Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

mighty Oak

Posts

mighty Oak

#1

Dick Hines

mighty Oak

dick hines

I was ridding around today and started to notice that except for pines the mighty oak fell over more than any other tree.

Want to guess the tree that held up better any any other?

......................sweet gum. Last storm was the same way.

I guess the mighty oak ain't so mighty

.,

Re: mighty Oak

#2

Re: mighty Oak

Carole Valentine

Seems one the others that goes easily is Pecan.

Re: mighty Oak

#3

Dick Hines

Re: mighty Oak

dick hines

Way more oaks than pecans over here. Believe. I Have been checking. My saw in the truck.

Re: mighty Oak

#4

Steven Antonucci

Oaks down here too

steven antonucci

Blown over at the roots, assume it's the broad, dense canopy that does them in. A big surface area in high winds is a losing proposition...

steve

Re: mighty Oak

#5

Same thing during Isabel.......

Richard Jones

when I was doing damage assessment after Isabel in Chesterfield, the red oak was far and away the leader in the blown-over-and-land-in-the-living-room category.

See the same thing in this county, fortunately on a much smaller scale.

Rich

Re: mighty Oak

#6

Re: mighty Oak

Ed Heuslein

Here in East Texas, due to the drought, Red Oaks are the first to go. I've lost dozens - all of the leaves are still on the tree but every leaf is a dried up piece of toast that crumbles in your hand. Right behind them are my Dogwoods. Those are the ones I hate to lose the most. The darn Sweet Gums and pine are looking just fine! Go figure. Hopefully we'll finall get some rain this weekend.

Re: mighty Oak

#7

Re: mighty Oak

Carole Valentine

Oaks and pines seem to dominate the woodscape here, so yes, when there are high winds a lot of them go! There are a lot fewer pecans (they are planted rather than native) but it seems proportionately that a heck of a lot more of them go. I am trying to get my tree man in to do something about all these Oaks and pines around my house before we get a storm in which I am not so lucky.

Re: mighty Oak

#8

Waterlogged ground

Jorge Casta�eda

and high winds is a very bad combo if you are a tree.

There are more red oaks than any other tree in the country, so that is another factor why we see so many down.

Re: mighty Oak

#9

Steven Antonucci

It grew by the lake...

steven antonucci

Which was very high the day of the storm. The dam was almost overflowing, but held.

It was big, and today I walked past it again. I decided to count rings, and unofficially, I think it's going to be 15-150 years old, which really makes me sad, since it saw a bunch of events like the past week, and survived all of them. I will definitely grab some of it for a few memorial projects.

Steve

Re: mighty Oak

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: mighty Oak

Mike Stafford

I have no facts or figures to add to the assessment of which trees here fell during Irene.

It seems more of the log piles in front of home are filled with pines, poplars and oaks. Bradford pears are in the brush piles.

I don't know if this is an accurate observation but it seems to me that stand alone trees in the home landscape which were not part of large planting beds covered with mulch in which smaller trees and shrubs were also planted fell in greater numbers. The 100 foot tall telephone pole pines which line the property lines at the back of many of the homes on the golf course here are not friends of homes when they fall as they slice houses in two with ease.

The number of trees available to the limited number of turners where I live is huge. I think there are only 3 turners here... In my experience the wood grown in the sandy soil of our area is not of the best quality being somewhat brash in texture.

Re: mighty Oak

#11

Re: mighty Oak

Carole Valentine

Mike, you are right about the tall pines. Though they sway and bend with the wind, they also have 99% of their "sail" at the very top. A lot of times they will snap 10 or 20 feet above the ground. Ones such as you describe, along driveways, etc. have also usually grown fast and probably have a proportionally weaker root system and trunk. It is mostly pines that I will have removed today. I simply cannot bear to touch the big White Oak in front of the house, even though she is far to close. She has been there too long and is too beautiful. Hope I have reached an agreement with her...we will spare each other!

Glad you and your family came through with no personal injury or too much damage. Have seen some horrific damage on TV, but mostly from water it seems.

Re: mighty Oak

#12

Re: mighty Oak

Bob Macgregor

We pretty much dodged the Irene bullet here...just some moderate winds and light rain...but I wondered about windfirmness of trees after looking at a picture from NYC of a bunch of trees down. Most landscaping trees in an urban setting have been transplanted to their site. This means that trees which, in the wild, would have a tap root must instead rely on laterals for stability. Secondly, soil conditions in urban setting are often really suboptimal for root spreading/penetration or general health of the tree...not to mention mechanical damage from cars, lawnmowers, weedwhackers, etc. Finally, as pointed out by others, urban and suburban trees often grow in exposed locations, unprotected by a forest windbreak; they also are often faced with peculiar wind regimes (eg funneling of winds around buildings).

Of course, pretty much any urban/suburban tree is going to face some or all of these challenges, but some are less able to adapt to the urban setting. Some are more flexible, some sink roots better, some are less liable to internal defect/rot, etc. I'm guessing that the amputated tap root is a problem for some urban-transplanted red oaks. Also, isn't red oak relatively hard, stiff and brittle which traits wouldn't help it stand up well against the huge wind resistance of the leaf canopy.

BOB