughing gouge was being used for spindle work -- mainly because it was stuck out too far over the tool rest.
This flaw was introduced by tool manufacturers when they stopped forging SRGs and started stamping them out of flat steel. The blacksmiths "bulk up" the tang, making it thicker and thus making it dramatically less likely to bend. The modern manufacturers simply skip this step, thus making the tool dangerous for both spindle and bowl work.
There are only two spindle roughing gouges on the market that are properly made. They are the P & N gouge (with a half-inch round tang) and the Thompson gouge, with a three-quarter inch diameter tang. These should be the gold standard. Others should be avoided.
He knows it too
steven antonucci
I don't think he was unaware of the issues at hand. I think he was making a video to illustrate why it was a bad idea, and unfortunately, did so graphically.
I am also not convinced his triage is 100% accurate. I think that the left corner of the SRG hit the square wing and caught, drawing his hand into the wood because he was so far over the rest and at such a high angle to get bevel contact. The wood surface is actually cut pretty cleanly.
I've watched Michael's video on the continental grind he uses, and I think that the issue is that I would not call that a SRG. The rounded nose profile and flatter flute completely change almost everything about what he does. His position that it is a roughing gouge doesn't match my definition of a SRG... and hence the debate ensues...
Steve
Re: He knows it too
John Lucas
I think it's an excellent video simply because that's how most beginners try to use the gouge and he did a great job of showing the results.
I don' t believe you will get the same catch he got with a bowl gouge simply because the wings are ground back and you would have less surface hitting that outside uncut edge. The catch was a result of both the angle of the gouge, how far it was over the rest and that SRG straight wing. The straight wing is unsupported so when you do stick it into the wood the gouge twists and pulls itself into the wood deeper. A bowl gouge wing presented that way won't do that nearly as aggessively.
Mark Baker and I had a good discussion about using roughing gouges many years ago. When I got home I played with it on bowls. If you have enough knowledge of cutting edges and how they work you can use the tool quite successfully. I cut on the inside the outside, turned it upside down and cut with the wings on the inside and outside. It's not something I would ever teach simply because there are better tools to do that job and in the hands of a beginner it's an accident waiting to happen.
The P@N and Thompson tools overcome the narrow tang problem but it's the cutting edge shape that is the problem when used on a bowl.
Re: A good safety video (sort of...?)
robo hippy
I have 2 'bottom of the bowl gouges that I use. 75 degree bevel, and square across the flutes like the SRG. One, an old Glaser, the other a smaller house brand one from Craft Supplies. When I use them, I have them rolled on their sides. The corners can not catch, and you have a high shear angle for a clean cut.
A SRG for a roughing tool, NEVER! For a finish cut on, rolled onto its side, not my favorite tool, but it works very nicely.
Thing is, I think we need to teach right and wrong ways to use the tools.
robo hippy
Right and wrong is somewhat subjective
steven antonucci
I agree that the right way to use tools is important, as is the right tool for the job. Some folks might argue that any way that you can get wood out is as good as the next, and only the end results count...
There are things that I do that I would never teach. It's not that they are unsafe (for me), but that they require such specific methods and control that they are simply not for the beginner. MM's methods of using the continental gouge are one example where something he can do that would be risky for a beginner to attempt. Another example might be me finishing the outside of a hollowform with a skew to minimize sanding.
Showing proper technique will not always translate into proper technique. MM demonstrating the continental gouge used properly doesn't explain the 10,000 things he is doing right to the person watching it. Sadly, all they see is "hey, I can use the SRG on the inside of a bowl..."
It is important to remember that the only qualification to posting a turning video on YouTube is that you shoot a turning video and upload it. There is no qualification or warranty of skill... let the viewer beware!
Steve
P.S. I think the original poster is probably a pretty good turner, but picked a bad way to illustrate what you shouldn't do...
