Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Outside bowl profile cutting direction

Posts

Outside bowl profile cutting direction

#1

Outside bowl profile cutting direction

Starry S Chan

Steve's "A teaching epiphany: prompted me to post this.

When I first learned to use a bowl gouge to cut the outside profile, I always cut from bottom to the top. Lately, I am addicted to the Easy Rougher and I found that cutting from top to bottom is easier once I rounded the bottom 1/4. I do a push cut using the upper right corner of the square cutter to do the cutting.

What is the problem of doing this way? Am I developing a bad habit?

Starry

Re: Outside bowl profile cutting direction

#2

Steven Antonucci

Probably

steven antonucci

The wood cutting direction is independent of the tool you cut it with. Everything is Good/Better/Best.

Good is what you are doing.

Better is doing what I describe.

Best is doing what I decribed and having the foot of the vessel at the bark side of the tree (Then the grain is also aligned with the cutting direction.)

Steve

Re: Outside bowl profile cutting direction

#3

Re: Outside bowl profile cutting direction

John Lucas

I agree with Steve. You are talking about a scraper vs a cutting tool. Although it works I believe you can get a cleaner cut when using a cutting tool in the proper down hill grain direction.

It all sort of depends on your skill level with the tool, how much you are willing to sand and basically how well you finish.

A scraper in a skilled hand is an excellent tool. Pattern makers use them and these guys need the ultimate precision. Cutting tools in the hands of professionals leave an exceptional finish. I've watched Stuart Batty turn a piece that he sanded one side to 400 grit and turned the other side straight off the tool. You couldn't tell the difference. I have yet to see a scraper leave that good of a finish although some come close.

So to answer your question. It's all about having fun and what your goals are. If your able to achieve the pieces you want and the quality you want then it really doesn't matter what tool you use to get there or how you cut.

If you have a passion to learn more and get more proficient with tools and create finer forms with less sanding then working with the cutting tools is in your future and worth the effort.

Re: Outside bowl profile cutting direction

#4

Re: Outside bowl profile cutting direction

Terry Scott

My bent is if it dont cut one way cut the other

People often ask me are you cutting up hill or down I say I am cutting sideways l.o.l

Re: Outside bowl profile cutting direction

#5

Re: Outside bowl profile cutting direction

John Lucas

You also have to remember that on a side grain bowl, even though you are cutting more or less with the grain, at 2 points 180 degrees apart you are cutting much more into the grain.

If you look at flat board spinning CCW then these two points are about 10 oclock and 4. As these two points spin past you on some cuts you are actually cutting against the grain. That's why sometimes you'll have 2 areas on the inside of a bowl that just don't want to cut clean.

What I will often do in these cases is to cut in the opposite direction and see if it improves. Usually it will improve the 10 and 4 but leave tearout in the 2 and 8 oclock sections. Sometimes these won't be as bad so I pick the lesser of two evils.

Which direction to cut is pretty straight forward on a flat board with straight grain. Much more difficult when it's an odd shape like a bowl. Throw in some squirly grain like a crotch bowl and your guess is as good as mine which direction to turn, or sometimes even which tool. I have occasionally had a scraper give me a cleaner cut than a cutting tool. It's rare but it happens. Don't get hung up on one technique, feel free to explore. You may learn a new technique you can share with us.

Re: Outside bowl profile cutting direction

#6

Lyle Jamieson

John Lucas for President, very diplomatic