Hollow Roller
Doug Adams
Has anyone tried the Hollow Roller made by Carter Products?
Doug
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Hollow Roller
Doug Adams
Has anyone tried the Hollow Roller made by Carter Products?
Doug
Re: Hollow Roller
John Lucas
Only for a few seconds at a demo. It is very smooth. It seems overly complex and I'm not totally sure of the advantages but it's very well built, operates effortlessly and is well finished. It does seem to allow a lot of freedom of movement.
There are so many hollowing systems out there now. We need someone who has used them all to give a report. I have played with them but that's a whole different ball game than actually turning some hollow vessels with them.
From a play with, but non user standpoint I tend to like the elbow kind of systems like the elbow tool, monster tool, and the even the more advanced Cobra. They seem to have a lot more freedom of movement. They are more complex and if not built well could have potential problems down the road. The Jamieson style systems are a little more restricting but there are absolutely no parts to wear out.
In my restricted space the Jamieson style system is harder to store. I'm short on wall space. The elbow style systems will fold up a little better but some have a larger secondary platform that must be stored. This would include the Carter system.
All of them probably have their pro's and cons and since I haven't actually turned a whole project with any of them other than mine I can't say which would be better. I think they all will get the job done for all but the most demanding projects.
Re: Hollow Roller
Billl Jacksonville, NC
Keith Burns wrote a review on Hollow Roller at:
www.woodturnersamerica.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=246:the-hollow-roller&catid=81:tool-reviews&Itemid=2
Re: Hollow Roller
David DeCristoforo
Go over to the Woodturners America site and post the question for Scott Hackler. He just won a hollow roller in the B&B competition. He's the only guy I know of who actually has one...
Re: Hollow Roller
Doug Adams
David
They also have a nice review on it. Thanks
Doug