Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

The finish cut:Long!

Posts

The finish cut:Long!

#1

The finish cut:Long!

robo hippy

Well, after chatting with Mike Mahoney, and getting a comment from him that he preferred a more serrated (rough grinding wheel) edge for finish cuts I started experimenting. I took a nasty old piece of big leaf maple that was too soft for a good finish cut, took every conceivable cutting edge and tool variation I could come up with, and found out a few interesting things.

Sharpening station variations: Tormek 200 grit black wheel, D Way tools CBN wheels 80 and 180 grit, Matrix type CBN wheels 80 and 150 grit.

Scraper edge variations: Honed with no burr, grinder burr, burnished burr, honed burr, burr honed off but bevel not honed, honed on the Tormek and with diamond cards. Scrapers tested, HSS, A 2 from Serious tools, some Doug Thompson scrapers. I even did all of the above with a negative rake scraper.

Gouge steel used: HSS and carbon, some of Doug's gouges, some Glaser.

Gouge flute profiles: Spindle roughing gouges, both standard and continental. Shallow flute, deep flute, V flute, fluteless gouge.

Gouge nose profiles: swept back, fingernail, bottom of the bowl types (similar to SRG but with steeper bevel), 40/40 gouge (Stuart Batty type).

Cuts made: bevel rubbing and non bevel rubbing (often called shear scrape), and scraping (cutting edge 90 degrees to the rotation of the wood).

Most interesting conclusions:

Tool steel makes little difference, at not least anything that can be seen by the naked eye or felt with finger tips.

Bevel rubbing cuts, no matter which tools you use, rubbing the bevel leaves a better surface. Note here, I did bevel rubbing cuts with all the tools, gouges, standard scrapers, and even the negative rake scraper.

The single most important factor seems to be the shear angle. The more vertical the cutting edge, the smoother the cut. Best tools for this were the fluteless gouge from Doug, my scrapers, and the standard spindle roughing gouge. With these tools, it is easy to get the cutting edge at 70 or more degrees. Note here, I used the SRG with flutes rolled away from the wood at 90 degrees to the wood rotation. Dropping the handle way down and rolling the tool slightly on the bevel till it starts to cut. The scrapers I used had a ) profile, and I worked on the bottom half with the handle slightly lowered, keeping the cutting edge balanced over the tool rest, not above center which would make catches probable.

As soon as the bevel comes off the wood, the cut gets rougher, no matter which tool or cutting edge I used, including variations of the burrs, no burrs, and how fine the edge was.

On some solid, highly figured Myrtle wood, I could get great cuts with most of the tools and edges, but still, the best cuts were with high shear angles, and the bevel rubbing. The difference just wasn't as dramatic as with the punky wood.

Standard bowl gouges rolled more on their sides left a good surface, but had a very small sweet spot for the high shear angle, so tended to wear/dull more quickly.

I guess that the high shear angle is like running over speed bumps with your car. If you hit it head on, the bump is pretty sharp. This would be like a scraping cut where the fiber tends to pull out before it cuts. If you hit the speed bump at an angle the bump is way more gentle, so a high shear/tool cutting edge angle will lift the fiber more gently and cut it before it pulls/rips/breaks off.

robo hippy

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#2

Re: The finish cut:Long!

Harvey Ghesser

You just now found this out?

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#3

Re: The finish cut:Long!

robo hippy

I almost never turn dry wood. When turning green wood, you can get an equally good surface, no matter which method you use. Bevel rubbing or not rubbing, it makes no perceivable difference with the exception that the bevel rubbed surface is burnished and more shiny. Same with amounts of tear out. Almost no difference. I turn green to final thickness.

robo hippy

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#4

Re: The finish cut:Long!

john lucas

I agree on the shear angle. I've been playing with that a lot. I have some box elder and punky maple both of them are very prone to tearout. I like Stuart's 40/40 because you can rotate to a fresh edge without changing the tool angle. My spindle gouge gives a better cut but I think it's because it's 35 degree angle.

I'm still experimenting but so far the 3 factors that seem to affect a clean cut the most are shear angle, sharpness angle, the speed of the cut as it relates to surface feet per minute. I don't want it to sound like you need to speed up the lathe, you could slow down the speed of the cut to achieve the same thing.

Shear angle affects this also because the more steeply the shear angle the slower the tool wants to feed. I could be wrong but I think the steeper the sharpness angle the faster the tool can be pushed withought tearout. At least that's how it feels.

I do know that if I'm having problems, I go to tool with a more acute edge. I increase the speed of the lathe a little. I lighten up on the bevel and really lighten up on the forward speed of the tool. I do this by holding too delicately and trying to "feel" the wood so I'm not cutting it any faster than it wants to be cut. And then I try to rotate the edge so shear cutting.

I have another question that is confusing me but will have to take a photo of the tool in this position to see if anyone can answer. I'm headed home now. Just finished a good old Sunday awards ceremony so I can go back and play in the shop now.

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#5

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: The finish cut:Long!

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Did you find any significant differences among the various grinding alternatives?

