Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

For Steve A

Posts

Re: For Steve A

#26

Oops,  here it is,

Mike Foster

I must be getting old. That's the second time I've done that in the past 2 days.


Re: For Steve A

#27

Re: Oops,  here it is,

Craig Daymon

Either way, it's a beautiful piece.

Personally, I like the first base better. I think the sharp edges contrast well with the piece and accentuate the curves. The second stand competes a little with the curves of the piece. (This is personal opinion, of course.)

Stem-wise, I like the first, longer stem better. Makes it look more like it is floating, which matches well with the way the piece, to me, conveys a sense of motion.

Really nice work.

Re: For Steve A

#28

Re: Oops,  here it is,

Carole Valentine

Actually, I liked your original base best of all. It directs the eye without competing, yet is it is not just "plain Jane". The texture on this new one competes with the piece itself. Don't care for the curved one at all for much the same reasons.

Re: For Steve A

#29

Mike, if it ain't broke..........

Ruth Niles

That is just the most perfect piece I have seen in a long time. But you know I love all of your work.

I like the original stand exactly the way you did it, it's all in proportion, it lifts the piece, I like the small separation between the stand and the awesome turning. Perfecto! now leave it alone and go make another piece of artwork. : )

Re: For Steve A

#31

You're right Jamie

Mike Foster

Seems the consensus is to stick with the original and you have to respect what Ruth says.

Mike

Re: For Steve A

#32

Re: Oops,  here it is,

Don at Central Illinios

Definitely, the stepped pyramid with the longer rod.