Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Broken bowl gauge

Posts

Broken bowl gauge

#1

Broken bowl gauge

Bob Rogne

I was working on a vase this am and was trying to clean up a spot in the bottom. Was using my 6 month old very good 1/2 in. bowl gauge maybe to far over the rest. Bang, it snapped off just about at the end off the V.

Question. I know I was to far over the rest but should it have snapped.

Looking at the broken end there is a very uneven color of the metal.

Should I connect the mfg? or is the new great metals very brittle?

I have heard of files snapping off but never a new 2011 high tech one.

Bob Rogne

West MacTurnings

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#2

Re: Broken bowl gauge

Ed Moore in SW VA

Bob,

I would recommend that you contact the manufacturer and tell them exactly what happened. There is a question of brittleness in some of the better woodturning steels.

Ed

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#3

Re: Broken bowl gauge

Bob Rogne

Thanks Ed

That is what I plan on doing. Just wanted to hear if this is a problem with the new metals.

Bob

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#4

Richard Allen

Re: Broken bowl gauge

Richard Allen

That sounds like a defect but I don't know what you were doing. Cleaning up the bottom of a vase shouldn't have that much force involved.

Many tools are tempered hard through the cutting portion of the tool and left less hard (tougher) through the non-milled portion of the tool. That would tend to make the area where the heat treating changes suspect.

Contact the manufacture and ask what they think. Once the issue is resolved let us know what happened.

I broke a parting tool from Sorby years ago. The company rep was at the store doing a demo I was watching. I showed him the tool and without a blink he walked over tho the wall of tools, retrieved a replacement and handed it to me. He then took a close look at the tool and asked me about the circumstances. I tried to hand back the new tool as I felt the break was my fault. He wouldn't take the new tool back. He even handed me back the broken tool and suggested that I could grind a new tang and mount it in a handle.

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#5

Re: Broken bowl gouge

Greg Haugen

Bob,

There's a graph on Glaser's website's front page about the comparison of wear resistance to toughness of different steels at various hardness. As the wear resistance is improved, the toughness is decreased. No one makes 1/16" thin parting tools in the high end steels and there's a reason for that. They would be too brittle and not flexible enough. There is a trade off. Even though, you say, you were further over the tool rest, it's not a common occurrence and incredible rare to break a gouge. Talk with the manufacturer.

Glad you didn't get hurt.

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#6

Re: Broken bowl gauge

John Lucas

I would definitely talk to the manufacturer. If it was a problem with quality I think they would want to know. If it is a problem with your technique they may be able to help you. As was mentioned above. They make tools hard to add edge retention. My understanding is that the newer metals are less brittle but everything has a limit. Give em a call.

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#7

Re: Broken bowl gauge

jim miles - Charlotte

Done that! Made new tool. Took 1" diameter x 3' long metal bar- drilled hole in end, added set screws inserted about a 4" piece of broken gouge. Now makes a great tool for going way over the tool rest to the bottom of something deep

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#8

Walt Bennett

Re: Broken bowl gauge

Walt Bennett

Interesting. I had a Crown heavy duty bowl scraper (hook type) break at the tang about five years ago for no real reason. I took it to where I'd purchased it (Woodcraft) and they replaced it with no questions. The newer one has been fine.

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#9

Don Leydens

Re: Broken bowl gouge

Don Leydens

A quick thank you to Greg. I have been wondering why you can't buy a high end parting tool for some time. Thanks for the answer.

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#10

Re: Broken bowl gauge

Paulo Marin

Sometimes, in a high production environment, certain procedures could be overlooked which could cause a serious issue. resulting in breakage.

There is a very recent thread on Sawmill Creek about a woodturner who experienced a breakage at the tang area. His pictures, clearly show that the tool was NOT inserted properly in the wooden handle, creating a "weak spot" in case of a catch.

Ultimately, the answer is absolute quality control. Just because we are dealing with a hobby, does not mean that the quality should be overlooked.

As we all know, woodturning is a dangerous activity where we are in direct contact with a rotating piece of wood. In metal manufacturing, the operator is protected when the doors of the CNC are closed. In woodturning, is a different story.

Most importantly is to minimize all risk aspects by wearing proper protection and using common sense (although most of the time is not common).

I would like to see a picture of this breakage. It is a perfect opportunity to learn in order to improve guidelines and prevent future injury.

Manufacturers have the RESPONSIBILITY to strive to achieve the best possible quality. They should establish the proper procedures and obviously carry a substantial amount of liability insurance.

After all, like what happened not too long ago when Joan passed away being hit with a dislodged piece of wood, if a woodturner gets severely injured with a tool, I assure you a lawsuit will follow.

Ultimately, it is good to know that no injury has occurred ! One more reason to tighten up those quality control procedures

Paulo Marin

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#11

Re: Broken bowl gauge

bill Crommett

I have two 1 1/2 inch roughing gouges with new tangs that were the result of forgetting to move the rest when the work piece got rounded off. The new tangs were ground, then replaced in the handle with a 1/4 in bar glued with JB weld. Nobodys fault but mine, and they work just like new.

Re: Broken bowl gauge

#12

JL

Gotta love Sorby

JL

They sent me a replacement center (or is it centre?) pin for my Steb centre. Express mail, no charge.