Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

pens out of round (HELP)

Posts

pens out of round (HELP)

#1

pens out of round (HELP)

Ken Ward

OK I just started turning pens this year nand all was going great,untill recently and they started coming out egg shaped.I got new mandrels,but it is running about 5 thousands off,same as the old ones.I checked the lathe and the live center and they are true.Could it be the mandrel chuck its self ?? I gotta get this runout thing straightened out.Any ideas.

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

#2

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

Nick Tuzzolino

One possible problem could be that you are tightening the tailstock too much and causing the pen mandrel to "whip." This is hard to judge if you are new at this.

One solution would be using a Mandrel Saver Tailstock Center. Penn State sells this as #PKMSTS2. Packard may also sell this. Once you see this, the light bulb will go on.

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

#3

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

Greg Haugen

Tell us a little more about your methods and techniques. Maybe there's something there.

One technique that I learned from Barry Gross was once you've turned the pen, down the to bushings, but before you sand. Stop the lathe, loosen the mandrel's nut and turn (twist) the blanks 90 degrees on the mandrel, and re-tighten the nut. When you turn the lathe back on, just turn the high spots down. It's simple method but will take out the possibilities of a run-out.

It's been a long time since I turned a pen but this did work. I've seen high end pens from notable pen turners with issues of run out, hardware and blank perfect on one side and had a step on the other.

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

#4

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

Ken Ward

Nick,I don't believe I'm tightening the tailstock to much,as I just started having this problem recentlly,and I really watch that close when I put the piece on.

Greg I ordered that mandrel saver,but they sent me the M1, :( but the M2 is on the way :) I even got a new mandrel and it read the same as the old ones,thats why I thought it may be the mandrel chuck.I just ordered a new chuck,but it's the other type that has the compresion nut,so I'll see what happens when I get the mandrel saver and the new mandrel chuck in,meanwhile I'll give that idea of spinning the blanks around right before sanding.Thanks folks for the advice.

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

#5

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Most lathe issued live centers have a 45° point. Pen mandrels are 60°. You can buy 60° centers from most suppliers. I like my ~$20 one from Grizzly. The small point in a big hole makes wobble.

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

#6

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

Lan Brady

Same thing happened to me. Turns out, mine was the MT2 taper had a scratch which was pushing the inserted drive to one side slightly. a little cleaning and needle file took care of mine.

Just thought I would share, Lan

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

#7

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

ken ward

OK,I went down last night and checked out the tailstock alignment with the headstock and it is as perfect as it can get,(0 runout)so I have come to the conclusion that the problem lies with the mandrel chuck.BTW I do have the 60 degree live center.So can someone tell me where I can buy a precision made mandrell chuck and mandrell ?????? thanks for the help.

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

#8

Ken Vaughan

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

Ken Vaughan

Ken - Please check to assure that you process of squaring the tubes with the end of the blank is highly precise. One of the largest cause of Out-of-Round I have observed occurs when the axis of the blank is not co-linear with mandrel.

Missed alignment with the process for setting the ends to be at a true right angle with the axis of the tube keeps the co-linear much closer. If not square, the bushings tend to "kink" a bit and the tolerance built into the system, allows out of round.

This slapped me in the face when putting steel shanks into a run of beer tap handles. I let some of the rods get installed at a slight angle to the axis of the tap and had out of round where the tap met the ferrull. (only blotched 4)

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

#9

Re: pens out of round (HELP)

ken ward

Just a little update.I found the hradache.It was the mandrel chuck.I had the type that you had to use two wrenches to tighten it up to hold the mandrell,now way I could get it to run true.Well I got the one that the mandrel just screws into and all is running true now.