Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

Posts

A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#1

Steven Antonucci

A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

steven antonucci

Earlier this year when I taught my third installment of Intro to Woodturning at Peters Valley, I had an epiphany. All woodturning can be dumbed down to a few simple things. Here is the most profound of these things:

A bowl is just a bead with a cove inside of it.

(T-shirts coming soon...!)

If you take a piece of wood and mount is in spindle orientation between centers, cutting beads and coves is usually very simple to explain. If you want to turn a bead, you start in the center and work center-left and then center right. To turn a cove, you work left-center and then right-center. In either case, the goal should be to keep a consistent cut pace (i.e. same sized curl for the whole cut). On a bead, this means removing the corners first and sneaking up on the final shape in 2-3 passes. On a cove, this means cutting out the middle first, and then sneaking up on the final shape in 2-3 passes. (See John's video)


So what does this have to do with cutting a bowl?

In a typical bow, the grain runs perpendicular to the lathe axis, but it does not mean that the rules of grain direction change at all! The outside of a bowl is a bead, which means you cut from the foot to the rim as if you were cutting a bead. You end up getting both sides of the bead, which is probably a good thing because you don't have to fuss with making them symmetrical.

The inside of a bowl is just a cove cut on the left side, which means you should cut from the rim to the foot as you would cut a cove in a spindle turning. When the wood is oriented in face grain position, you cut both sides of the bead and cove at the same time, and only have to get it right one time instead of twice (and matched!)


(if you look at the drawing, all I did was reorient my notebook like I did with the wood on the lathe. The arrow do not move because the "right direction" or "with the grain" is a constant.

Once you understand this, you can do anything on a lathe (with a sharp tool and a lot of practice...)

Steven

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#2

Steve Kubien

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

Steve Kubien

My "t-shirt" moment is what I had engraved on the back of my iPad... "I make wood round".

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

Keith Tompkins

Hi Steve, In my "Ten essential cuts" demo, I showed the spindle cuts, then the bowl cuts...then, how there was really no difference; if you could turn a good spindle, you could turn a bowl. Good post.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#4

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

John Lucas

Steve I'm doing a demo called making turning easy for our local clubs. I plan to talk about working with the grain and this analogy should help a lot. I just got 288 pencils in the mail. I'm going to glue them up and turn a side grain bowl, an end grain bowl and a spindle. I think they should be able to see the grain direction quite easily in these glue ups.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#5

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

Cyril Griesbach

John, that is such a great idea for showing grain orientation.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

Brad Vietje

Great idea, John....

...now how about turning a bead ON a bowl? That's a little tougher, and people who get pretty good at turning beads on a spindle get pretty frustrated trying to get a bead the first time on the exterior of a bowl.

I gotta try gluing up a box of pencils, though -- that's pretty cool.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#7

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

john lucas

Can't take the credit. Ed Lewis of Chattanooga did it with dowels. I always thought it was a great visual aid but dowels were expensive for that many. When I was down there doing a demo recently someone had a vessel made from glued together pencils so I thought I would see how expensive they are. They aren't cheap but cheaper than dowels and of course very visual. Now I have to figure out how to glue them together.

what I'm thinking is to put about 3 or 4 oz of epoxy in an 8x10 plastic bag. Put the pencils in and roll them around until all are covered. Then just put some tape around the bag to hold them in shape.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#8

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

john lucas

Turning a bead on the exterior of a bowl is really just like turning a bead on a spindle. I use detail gouge and roll the bead from top to side just like I do on a spindle. The only difference is I raise the tool rest a lot to get the spindle gouge in a more comfortable position.

Now turning a bead on a platter (or my hand mirrors) is harder. In this case I move the tool rest way up. I'm talking really far up so I'm turning the bead at about 10:30 or even 11 oclock if the tool rest will go that far. If I can do that I can turn the bead just like on a spindle by starting on top of the bead with the flute toward me and then rolling the gouge to either side just like turning a spindle bead.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#9

Mike Stafford

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

Mike Stafford

A guy in our club did something similar with colored pencils and the resin with which you would cast pen blanks. As I recall he had a fortune invested in this blank.

Jim Rinde, in California, specializes in casting blanks in epoxy and he uses vacuum to ensure that all the voids are filled.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

Mike Stafford

An excellent reminder of the way to make these cuts.

