The finish cut:Long!
robo hippy
Well, after chatting with Mike Mahoney, and getting a comment from him that he preferred a more serrated (rough grinding wheel) edge for finish cuts I started experimenting. I took a nasty old piece of big leaf maple that was too soft for a good finish cut, took every conceivable cutting edge and tool variation I could come up with, and found out a few interesting things.
Sharpening station variations: Tormek 200 grit black wheel, D Way tools CBN wheels 80 and 180 grit, Matrix type CBN wheels 80 and 150 grit.
Scraper edge variations: Honed with no burr, grinder burr, burnished burr, honed burr, burr honed off but bevel not honed, honed on the Tormek and with diamond cards. Scrapers tested, HSS, A 2 from Serious tools, some Doug Thompson scrapers. I even did all of the above with a negative rake scraper.
Gouge steel used: HSS and carbon, some of Doug's gouges, some Glaser.
Gouge flute profiles: Spindle roughing gouges, both standard and continental. Shallow flute, deep flute, V flute, fluteless gouge.
Gouge nose profiles: swept back, fingernail, bottom of the bowl types (similar to SRG but with steeper bevel), 40/40 gouge (Stuart Batty type).
Cuts made: bevel rubbing and non bevel rubbing (often called shear scrape), and scraping (cutting edge 90 degrees to the rotation of the wood).
Most interesting conclusions:
Tool steel makes little difference, at not least anything that can be seen by the naked eye or felt with finger tips.
Bevel rubbing cuts, no matter which tools you use, rubbing the bevel leaves a better surface. Note here, I did bevel rubbing cuts with all the tools, gouges, standard scrapers, and even the negative rake scraper.
The single most important factor seems to be the shear angle. The more vertical the cutting edge, the smoother the cut. Best tools for this were the fluteless gouge from Doug, my scrapers, and the standard spindle roughing gouge. With these tools, it is easy to get the cutting edge at 70 or more degrees. Note here, I used the SRG with flutes rolled away from the wood at 90 degrees to the wood rotation. Dropping the handle way down and rolling the tool slightly on the bevel till it starts to cut. The scrapers I used had a ) profile, and I worked on the bottom half with the handle slightly lowered, keeping the cutting edge balanced over the tool rest, not above center which would make catches probable.
As soon as the bevel comes off the wood, the cut gets rougher, no matter which tool or cutting edge I used, including variations of the burrs, no burrs, and how fine the edge was.
On some solid, highly figured Myrtle wood, I could get great cuts with most of the tools and edges, but still, the best cuts were with high shear angles, and the bevel rubbing. The difference just wasn't as dramatic as with the punky wood.
Standard bowl gouges rolled more on their sides left a good surface, but had a very small sweet spot for the high shear angle, so tended to wear/dull more quickly.
I guess that the high shear angle is like running over speed bumps with your car. If you hit it head on, the bump is pretty sharp. This would be like a scraping cut where the fiber tends to pull out before it cuts. If you hit the speed bump at an angle the bump is way more gentle, so a high shear/tool cutting edge angle will lift the fiber more gently and cut it before it pulls/rips/breaks off.
robo hippy





