Nature assisted me with this little platter -- a story about modern society, of people wanting to connect with each other but unable to. Ironically, while we can talk to each other through the phone, text messages, e-mail, etc., we become disconnected within the local community, making it even harder to find a romantic partner, or even a friend.
The natural "barriers" were provided by Mother Nature at exactly the right spots, and I pyrographized the figures in between.
This piece is signed, dated, and titled, and bears my artist’s signature mark.
Man can I relate. We are obviously both having the same problems. I think everyone stays home now and either stays on the internet or watches TV. I never see my neighbors out, other than the rednecks across the street who like to party.
I don't even know how to go find a date. They certainly don't magically appear in my shop.
Your pieces have me thinking. I designed 2 more pieces yesterday morning while trying to either wake up or stay in bed, never could decide which one. they both have to do with what your talking about so I hope I can pull them off some day soon.
I absolutely agree! I've discovered that the magic person also doesn't appear at woodturning meetings, nor have I found him at a symposium yet. I thought I would have a fairly easy time, seeing as 95% of the woodturning community is male. However, whether young or older, it seems everyone is married.
I wonder if anyone's started a woodturner's online dating site yet??? That would certainly help us folks who spend so much time alone in the wood shop.
attending an active church? Many large churches have very good singles groups of various types and age ranges.
People in a bar are going to view others from the appearance/bar perspective - which is what Katherine found to be unfulfilling. Hopefully, some of those in church will be looking for deeper thinking folks.
I understand what you are trying to say, but I don't think I'd get that without reading it. I think that part of the challenge with a piece like this is that it has to stand by itself.
It wouldn't be obvious to me that any of the four people on the front were lonely because there were four of them. I get the metaphor of being in the same place with people and still not being connected, as I have kids that often sit in the room with their iPads and iPods who might as well be in Uraguay. Still, the "no heart" "no love" "broken heart" symbol on the back sort of confounds me? Why are these four people like this? Are they unwilling to change for love? Are they trying to change the other people? Or have they just not met yet?
The first piece was far more successful in my assessment because I knew exactly what you meant. You have to remember that approximately half the world is male, and we don't want to think that much (not that we can't, we just want it to be simple)
Comparison between the two pieces isn't necessary -- they aren't meant to work together. In person, this piece does stand on it's own, with no explanation card. (Maybe I should leave the explanation off when I post next time?)
I'm designing most of these pieces from more of a fine arts/design perspective rather than a commercial one. In woodturning, this style is not common, and so may be something new to viewers in our community.
The design philosophy: the four people are separated by barriers, a reference to the disconnectedness of our society. The main character is female, as denoted by her larger size in relation to the others. The characters' arms are so close they almost touch, yet are prevented by these walls.
The barriers themselves are not "hard", (pyrographized), instead, left at the figuring of the wood as symbolic of being flexible or breakable, if only there was the impetus of the characters to do so.
They are positioned in an order of male, female, etc. to stir the memory of cultural custom. (Traditional male-female relationship). The X-ed heart on the reverse is the indication of the paucity of love-interaction between them.
The titles are integral to these pieces, (which is another reason I pyrographize them on the reverse side.) The symbols are meant to work together with the titles and/or text.
---
In any case... I am giving you the artist's thoughts behind the work. However, your observation as the viewer is equally valid. Good art will have many interpretations. (And while I would never make a direct comparison), think of the Mona Lisa, and how many different interpretations there are in THAT piece!
That's one of the exciting things about making new work -- to see what my symbols mean to other people, to see if they can relate on some level.
As with my other new work, it's a piece meant to be contemplated, not necessarily understood in two seconds. (In my own collection, I prefer art that has some mystery, some meanings that are not instantly apparent. I've studied the music of Tori Amos for, oh, about 14 years, and I still find new meanings in the songs.)
I wasn't comparing the qualities of this piece to the others for any other reason than to suggest that if you look at the types of comments they solicited, you'll see that they are very different. If you are asking a thought provoking question, I would want the viewer to think about the same question when they view it. If you have to explain it, then perhaps your message isn't very clear?
My issue with this piece is that there isn't the mystery or intrigue that the first one had? Why on the front begs to be picked up to see why what? It pulls the viewer in... a curiousity killed the cat moment. Once you see why... you have to know why what and your challenge is forced upon the viewer. They have to consider the question, even if it is uncomfortable.
This piece just doesn't do that. I'd say that it's more confusing than thought provoking. An as a guy, I'm probably going to look at it and give up. It's not that I can't comprehend your message, but you didn't capture my attention. If you want me to think hard about something, you, as the artist, have to draw me in... and my 0.02 for this piece was... it missed doing that the way the first one did.
You are mistaken. I am not marketing MYSELF. I am not even marketing my work. I am creating artwork that comments on social issues.
Your attack on my person is unjustified. I do not have "social issues." I am secure in my life -- I know exactly who I am and what I want.
