Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Ever have one of those nights?

Posts

Ever have one of those nights?

#1

Ever have one of those nights?

Randy Gleckler

I did a demo for our club last night and turned an OK piece. Think the demo went well and communicated the how to fairly well, I hope.

So when I got home, decided to try and refine the shape look of the piece and realized I didn't really like the wood/overall shape I had. So decided it was time for a design opportunity and did some band saw cutting on it. Started carving to an idea I had in my head, and further I got towards the idea, the worse I thought it looked in reality. So took it back to the lathe, turned off some more wood to try another direction.. and now at this point, I think I'm just making it uglier by the minute. So, it's now sitting on a shelf and maybe in 2 to 3 years I'll look at it again and go, wow I should do X with it. It was just one of those nights...

And the more I reflect on it now, the more I think, if I'd have left it alone, it may have not looked so bad as I originally thought.

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

#2

that's how my mini goblets got started 


Re: Ever have one of those nights?

#3

Steven Antonucci

It's cool enough in NJ to light a fire?

steven antonucci

Burned a whole bin full of tragedies the other night...

S

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

#4

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

Katherine Kowalski

LOL John and Steve!

Randy, I think we ALL have nights like that! :)

Katherine

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

#5

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

Dick Wilson

Randy, I read your thread and am sitting here chuckling. I have had so many turnings go south on me that I can't even count them. Your discription perfectly describes the road I have gone down. You have no idea how many times I have thought to myself "self, you better stop turning or the whole turning will be shavings on the floor".

I cleaned my bench off one day and threw a lot of them in the burn barrell. A friend came over and we dumped the barrell in his pickup. I thought dang, all that work, I am going to try to do something with them. I took them back to the bench. Over time I got ideas and finished them. I don't have many left cuz they sold. Go figure. I don't throw anything away any more.

I found that as my artistic eye developed I saw something that I didn't see before.

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

#6

Joe Fleming

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

Joe Fleming

When I have one of those pieces, I either just complete the item without a signature and save it for whatever might come along, or I cut it in half to study the profile like Raffan does. I have a whole stack of halves that I use in demos to talk about design, profiles, etc.

I also use the rejects to practice texturing, coloring or burning techniques. You can practice all you want on flat boards, but nothing beats doing it on a curved surface where the grain goes all over. Joe

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

#7

Steven Antonucci

It's OK to fail (Hopefully, not too long winded)

steven antonucci

I was talking to a guy at the NY Maker Faire and we got onto the conversation of how he had learned to do something. Oddly, it was the same way that I had learned to turn.

We simply exhausted all of the wrong ways to do something first!

The conversation went on to discuss how we had learned more by doing something wrong than learning how to do it right. Failure is a part of the process. It is expected. It is normal.

If you aren't failing, you probably aren't learning either. It's OK to fail, and even moreso, it's exciting. My best days in the shop are when I get completely stuck and don't know how to do something. Days when I go out to make a bowl or hollow a vessel... meh? They're OK too...

Don't dwell so much on what you failed to do, but focus on what you learned. You got better because you failed, not worse.

(the guy I spoke to was a robotics guy, but it doesn't matter...)

Steve

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

#8

Steve Kubien

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

Steve Kubien

I have a few pieces like this, sitting on shelves or in boxes, waiting. It's as though my mind has this "great" idea, I start it, get stuck, have no clue how to finish it and hope I figure it out someday. The thing it, the original idea, while not complete, still has merit and to my eye is well executed. So, I can't get rid of them...

Re: Ever have one of those nights?

#9

Steve Kubien

Re: It's OK to fail (Hopefully, not too long winde

Steve Kubien

This is a very old method of teaching and learning. Sensei would show a technique and say, "hajime" (begin). The student would not get it right. He would instruct the student to do it again. Fail. Do it again. How do I do XYZ? Just do it. But I don't understand. Just do it.

Do you see a pattern here? This is a system of teaching and learning that flat out works. It has been proven over hundreds of years. It works. Try, fail, try, fail, try, fail... For some reason most people in the west have a tough time with this approach.