Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

RC Helicopter's Battery Life & Turning

Posts

RC Helicopter's Battery Life & Turning

#1

RC Helicopter's Battery Life & Turning

charlie belden

If you've been to a large mall recently, you've probably seen a guy at a little booth flying a small, remote controlled helicopter. The guy at the booth makes it looks so easy and effortless, swooping then hovering, slowly rotating the helicopter in place then rising to swoop about again.

You ask about the flight time given that these things run on a very small battery. Surprised at the short flight time of only three to five minutes, you assume that a tiny rechargeable battery is necessary for the thing to get off the ground. Only after you try and fly a little RC helicopter do you realize how "not so easy" it is to get it to do what you want it to do. And you quickly come to realize that maintaining the concentration and fine motor control required is exhausting to maintain for more than three or four minutes. Rubbing your stomach while patting your head and chewing gum - while hopping on one foot and doing a mental multiplication table - is easy by comparison.

For me at least, hollowing through a small opening is very much like flying a small RC helicopter. I can only maintain focus and tool control for a few minutes before I'm at the edge of tool control, attention span - and disaster. The farther past the tool rest I go, the shorter period of time I can spend removing wood. Passed about four or five inches I find myself clenching my jaw and making lighter and lighter cuts for about 30 seconds - which prolongs the Total Time Of Tension ( and stress).

And this is IF I'm working with DRY wood - that's fairly stable- and permits many breaks. Turning GREEN hasn't lent itself to frequent breaks - things move too much, too fast. I've sworn off madrone - green or dry - moves no matter what I don't like Beat The Clock turning.

Do YOU turn a piece beginning to end in one grueling / enjoyable session and if so, how long IS that session.

Or

Do YOU turn some, hollow some, take a break, come back to it . . .

If so, is that only with DRY wood?

Is it possible to do thin walled hollow forms - using green wood?

Re: RC Helicopter's Battery Life & Turning

#2

Katherine Kowalski

Depends on your proclivities...

Katherine Kowalski

Charlie,

There is a huge difference in hollowing methods as well as wood choice, all which affects what one experiences.

For small boxes, I will use a negative-rake scraper, but when I make anything larger, I always reach for my Jamieson system. (For those who are new, it is a captured bar system).

For hollowing, I prefer to turn wet burl more than anything else. (Boxelder Burl (Manitoba Maple) is choice #1, followed by any number of Australian burls, especially the ones with voids).

I turn my pieces all in one session. My experience is rather the opposite of yours -- instead of being fatigued, I find that my concentration sharpens, and I learn the inside of the piece as well as the outside. It's quite relaxing, almost a zen experience.

(Now that I'm talking about it, I've forgotten how much I enjoy hollowing! Been making LOTS of platters, I gotta start another series of hollow forms...)

It's strange, I sometimes hollow with my eyes closed, and just feel the form with the tool. (The Jamieson system uses fingertip control, so there's no tension, no leverage required). Depending on the opening size and the volume of the vessel, a turning/hollowing session might take 3-5 hours. (It goes faster if your piece has voids!) :D

On the other hand... hollowing with hand-held tools was exhausting! It's much more difficult to judge the position of the tool since the turner is positioned further from the vessel. With a captured bar, the turner is off to the side, and makes visualization of the tool position easier.

My advice is to try different wood or different tools -- hollowing should be a PLEASURABLE experience, not an exasperating one. Have fun with it!

Katherine

Re: RC Helicopter's Battery Life & Turning

#3

Re: Depends on your proclivities...

Donna Banfield

Pretty much agree with everything that Katherine said. I, too, use the Jamieson captured boring bar when hollowing, and admit that I haven't done much of it lately.

But when doing so, I turn/hollow in one session, always using green wood. IF I MUST leave it for more than 5 minutes, I will spray/soak it with water, cover with a large plastic bag to reduce air/drying/movement, and return to it as quickly as possible.

Also like Katherine, I've never experienced a problem with distraction or losing focus or concentration. When you have a "fire in your belly" for what you do, lack of focus has never been a problem for me :-)

Re: RC Helicopter's Battery Life & Turning

#4

Re: Depends on your proclivities...

John Lucas

Interesting analogy Charlie. I guess I am a little bit of both. When hand hollowing I start out kind of ragged. Then I get a feel for things it starts to get easier. For really deep things I then run into your situation. I'll use the analogy of golf. I start off hitting great shots and half way through I start duffing. I don't even know exactly what I'm doing because it feels like I'm hitting the ball the same way. Well hollowing big pieces by hand is sort of like that with me. I start out weak, get strong and then start to fail. It's probably fatique because I don't do a lot of big hollow vessels by hand.

It just so much easier for me using my homemade version of the Jamieson system. You are so relaxed when cutting this way because it takes not physical effort at all.

Re: RC Helicopter's Battery Life & Turning

#5

Steven Antonucci

Most things I make in 90 minutes or less

steven antonucci

Typically if I am turning a "small vessel" (<6" dia), I can cut the entire thing in about an hour to +/- 3/16". The truth is that most of the time spent hollowing is actually removing the shavings, not cutting. If you want to test a theory, take a 6" round and turn it until is it completely gone, using whatever tool you want. It might take 5 minutes to completely waste the entire block.

Tension comes from doing it infrequently. If you have made more than a few forms, the tension usually is replaced with impatience, since 50 of the 60 minutes will be spent with the lathe off and the compressor blowing shavings. For me, it's more like the 5 minutes of flight time with the 20 minutes to recharge my batteries.

Having a system "help me" is analagous to switching on the autopilot on my little RC. It may work better and fly longer, but it sure is boring...

S

Re: RC Helicopter's Battery Life & Turning

#6

Re: Depends on your proclivities...

charlie belden

Maybe it was just this piece. Christmas ornaments in dry wood, through a 1/2" hole don't stress me out when hollowing them. And larger (for a JET mini) hollow forms that I can use the MiniMonster on aren't white knuckle experiences. I do hollow forms in dry wood, preferably straight grained. This one is root burl, green. tall and narrow. Burl is unfamiliar, green is unfamiliar and this form is unfamiliar.

The fact that the piece kept changing dimensions as I hollowed from top to finish thickness then working downward didn't help. I was using John Jordan's 1/4" diameter straight and goose neck hand helds once I got under the undercut top done with a much smaller straight shank with an insert cutter set at about 45 degrees. Found that a green wood tenon has some give to it if there's a catch


This thing ovalized as it was being turned. Even with a damp washclothe wrapped around it and a zip lok bag over that - it kept moving.


The rays in the piece shrunk more than the adjacent wood, producing a shallow fluting effect. Interesting in hand.

Plan on bleaching the piece then trying a Pytlik dying from inside thing.

Have another blank this size in the freezer and a bunch of larger blanks of this burl under damp towels on the driveway. Will do some experimenting with these small pieces before taking on a "real" hollow form - that I can use the MiniMonster on.