However I was just taught a different way by Richard Raffan who cuts beads on the outside of his bowls with a small spindle gouge and starts at the smaller diameter and works his way up the side the bowl to progressively larger diameters. It works very well when done with a sharp points spindle gouge.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#11

Raffin's way is definitely different.

john lucas

I went home afterwords and tried his method. It works. I guess I'm too comfortable doing it the way I learned. However I have been using the 3 point tool for beads and it works quite well. Of course my homemade beading tool works well but it only gives me the one size of bead.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#12

Steven Antonucci

It's actually the right way.

steven antonucci

If you draw a bead, and then a bowl and follow the arrows, you'll see he's cutting in the right direction. That said, I cut them the wrong way because I can and I am so used to doing it wrong, that I've gotten pretty good at it.

S

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#13

Re: It's actually the right way.

john lucas

I don't know Steve. His is cutting in the right direction from bottom to top of bowl on the outside. But he cuts up hill on the bead. It works obviously.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#14

Steven Antonucci

It's not uphill on a bead.

steven antonucci

Because the grain is facegrain, the left side of the bead is the right direction (foot to rim). The right side is the wrong direction, but still with the grain. (if that makes sense...

When I teach, I separate the right direction and the grain direction. Some times, like in the case of the right side of the bead, you have to cut against the grain, but in the right direction. Generally speaking, the drawing that I posted is correct, but not always obvious. If I think about it, the proper way to turn a bead on a bowl is probably to start on the bottom on the left and go completely to the right bottom. (Man, would that be a hard cut to master in one motion!)

Steve

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#15

Lyle Jamieson

Re: It's not uphill on a bead.

Lyle Jamieson

Steve, that is not hard at all. Al Stirt taught me that method ages ago. Let me try to put it into text. Use a spindle gouge with a tip angle of around 45 degrees or less and a swept back wing. Start with the flute up and the bevel against the wood. Tool rest a little high will help but not as high as John indicated. Roll the right side of the bead by rolling the flute to the right and lifting the handle to get to the bottom of the first grove. At the bottom, the flute is facing directly right. Now start to lower the handle and open the flute slightly. This motion will actually sheer scrape the left side of the bead. At the apex of the bead we are handle down again and the flute up again. To start right side of the bead ride the bevel down and raise the handle again. Repeat. So the motion requires you to move the handle up and down in a pumping motion. This is so sweet with a sharp tool, there is no sanding required. Sharp tool is critical because half the bead is actually sheer scrapped. I sharpen after every 3 or 4 beads.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#16

Mike Stafford

Re: It's not uphill on a bead.

Mike Stafford

Lyle's description is exactly how Richard showed me. A sharp gouge is essential.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#17

Re: It's not uphill on a bead.

John Lucas

I am having trouble follow this. The first part sounds like what I'm doing. I use a detail gouge bevel up, tool on top of bead, move tool to the right while twisting the tool so the flute faces right. I lift the handle so the cutting edge moves from the tip of the tool to the side. As I finish the cut the flute is to the right and the tool is cutting at about 3 oclock on the edge of the gouge. On this final part of the cut the cutting edge would be deep down almost like using the toe of the skew to finish off a bead.

If I understand you correctly we are the same at this point. Now are you shear scraping the left side of the next bead, the one to the right of the one you just did. If your opening up the flute it seems like it would change from a shear scrape to cut. I've forgotten exactly how Rafffen did it. Wish I had time to do a short video to help with this discussion.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#18

Lyle Jamieson

Re: It's not uphill on a bead.

Lyle Jamieson

John it is really hard to put it into writing without pictures. It is so easy to miss one little element that would make all the difference.

As I make the right side of the bead the cutting action stays up near the tip of the tool with a standard push cut with the bevel supporting the cut.

The left side of the second bead is sheer scraped, true. With the flute facing 3:00 and the tip of the tool deep in the groove between the beads the handle is in the up position. Lowering the handle as you come up the left side of the second bead will keep you in a sheer mode. For a short time the cut is off the bevel. About half way up the left side of the bead the transition (from the bottom grove to the top of the next bead) will get the bevel back on the surface to come accross the top radius of the bead with the handle down. So I would guess that about 2/3 of the bead will have bevel support. The handle is moving significantly up and down with each bead.

Clear as mud?? Way too deep for most people. The terminology is not universal. It is too easy to misinterpret the lingo.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#19

Re: It's not uphill on a bead.

john lucas

Thanks Lyle. I think that is what I remember from Raffin. I just haven't done it in a long time. Too bad we can't just do some sort of mind meld and transfer what we think in out heads directly to someone else. Come to think of it they tried a mind meld on me once and it blew a fuse. :)

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#20

Lyle Jamieson

Re: It's not uphill on a bead.

Lyle Jamieson

I would not have enough matter to make the link or blow a fuse.

Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#21

Steven Antonucci

Full disk drive, but it's got some bad sectors...


Re: A teaching epiphany: Bowls and beads

#22

Lyle Jamieson

I run off track sometimes