Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

New Work: "Affirmation No. 2"

Posts

Re: New Work: "Affirmation No. 2"

#26

Katherine Kowalski

Futhermore...

Katherine Kowalski

Hi Charlie,

Sounds like you have a good start then.

I have traveled the world, also visiting many renowned sites: the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, the Smithsonian Institution in Washington D.C., and many other museums in the US. I have also been to the Louvre, Paris, The Hermitage in St. Petersburg, Russia, manifold museums in Moscow and St. Petersburg, including the Kremlin, and several palaces in and around the north country. The Singapore National Museum, many MANY museums in Thailand, China, Malaysia, and Indonesia. In addition, I have also visited huge numbers of religious temples, cathedrals, and churches, (all of which have ASTOUNDING works of art), in Europe, Southeast Asia, and the United States. (Among well-known establishments: the Cathedral of Notre Dame, Paris, St. Basil's Cathedral, Moscow, etc. etc. etc.)

The Imperial Palace, Bangkok, Thailand, The Forbidden City, Beijing, China, (The Great Wall of China), also MANY national monuments in the United States and abroad.

I also make a study of contemporary art, as well as traditional, classical, fine, and primitive arts. (And have similar miles of books on art at home).

--

From your message, it seems you are minimally aware of the use of text in art. Allow me to direct you to the fine art form of calligraphy in China and Japan. Contemporary art often makes use of quotations, etc. In ancient temples, the text is as much a part of the decoration as the illustrations, if any. (I have seen numerous gilded Buddhist temples in Thailand decorated in this manner). Recall ancient Egyptian art -- hieroglyphics bring meaning to sculptural pieces. Prayer flags, containing words to the gods, fly high in many of these far-flung locales.

My reference to the AAW controversy was not to you personally. (And yes, you were very civil in your post). I meant to draw attention not to the fact that hate was a topic, but that hate was EMPLOYED by MANY people to attack others. In fact, humanity seems to be prone to hateful behaviour, which is NOT restricted to some "few fanatics," but the population at large.

My message of peace is applicable.

--

My artwork is influenced by manifold ideas, including cultural customs, (such as employing text to make specific reference).

It has been repeated that one should never critique a piece unless one understands it, (or at least understands its background). Though you advised me to "grow a thick skin," I am sure you can relate to the frustration an artist feels when disparaging comments are made when the author of such clearly has no understanding of the work. (Why ANYONE should want to put down another's work is beyond my understanding.)

--

You suggested previously that I should use "universal symbols." As far as I know, there aren't any "universal" symbols for "hate" or for "reject." There aren't even GLOBAL ones. Your argument is flawed. What do we use on a daily basis to communicate complex ideas to one another? Do we draw pictures every time we want to say something? (I've never seen you draw a pictograph to represent your long postings on this forum...)

We use language -- WORDS. While pictures can be effective at communicating generalities, like beauty, ugliness, love, or sadness, they are LESS EFFECTIVE in communicating precise thoughts.

You complain that I use English, that it wouldn't be understood. Got news for you -- linguists around the world are in uproar over the Englishification of ALMOST EVERY NATIVE LANGUAGE... by their own countrymen. I have no doubt that by using google or some other service, any person would be able to understand my message.

I have to say that both your and Steve's posts contradict themselves. My piece CLEARLY generated a response, from both of you! To say that it was ineffective doesn't make sense -- otherwise, you would have simply ignored it.

--

I KNOW I am making "weird" art. I don't expect everybody, or even ANYbody to like it. I'm putting it out into the world to share a message, utilizing a seldom-seen form of artistic communication. It's frustrating that people want to disparage it simply because they don't understand it.

Surely, as woodturners we can at least relate to the form of the piece, the beauty of the wood, the way the chatoyant rays highlight the message as one of enlightenment.

I think I’m just about done on this topic.

Thanks,

Katherine

P.S. Anyone remember that post about the art piece with the hundred bowls -- the one where the artist pyrographized all of the sayings about her mother who had died young? Nobody complained that THAT wasn't art.

