Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

You Tube

Posts

You Tube

#1

You Tube

Barbara Gill

There are some good You Tube choices for woodturning but some of the "best" are too frustrating to watch. They load so slowly that watching them is painfully difficult. I assume it has something to do with the size of the files.

I know the information can be presented much quicker. When I watch the videos on AccuWeather I do not have the loading problem.

Re: You Tube

#2

Re: You Tube

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hi Barbara,

I think it mostly depends on your connection speed.

I have been very happy since I upgraded to a dsl connection, no problems on any youtube videos.

I don't have the fastest one available, but mine seems to work for what I want to see.

What is your connection speed?

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: You Tube

#3

Steven Antonucci

Things that kill download speeds

steven antonucci

When you look at you internet connection, you should think of it like a highway.

First, a straight road can travel much faster than one with a million curves. If you are on one of the major providers, you are on a straight road. If you are on a local ISP, you have a curvy road in front of you.

Secondly, there are posted speeds, but the reality is you travel at the speed you travel. In some cases, you cannot go as fast as you should because of the other cars around you (other traffic slows everyone's theoretical maximum) or the car you are driving has problems (you may have something locally on you PC that drags down performance).

In some cases, I have also seen bad performance in downloading Youtube videos. I usually yell upstairs to my son to get off of the internet, because he likes to sit on YouTube and watch Halo videos. If you have other WiFi devices in your house, you may be killing your own performance. If not, your neighbors may be hopping on to your WiFi without your knowledge.

When my son gets off, if performance improves, I know it was him hogging the bandwidth. If not, it is also possible that you are connected to a slow server at Youtube. Google is reported to have over 1 million servers, and it would be silly to think that all of them are running perfectly all of the time.

Here is an exercise:

If you look at you subscribed bandwidth, you should be able to calculate your maximum throughput. In my case, I pay for 3Mbit access. (8 Bits/byte) so it's 3000000/8= 375,000 Bytes/s or 375K/s maximum download speeds.

I simply go to a site that allows me to download large files, and start a download. If my bandwidth is clean, I end up near 375K/s in the status bar. If not, well... then you may have one of the problems I mentioned above.

Steve

Re: You Tube

#4

Re: You Tube

Carole Valentine

Barb, your internet connection is fine, I think. In fact it is a lot better than mine! Most of the time, problems with videos relate to the server, or occasionally a router on a particular hop between you and the YouTube server. Sometimes you can do a "tracert" (trace route - but don't know how you do that on a Mac) and tell where the problem is by looking at the times, lost packets, etc. From what I can tell when I uploaded that little test video, You Tube converts videos when you upload and I am not sure the user has much control over it other than very basic choices in format.

Re: You Tube

#5

Re: You Tube

Barbara Gill

I know the connection is fine. ;)

I also know that if I go to Accuweather and watch a video without the slow down load and then go to You Tube and try to watch one of the slow to load ones, it is not my computer. I also know if I am watching several You Tube videos which load just fine and then go to one or two which don't and then go to some that are fine it most likely the file size of the video. I think that sometimes whoever is making the video has a much higher resolution than needed for computer viewing.

Would the server vary that much within a period of 10 min?

Re: You Tube

#6

Re: You Tube- a possible answer

Carole Valentine

Found this:

Services like YouTube have a pretty complicated content delivery network. These typically replicate content to be closer to the users in the nodes that are demanding it.

If you're one of the first in your "area" to be requesting a video, and it's not in cache near your node, up the stream it goes as it finds some place to deliver it to. If it's not in memory and you actually have to do a read from disk, this will take even longer for you.

Load balancing schemes rely on several metrics to help distribute the content appropriately and most efficiently. Making a determination to move content into a node's memory-based cache can be some fancy mojo, based, among other things, on the frequency of requests and the sheer volume in your area.

Re: You Tube

#7

Re: You Tube- a possible answer

Jim H

I am not computer literate, but I know that I have 2 main wood turning producers I like watch on YouTube. One always slows down and buffers, sometimes to the point of being unwatchable , while the other almost never has a problem. If you are using a IPad, I have found that going to YouTube from safari is faster than using the built in app for some reason.

Re: You Tube

#8

Re: You Tube- a possible answer

Barbara Gill

Thanks Carole, that makes more sense than anything.

Jim, I often use my iPad; thanks for the hint.

Re: You Tube

#9

Re: You Tube

Chuck Engstrom

Hi Barb -- my Verizon Wireless connection here at home is not what I'd like it to be, limited by surrounding trees and leaves. If a YouTube is loading slower than it wants to play, I often click on the PAUSE button and allow it to load completely -- watch the progress bar fill up -- and then I can watch it without interruptions for buffering. Not all videos will do this, but it's worth a try. You can tend to some other matter while it loads.

Best --

Chuck

Re: You Tube

#10

Steven Antonucci

Hit pause b4 viewing

steven antonucci

While CDN's like Akamai, L3 and Limelight Networks are responsible for content delivery, I think it's not really a place that I would start looking for issues. For one, there is nothing you can do about it. If Google is serving from local cache vs. a read from disk, trust me when I tell you that your bandwidth and latency is probably a couple of orders of magnitude greater of an issue than this.

A simple test that anyone can run to troubleshoot is downloading two videos from Youtube at the same time. Open two windows, side by side. Pause them both so they don't play at the same time. Watch how fast the bar progresses. A short video in HD quality may be 1GB. A longer video may be highly compressed and only 10 MB.

When I hit a slow video, I pause it to allow it to download enough of the video to watch it uninterrupted. It may be about 1/2 the video, but at least I don't have stop and start problems. It may cost me a minute of buffering/wait time, but I do something else during that minute, so I don't care.

Steve

Re: You Tube

#11

Download it, then play it.


Re: You Tube

#12

Ken Vaughan

Some Videos are in higher definition (lots more by

Ken Vaughan

Re: You Tube

#13

Re: You Tube

Lan Brady

Barbara,

I run into the same problem. Some videos open and play immediate while other take forever to load. I just hit the pause button and the video continues loading.

I go play solitaire for a minute or open another browser to look up items I just saw in the previous video. Having 2 browsers open does not seem to slow down the loading any further.

Good Luck, Lan

Re: You Tube

#14

Re: You Tube

Barbara Gill

IMHO no video is worth waiting while it loads. There is no way I am going to amuse myself while it loads. I will just not watch it.

Re: You Tube

#15

That Is What I thought


Re: You Tube

#16

Dick Hines

Re: You Tube

dick hines

Barbara, my advice it to read a book on the subject. :b

Re: You Tube

#17

Test site

Bill Howatt

There is a site, www.toast.net that you can go to and check your download speed. It us under Resources on the left. Select a location to download it from (closer is probably better),a photo and download. At the end it will post your speed and you can compare with other ISPs.

Bill

Re: You Tube

#18

Re: You Tube

Dinyar Chavda

Try using Realdownloader, check the videos you want to see, walk away, and then come back after they have all been downloaded, and you won't have to wait.

It's at http://i.realone.com/product/help/downloader-pro/en/downloader-help-how-to.htm