Re: Right and wrong is somewhat subjective
Dale Bonertz
Well said Steve,
"There are things that I do that I would never teach. It's not that they are unsafe (for me), but that they require such specific methods and control that they are simply not for the beginner. MM's methods of using the continental gouge are one example where something he can do that would be risky for a beginner to attempt. Another example might be me finishing the outside of a hollowform with a skew to minimize sanding."
That is why I suggest posting this wherever you can on the forums. MM may be able to use his continental gouge but to go around encouraging beginners is another thing. Heck, just because someone can sharpen a piece of rebar or something else and use it as a flute less gouge or whatever without incident does not mean he/she should encourage others to do so. I watched the video again and I believe this gentleman knows how tools cut and was demonstrating why and how the SRG can be dangerous. Kudos to him for taking the time to educate others.
Dale
Re: A good safety video (sort of...?)
robo hippy
This is how I use the SRG on a bowl.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OwlAb2BWHw8
The interesting thing about Michael Mouse's use of his continental style/broad sweep gouge is that he is not rubbing the bevel. I guess that makes it what a lot of people call a 'shear scrape'.
robo hippy
Re: A good safety video (sort of...?)
Alan Zenreich
Very nice, Robo Hippy
On the outside, you can use almost anything
steven antonucci
I usually use the wing of the bowl gouge with the handle WAY WAY down. Same idea- a high shear angle, long thin ribbons like your video. It's all in the way you present the edge, and how you get the danger spots away from the cut.
I like the way you illustrate the problem (without bleeding all over the place like the first guy). I wonder if there is a market for a technical video that shows only these types of issues and how to resolve them?? One hour of "if you do this, you will bleed and here is why... instead, do this..."
Steve
P.S. I have no doubt that what Michael is doing is fundamentally sound, since I suspect that was how it was done prior to the bowl gouge being invented. I just struggle with the "language" - CRG or SRG...two different things in my book.
Re: A good safety video ...Staged ?
Doc Green
I believe the big catch was staged, and done quite effectively. Why? If you view it frame by frame by double clicking the pause button, you can see ...
(1) Just before the big catch, he hesitates just a fraction of a second, probably inadvertently, as he prepares himself for what comes next.
(2) During the mishap, his hands seem to go to the left and away from the workpiece. This is hard to judge with any certainty because of the blurred images.
(3) Right after the mishap, his left hand and left index finger come into the frame, and there is no injury.
(4) While the closeup of the injury is graphic, it could very easily be faked.
(5) The wound appears to be more of a puncture wound rather than a scrape or a shearing cut that would come from the whirling corners of the workpiece.
(6) Had the wound been real, I think he would have used a bit better bandages than whatever he placed on TWO fingers. (No wound was apparent on the middle finger, so why does it need a bandage?)
(7) The guy knows too much to have stumbled into this type of mishap. I judge by his explanations and placement of the tools that he's not new at this game.
I may be totally wrong about this, of course, but I suspect he's having a good laugh. Nevertheless, it does an excellent job of making the point. ~Doc
Re: A good safety video ...Staged ?
Alan Zenreich
Doc,
It's unlikely that there was any faking done... the turner also posted this video on another woodturner site for review.
Yes, he was trying to get a catch, but I think the severity of the catch and the injury took him by surprise.
Re: A good safety video ...Staged ?
robo hippy
Go to the Australian wood working forum, you can google that. Follow it to woodturning general, and look at the entire thread. He was intentionally showing what can happen if you use a SRG on a bowl.
Steve, it is in the workings now.
robo hippy
I agree with Alan and Robo
steven antonucci
I think the situation was staged to show what might happen, but the turner certainly wasn't volunteering his hand as a sacrifice. Like Alan said, I agree that he was surprised by how bad of an injury he got.
I know that I certainly wouldn't grind up a body part as a demo...
Steve
Re: I agree with Alan and Robo
Alan Zenreich
"I agree with Alan and Robo"
Who are you and what have you done with Steve?
Be happy, it means you are right for once