The thoughts I wish to provoke are about ART & social commentary. I am not looking for a counseling session.
It is interesting that you label this work as "unacceptable." When I showed this piece in person at several clubs & a symposium, it was critiqued VERY favorably by David Ellsworth, (and other professionals in my area), and many others "got" the message. I understand different turners have different proclivities, but if you bothered to consider the design of the piece, you would find it mature, instead of labeling it "childish."
When I post work on a forum, I am happy to receive CRITIQUE -- meaning a knowledgeable, objective analysis. Your commentary was NEITHER. It is unacceptable for you to attack me personally, and suggest that I have serious problems and need "counseling."
What I am expressing is a view into another world -- one that is NOT represented on the happy-go-lucky TV programs out there; one that is NOT talked about. If that makes you uncomfortable, to the point where you insist on denigrating me, then please find it within yourself to skip my postings all together. It would seem that you are projecting your OWN problems on to me.
Ed Art isn't always meant to be pretty. Sometimes it has to evoke other emotions. Everyone keeps telling us to speak from the heart and then when we do they can't accept the piece. Not jumping on you, I understand where your coming from. It's easy for people to accept, cute, nice, pretty, and cuddly. It's hard for people to accept deeper feelings.
Katherine is taking a risk putting this out there. Other famous artists have had what they call dark periods. If you really make work from the heart it can easily have all these things.
When my favorite cousin passed away I wanted to make something expressing my feelings. Fortunately that piece showed the love she had for her family. I suppose it could have just as easily been a piece about my grief. When you start expressing yourself you take a huge risk, some will like it a some won't.
Thanks for the opinion. It makes us think (which some people tell me hurts)
Katherine - I think these pieces are very interesting in that you are attempting to send a message or ask a question with a wood turning. As a result it doesn't surprise me that you are getting a range of comments from several forum members. Most of us a see a turning and know that we are to like the form, the wood, the finish - or not. We don't expect them to make us think. Your turnings have generated more discussion about what they mean or did the viewer get your meaning.
They always say that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. That is the crux of the continual artsy vs round and brown wood turning discussions. My adult son is a sometime playwright and once wrote a play that was performed at the U. of Richmond. It was around a situation of a young pregnant couple wrestling with whether to have the child or not. Afterword, he had two different analyses from audience members - one that it was pro choice, the other that it was pro life. He said "I must have gotten it just right". Such is the art interpretation world!
I think your pieces are interesting and thought provoking and certainly show that you trying to evoke a range of mental images in your viewers. I actually think that the "folk art" nature of your drawn shapes adds to your goal of jostling the thought process of your audience.
People in a bar are going to view others from the appearance/bar perspective - which is what Katherine found to be unfulfilling. Hopefully, some of those in church will be looking for deeper thinking folks.
For the record, I've never been to a bar. I don't drink. My experience stems from "every day life" -- the office, library, grocery store, woodturning meetings.
I think I "get" what you are doing here. Well, I have my own vision of it. Too many people in our society are seperated by barriers, some invisible, some not, some physical, some not. These people can feel isolated and often rejected by those around them and despite the "sage" advice of some, no church or pastor is going to help. Imagine the un-wed teenage mom-to-be, the guy with the speech impediment that others view as slurred or drunken, the gay couple desperate for a child of their own. How about the abuse victim? The family of the alcoholic? On the outside, they look as normal as anyone but inside...THAT'S where the barriers are.
As a critique of the piece, I would suggest that you could have pyro'd the ambrosia borders even more, leaving a tiny opening in between each figure. For some of us, that would be more symbolically accurate. Trust me.
Now, I want to give a slightly different take and it has to do with phone calls, email, texting etc. I think many would be shocked by how many people only seem to exist online. Phone calls are a joke and face-to-face discussion of issues? Please. It's not possible for far too many, because of the societal stigma's associated with whatever they are going through. Social media (Facebook, Twitter etc) are the ONLY place many feel able to exist, to share what they are going through. Welcome to the new world. It is the new reality, whether we like it or not. I know several people who have been rejected by their families, their co-workers, their church and doctors who said they were under stress of some sort. Duh! Along comes the Twitter-verse. Did you know that there is someone awake somewhere, 24/7 who is not going to judge you, call you fat, pervert, worthless, a slut, fag? Yup, they are out there and they are willing to listen and to care. Don't believe me? Do you doubt the awesome power of social media? Go to youtube and find videos on the "140 Conference".
On last thing, because it truly needs to be said... Until you have been on THIS side of the situation, feeling lost, alone, inadequate or perhaps vastly superior and nobody else realizes it... Until you have cried yourself to sleep because the world doesn't "get" you, until you have lived with the barriers that CANNOT be seen, and until you have stayed in bed for days at a time because if you don't get up, you won't disappoint everyone around you... Until you have been there, DON'T YOU DARE judge someone else!!! You have NO right!!! You have NO authority, moral or otherwise!!!