P.P.S. Charlie, I really don't appreciate your comparing my art to shit -- it's uncalled-for. And though I have never been enamored of your work, I would never be so ill-mannered.

Re: New Work: "Affirmation No. 2"

#27

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Futhermore...

Barb Siddiqui

"I am sure you can relate to the frustration an artist feels when disparaging comments are made when the author of such clearly has no understanding of the work."

Katherine, you are overlooking one very large factor here. Whether it is painting, sculpture, drama, the great American novel or wood, it is never up to the maker to declare the value of his or her art. Only the viewers can do that. A thing gains value by its overall reception when thrust into the world, and maintains its place as art by gaining a universality through generations of viewers. And there is no contest as to who has been to the most museums.

Claiming a critique holds no validity because the work is 'not understood' is a bogus argument, I'm afraid. We all put our things out there. The idea is to learn from peoples' reactions and further assess what we have done.

You have some admirable ideas here. I hope you're willing to take the responses and glean from them what is useful to you in adapting more of them.

Re: New Work: "Affirmation No. 2"

#28

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Futhermore...

Katherine Kowalski

Hi Barb,

I have learned some very interesting things about human nature.

I have also learned that people on this forum are not interested in new ideas. They seem to prefer what is comfortable to them.

So, I will leave you to it.

Those interested may view my work on my web site or at a symposium. Posting here is pointless, and I do not engage in worthless endeavour.

I'm done,

Katherine

Re: New Work: "Affirmation No. 2"

#29

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Futhermore...

Barb Siddiqui

Well, I hope you'll reconsider. People here are very open to new ideas, but when one asks for opinions and critiques, it pays to Listen, that's all. I've enjoyed seeing your work and I hope you'll post more.

Re: New Work: "Affirmation No. 2"

#30

Re: Futhermore...

Carole Valentine

The beauty and meaning of art is in the eye of the beholder, and all are different. Just because they may not have been to untold museums does not mean their opinion is invalid. For the artist to practically demand that the viewer see and accept (and apparently even agree with) only the artist's interpretation/statement is absurd. If the opinions on WC are so worthless, I am curious as to why you did not post these works on WoW or AAW or some other forum to seek the reactions you apparently desire? To get in a snit because not everyone likes this particular work seems a bit childish to me. And to state that people in this forum are not interested in new ideas is, frankly, quite condescending, not to mention erroneous.

Re: New Work: "Affirmation No. 2"

#31

Clarification

charlile belden

The photo I earlier provided as an example of a piece of art (it was in the Pompidou after all, and therefore determined by qualified authorities to be art) that incorporated printed words - was just that - art that incorporated printed words.

I was looking for an image of a Bob Rosand turned bowl with a story carefully hand written in a spiral around the inside. A vessel from which to take sustenance for the body - and then, through the use of finely printed and thoughtfully chosen words, take sustenance for the soul. Didn't find any images of one of those Rosand pieces but, during that search, I recalled that I had another image of art that incorporated printed words.

That piece was just an example of a piece of art that incorporated printed words - period - full stop. It's regretable that you took it to be a comment on this piece of yours, or your work in general. THAT was NOT my intent.

I've read that about half or more of our communication is non verbal, more so via the written word. And even with all the information that was sent being received there's still the receiver's life experience and current mood that comes into play before perception is arrived at.

Oh, and despite what you may think, there are FAR more angels in the world - than "A-Holes".

Stick around. This place is a great place to learn and can provide opportunities to teach. Not a bad source for interesting ideas for future pieces either.

Re: New Work: "Affirmation No. 2"

#32

Ellis Walentine

Ornaments Gallery *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Charlie, we have an image of one of Bob's writing-decorated ornaments right here on WoodCentral.

Ellis


WoodCentral Ornaments Gallery

Re: New Work: "Affirmation No. 2"

#33

A photographic memory AND instant recall?