Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Band saw motor

Posts

Band saw motor

#1

Bob Moffett

Band saw motor

Bob Moffett

I have a 14” Delta band saw with a riser block. The motor has gone bad. Harbor Freight has an ad for October which has a # 67842 2 hp compressor motor for $139 or a 1 hp Farm/Agricultural motor for $149. Both motors are by Smith & Jones, a company I am not familiar with. My questions are: (1) what is the difference between a compressor motor and a farm/agricultural motor and (2) which would be better to use on my band saw? Thanks in advance for your help with this question.

Re: Band saw motor

#2

Re: Band saw motor

klowwn

Bob, I am not an expert on motors. But a few years ago I replaced a motor on a Sears bandsaw with a Harbor Freight one. At the time it was recommended to go with the farm duty as the compressor duty wasn't designed to run for more than short periods at a time. The farm duty supposedly was designed for continuous use.

Hopefully someone can clarify.

Another option if you want a higher than 1hp that the farm duty motor, is to check with local motor repair shops to see if they have any rebuilt motors in the 1-1-1/2 to 2hp range.

I recently found a 1-1/2hp on craigslist for $15 to replace the 3/4hp on my Rigid bandsaw. Just be sure to check it out before you buy to make sure it doesn't smell burnt.

Good Luck

Ricc Havens

Re: Band saw motor

#3

Steven Antonucci

Bigger is better

steven antonucci

I jeri-rigged a true 1HP motor to a Craftsman bandsaw that had a 3/4 HP Sears motor on it. It is safe to say that a true 1HP outperforms a Sears 3/4 HP by well more than 1/4 HP...

I wish I had a picture of that set-up. It was so McGyvered that I was even impressed. All that I remember was that it involved a wooden motor mount and bandclamps...

Steve

P.S. Buy the biggest motor you can figure out how to attach. You'll cut much easier.

Re: Band saw motor

#4

Re: Band saw motor

David DeCristoforo

I can't help you with the motor types but "Smith and Jones"??? Should be more like Chang and Fong. Those cheap Chinese motors are.... well you get what you pay for. Having said that, I can tell you that I just went through the same thing with basically the same saw and 1HP will not be enough power of you want to use the full capacity with the riser. You need at least a horse and a half so from that standpoint alone I would vote for the 2hp motor. Just make sure it has the correct configuration for mounting, especially if you have the enclosed base.

Re: Band saw motor

#5

JL

Re: Band saw motor

JL

Don't get a compressor motor. As previously mentioned, they aren't rated for continuous duty.

More hp is better. if you can get something more than 3/4 hp, get it. I replaced my old Delta 14" motor with a rebuilt one from the local shop (1.5 hp). Talk about performance increase! It cost me ~$75. Worth every penny.

I would stay away from Harbor Fright. But that's me.

Re: Band saw motor

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Band saw motor

Keith Tompkins

I installed a Baldor 2 HP 240V motor on my Delta 14", c. 1977, replacing the original 3/4 HP motor. I replaced the original hinge-type setup with a solid adjustable mount system. Huge difference...on the old mount, the hinge would swing up under load, causing the belt to slip. Now, I can cut anything with ease. I personally don't believe the bigger motor overstresses the machine as some claim.

Re: Band saw motor

#7

Re: Band saw motor

Don Evans

Couple of things Bob, that 2hp motor "Smith+Jones" at HF.

It is 1725 rpm (is that right speed?

More important is the mount and shaft diameter, the shaft is 7/8" which I'll bet your pulley on old motor is 5/8", be sure to check that.

The motor mount is a 145T Nema which I don't think will match up as yours is probably a 56 mount. You can make the other work maybe by drilling hole ect, but there are too many motors out there to go to that trouble if buying new.

Others are correct in the duty cycle on compressor motors, you don't want one of those.

Another thing you can look at is called the Service Factor, if it is 1.0 that is nothing special but if it says it is 1.15 then you are getting a motor that is rated for safely pulling more amperage during more than normal stressing. Those are really best looked at as percentages 1.0 is 100 percent load based on spec's and the 1.15 is rated to handle 15 percent more. This is determined by the size wiring that is used to make the motor.

If they don't state the SF then you can bet it is a 1.0.

I don't agree with he more hp the better but that is a long story, naturally it is the safe answer but much more is involved. One example is the ability to power through with a dull blade (which is not safe) but where to draw the line is the problem.

Adding 1/2 to 3/4 more hp than what came on it is probably a good idea as I'm betting they put bare minimum on it originally.

There is just too much we don't know, do you run a 1/4" blade 99 percent of time or a 3/4" and do resawing 99 percent of time, this is retorical and just example.

So:

Frame? Shaft size? RPM of original are all considerations.

Check out www.surpluscenter.com also, they sell a lot of new motors.

Never hear of Smith+Jones either.

Don

Re: Band saw motor

#8

Re: Band saw motor

Bart Leetch

On a regular 14" cast iron band-saw with or without riser block Mark Duginsky, Suffolk Machinery (aka Timberwolf) & others recommend not using a blade wider than 1/2" because in most cases these saws are not able to tension the wider blades properly. Of course I had to try it & found out they were right.

I have an older Grizzly 14" saw that I put a 1/2" wood slicer blade on & have installed a 1 1/2 HP motor on it cuts veneer with no problem at all. It will also cut 12" thick while rounding out a bowl blank using a Timberwolf blade.

I also have a older 1950's 12" Craftsman band-saw that I keep a 1/4" - 3/8" blade on for every day quick cutting & curved work.

Re: Band saw motor

#9

jim miles

Re: Band saw motor

jim miles

Been thinking about getting riser block for Delta 14" Band saw

Any advice?

Sources?

Re: Band saw motor

#10

Re: Band saw motor

Barry Irby

I bought mine with the bandsaw from Delta. It was a kit. The riser block, the bolt, and the guard extensions and the longer bars to hold the upper guides. I thought a hundred bucks for what I got was not too bad.

You can make the riser block out of oak or other hardwood, and that might work fine, but it leaves you without the other stuff.

Some people have fitted Brand X versions and done OK but I am not sure you save enough to justify whatever fiddling it adds to the process.

I am pretty happy with what I did, but one thing leads to another. I feel like I bought a kit or stripped down model and started adding up grades. A riser block, a Carter Tension release (not worth it), Carter roller guides (Not sure they are worth it) and better spring, Etc. Now I would like to add a bigger motor, perhaps 2hp. It would have been better to save up a while longer and get a bigger bandsaw to begin with.

Re: Band saw motor

#11

jim miles

Re: Band saw motor

jim miles

Thanks for info

Jim