Dennis

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#6

Re: The finish cut:Long!

robo hippy

Dennis,

That was the weirdest thing. The 80 grit D Way CBN wheel is very coarse, more so than a standard grinding wheel. My 150 grit matrix style CBN wheel is finer than any 150 grit wheel I have ever seen. The 200 grit wheel on the Tormek is pretty fine. Even if I honed them on the Tormek, there was no cutting difference I could notice (see or feel) with any of the different grits.

robo hippy

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#7

Here's my other cut.

John Lucas

this is with the flute up, cutting with the left edge rubbing the bevel on the side. I think why this works is the edge wings of my gouge end up quite thin after grinding. So even thought it's not cutting at an angle the cut is surprisingly clean.

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#8

Re: The finish cut:Long!

Doug Trembath

Reed, I found many years ago that if you use an extremely sharp fingernail bowl gouge with long bevel sweeps with fair curves, (Think Michelson grind, for instance, as an extreme), you can hold the gouge almost vertically, using the sides of the bevel edges instead of the point, and slice fibers in a long shear cut very effectively. The edge is gently rolled into the surface until you pick up a cut, then very carefully follow the cut line on the surface, taking extremely tiny shavings. They look like dust until you view them with magnification. It's not an easy cut to master, but really works with punky wood.

I have recently been turning a lot of very punky spalted wood, and getting a finish cut that I begin sanding with 320 grit. I very lightly apply the sandpaper, as well, so I don't introduce "High/Low " on the surface. Starting with such fine paper is not an ego trip, it's just that anything heavier will actually pull the free fibers out, leaving defects similar to torn grain. I have found that I need to apply a sealer coat very carefully, as well, as the soft cloth I use to apply oil-based finish will pull the fibers as well, until the first coat of finish bonds them together and results in a homogenous surface. That's some very punky stuff, but incredibly beautiful.

I think, in re-reading your post, and knowing Mike, he likes the serrated edges because the individual points of serration in reality are small cutting edges, with lots of cutting area , and a very shallow angle, so they will slice easier, and pull the grain up much less, and because of the multitude of edges in aggregate, it results in a superior cut surface. Multiply the cut by the number of differing edges, and you have a very smooth surface left behind. Mike and I spoke about this many years ago, about the time he showed me he could grade a Norton SG wheel with a good diamond dresser from 60 grit to about 200. I've shared that technique here a couple of times in the past.

Doug Trembath

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#9

Re: Here's my other cut.

Don Orr

That cut works well for a finishing cut for me. I use it with a more "conventional" grind, about 45 degrees-similar to a SRG. I also use it with a very blunt grind I learned from a Jimmy Clewes video-maybe 80 degrees-for deeper bowls inside the bottom. The wood slices along a steep, sharp edge with bevel support.

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#10

Re: The finish cut:Long!

robo hippy

John,

Your cut appears to have about a 30 degree shear angle. I have tried that one, and worry about getting too high up on the wing, which can make for a big catch, especially at the speeds I use. That gouge is too pointy to roll on its side, and use the nose. This is where I have found the more square nosed (like srg gouge) rolled on its side works. Do not do this cut with the flutes pointing straight up!!!!!

Doug,

That vertical cut is a very high shear angle, which is why it works. However, you can't do that on the inside of a bowl or form. I prefer to hold my tools level. Just more comfortable and controllable for me.

I got an e-mail from Bill Blasic asking if using an aluminum oxide wheel would have made a difference. It has been so long since I have used one, I can't really say for sure. The CBN wheels do tend to leave a more shiny surface than AlO. I doubt that it would matter though. The 80 grit D Way wheel leaves a surface comparable to 80 grit AlO. No matter how fine or how coarse seemed to make no difference.

Another thing that didn't seem to make any difference was the bevel angle, or how thin or thick the wings were. 75 degree scraper rubbing the bevel, 60 degree fluteless gouge, 60 degree standard bowl gouge, swept back thin wings on a HSS bowl gouge.

I always figured that a finer edge would cut better. From the above, it seems like shear angle is the main factor.

robo hippy

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#11

Re: The finish cut:Long!

john lucas

Reed I think the thinner edge does make a difference. I used to use a pull cut on my hand mirrors with a very long wing edge and handle down flute toward me. This was a steep shear angle. The gouge I was using at the time was sharpened more like Ellsworths with the wings being more of a blunt angle. One day I grabbed an old U shaped gouge and the grind had a very thin edge on the wing. I was amazed how well it cut swirly grain. the angle of the edge was just about identical to the other gouge in the way that I used both of them. Since then I've played with both found the thinner wing sharpening angle gives me a better cut.

It seems that way with my bowl gouges as well when using the tip in a push cut.

wouldn't it be fun if we could all get together in one room with our various gouges and some wood and just play and argue over the cuts. I'll bet we would learn an awful lot.

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#12

Re: The finish cut:Long!

robo hippy

I have heard people say that before. It would be interesting to have a sharpening and cutting seminar, pick one nasty punky piece of wood and see what gets the best cut.

Hmmmmm. I will be in San Jose next year......

robo hippy

Re: The finish cut:Long!

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Here's my other cut.

Keith Tompkins

John, that is the exact same cut I use...it even works great from the rim to the foot. Also, looking down on your grind, the sides of the grind appears to curve inward, not sloping away sharply. I find the grind like you show to be more forgiving, not as prone to catch unexpectedly. Man, we gotta turn together! We must be twins or something :D