Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

Posts

Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#1

Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

charlie belden

Maybe I've just got some bad madrone burl - with all sorts of bark inclusions, splits and cracks that seen to run in all directions. Even after boiling in water for three hours it seems to want to tear itself apart - as I TRY to turn it. There just doesn't seem to be any solid wood big enough to turn - even a bottle stopper.

Is this just the nature of arial madrone burl - or did I just get lucky?

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#2

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

Jim Swank

From what I've read, it's the nature of the beast. I understand you have to pressure cook it, not just boil it, to get it stable. I'm not sure I have a reliable source for that info, but it's a direction to start cchecking.

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#3

Ellis Walentine

Luck of the Irish

Ellis Walentine

You are Irish, aren't you? :)

I got some gorgeous madrone burl planks about 15 years ago from David Marks, and it was solid, creamy and beautiful to work, with no inclusions or cracks at all. That said, it tended to be sensitive to relative humidity changes, in that it had a tendency to twist slightly -- not too badly, but a measurable amount. The wood -- at least the burl -- doesn't seem to have much strength or stiffness, so it is wise to anchor it well if you're using it for flat construction. I have never turned it, but I imagine it would turn beautifully, but again, possibly want to warp or twist, especially if turned green.

I guess mileage varies.

Ellis

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#4

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

charlie belden

It'd take a hell of a big pressure cooker since this was an 85 inches in circumference burl - about 2 plus feet in minimum diameter. Even after cutting it into FIVE wedges, the pieces are still too big to fit in any pressure cooker I can afford. As it was, I could barely get two of the ten pieces I cut from just one of the original five slices in the two largest stock pots I've got. It looked like I had a Witches Brew going in my front kitchen (there's also a Back Kitchen).

I've heard that wood suppliers "steam" woods like walnut and cherry to a) speed up the drying time and b) get a more uniform color between the heartwood and sapwood. I've also heard that the steaming process "washes out" the heartwood colors (did you know that "persian walnut" has purples in it?).

The trouble with the pieces I have of this burl is not cracking due to drying but rather the weird bark inclusions and voids that seem to be the results of how the burl formed - as if it was folded and twisted and folded some more. Reminds me a lot of an illustration of a cross section of a brain.

BTW - the After Boiling water was a beautiful dark red orange. Should've saved it. Someone doing "natural dye" work would go ape over it.

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#5

Re: Luck of the Irish

charlie belden

David seems to have a real knack for acquiring really nice wood. Helps if you're hooked in with arborists, WoodMizer owners and half the lumber yards and mills in Northern California and southern Oregon. Not quite on par with George Nakashima's or James Krenov's wood stashes - but close.

Had this been quarter sawn trunk boards I'm sure the problems I'm having with this burl would be significantly fewer. The part of the trunk just above and below this burl were fine - pale yellow brown, fairly straight fine grained and nondescript. The burl on the other hand looks like it was twisted and folded then twisted and folded some more. Very much reminds me of a cross section of a brain.

I think I'm gonna stick with maple, walnut, fruit woods , ash, beech, black acacia, pepper, sycamore, deador cedar and maybe redwood - and skip the next madrone arial burl. Hopefully, the Bay Laurel (aka Bay Myrtle) burl that's coming will be more coopetative (and yes, that was a Drive By Neener)

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#6

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

robo hippy

Charlie,

My condolences. That is what happens to madrone that has sat too long before processing. Boiling only works on fresh green madrone (no need for pressure cooker, bring to a boil in the water, boil for 1 hour per inch of thickness, then allow to come to room temp in the water, remove, let dry for a bit, and seal). The logs I get never last through the summer, which is our dry season here in western Oregon. It will survive the rainy winter just fine, but even covered with heavy vynal tarps and sealed, it will self destruct. It needs to be processed as soon after cutting as possible. Just the nature of madrone. It has a way higher water content than other woods which is why it warps so much, and why the big lumber mills don't want to mess with it. The extreme warping is why I love it so much, plus it cuts like butter. I had a 22 inch bowl when it came off the lathe. Finished warping at 25 by 17 inches.

robo hippy

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#7

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

Karen F.

I am in the middle of turning a soon to be urn out of Madrone. I bought it from our supplier in Oregon about 5 months ago. As soon as I got it I sealed all of the sides and put it in a thick plastic bag. It was stored inside my shop (North San Diego) and it sat there. A month ago I rough turned a hollow form about 12" tall and 10" wide, 1" thick with the chuck hold still attached.

Then it was time for boiling. I bought a large tamale / stock pot ($25.00) and boiled for about 4 hours. Yes the water turned quite red but the form did not crack or even warp very much. The other day I turned it down to about 1/4" thick and I'm covering it with a towel, paper towels inside and lightly wrapped with a plastic bag. I have been switching them out every few days and there is very little moevment. The wood it still quite wet but so far it's behaving like most wet wood and has very little tear out.

I'm waiting until it dries some more to sand it and cut the base. The color is gorgeous and I can't wait to finish it. I will post a picture when I get it done. If you leave it in the sun or even uncovered when it's wet it get the worst cracks and warping unless you anticipate it and encourage it. I hope this helps.

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#8

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

charlie belden

Seems madrone TRUNK wood is much better behaved than this arial (as in "all the way around the trunk - 20 feet off the ground) burl. As you can see from these cut and boiled for several hours pieces, this stuff is quite different from normal trunk wood.


Here are two I've started to turn - the top one has been boiled, the bottom one hasn't been boiled. That's half a larger bottle of medium CA glue soaked into a LOT of shavings stuffed in all the cracks and crevices in hopes of avoing dodging flying chunks of wood that would otherwise likely fly off these things.


NOW do you understand why I call this The Devil's Wood?

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#9

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

Karen F.

How long was it sitting out? Mine has burl and straight grain so I'm not sure where it came from on the tree. I had some other Madrone that looked exactly like yours complete with cracks and warping when I left it in the back of the car in the heat. It cracked within the first hour when it got hot and not bagged.

I think sometimes it is the luck of the draw. I had some Walnut burl that looked like that with all the bark inclusions and dirt. Good Luck and don't give up on Madrone if you get another chance.

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#10

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

Ralph Lindberg

I'd like to echo and re-enforce Robo's post

We only work Madrone in the cool and wet seasons, starting about now (the local club has a shipment arriving in three weeks). We work it rough RIGHT AWAY, or keep it wet, wet, wet.

I (and others) have cut it into spindle stock (rolling pins, pepper mills, etc) or rough turned it to vessels, then boiled and boiled it (an hour an inch). I use an old Navy Kettle.

That being said, others just sink it in a stock tank of water until it's time to work it (Dale Larson told me in July, he had just put 2800 lbs into tanks)

FYI, the red water we get, only treats the surface. So this year I am trying something. I boiled the Madrone "soup" down and am using it as a water based stain on some of my Madrone, really punches up the color. But I have to keep the rag moving and keep it wet, the entire time I am staining the wood. Then I have to sand it with about 330 grit to take down the raised grain.

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

#11

Re: Madrone Burl - The Devil's Wood?

charlie belden

Even only moderately dry, this stuff definitely doesn't turn "like butter". Maybe if it were green it would, but this piece . . . And the cracks don't make for smooth cuts either.

But I'm giving it a go anyway.


Apologies for the image quality - but it does show the shape, the color and some of the details. The height is about 7"

Undercutting at the top has been a white knuckled, jaw clenched thing - but I want to keep as much of the "natural edge" as possible.