Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

Posts

U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#1

U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

Stuart Johnson

My neighbor took down a large Cedar Elm and for once I have enough green wood to look at each piece as practice material. As a result I am working on form but more important I'm concentrating on how each tool works with open bowls so I can see the tool tip. The Hunter #3 is putting up a good fight but will eventually fall but in the meantime it's teaching me new ways to get violent catches. I think with this tool it is going to a sudden realization of what I'm doing or not doing.

The other tool I'm having a major problem using is of all things a U-shape 5/8� fingernail grind Thompson 5/8� bowl gouge. It's a delight to use when roughing the outside. I'm able to get good smooth, controlled cuts with no effort. My problems start when I'm hollowing the center.

I have a Super Nova chuck so I need a dovetailed tenon which for whatever reason I have trouble cutting with nice flat shoulders and a clean dovetail. I'm also working on this issue. Anyway, after a few cuts to flatten the face I mark the roughed thickness and start hollowing. At the beginning I don't have any problems but when I start moving from the outside and sweep to the center I'm doing something to cause the blank to wobble the closer I get to center. I'm not getting catches but I am doing something and the blank will loosen just a bit and cause the wobble. I have to stop and tighten the chuck. A couple more passes and it is loose again.

Yesterday I decide to solve this so I could move on. The first step was to check the chuck and dovetail match when the chuck was tight. All was good. I started the lathe and spun it up much faster than I would turn. There was hardly and vibration. I slowed down and with the gouge freshly sharpened made my first cut very carefully watching that I was rubbing the bevel. Everything looked good. But once again after a couple cuts I had knocked the bowl loose.

At this point I laid down the Thompson and went to a 1/2� V shaped gouge with same grind. I knocked the handle off when I went to the Kelton handle so I don't know the brand. I re-tightened the chuck and proceeded to complete the roughing out, probably more than 75% of the total with no problem. This leads me to believe it is the gouge. Not the Thompson but the Johnson holding the handle. The differences between the two aren't great 5/8� vs 1/2� and U vs V shape, problem with 5/8� U and none with 1/2� V. I am firmly convinced there is something I am doing or not doing that is causing my problem but can't figure it out. One other thing that makes me pretty sure it is me is I did also give a brief go at using a Thompson 3/8 U-shape with his grind and had no better results. FWIW, I started out turning with V shaped gouges.

Any ideas on what I'm doing wrong or suggestions on fixing learning curve?

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#2

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem *LINK*

john lucas

without standing over your shoulder it's hard to diagnose a problem like this. I'm guessing that you may be forcing the gouging by pushing on it. As the cut nears the middle the surface speed of the wood is lower so the tool will naturally want to cut slower. If you force it by pushing you get chatter like your talking about. Chatter will help the chuck lose it's grip because as the wood vibrates it compresses where the jaws are pushing.

Do you have a shoulder on your tenon? If you just have a straight tenon it lets the bowl rock in the chuck and you will lose the grip of the chuck much faster. Then tenon should not bottom out on the face of the chuck. There should be a shoulder at the top of then tenon. This shoulder should bottom out on the top of the jaws. This provides 2 points of reference on the chuck and helps keep the wood from rocking.

The difference in the V or U shape has nothing to do with your problem. Mostly the difference is in how the wood comes out of the flute, the shape the tip will be after grinding and the thickness of the wings after grinding.

I you haven't seen my video's on the usage of the Hunter tool I urge you watch them. They should help you reduce the catches. They are on Mike Hunter's website.


http://www.hunterwoodturningtool.com/tutorials/

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#3

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

robo hippy

I will agree with John that the gouge is most likely not the problem. Tool presentation would more likely be the cause.

Mounting the bowl could be part of the problem. When mounting with either a tenon/spigot or mortice/recess, you need the jaws snug, but not as tight as you can crank it down. If you have a keyed chuck, snug it up in one key hole, then rotate to the other key hole and snug it up again. On large bowls in the 14 to 16 inch range, I will rotate and snug it up a couple of times.

How you orient the grain in the chuck can be part of the problem too. If you have 2 of the jaws on the end grain, and 2 on the side grain, the bowl can work loose. End grain will not compress nearly as much as side grain does. With dry wood, this is less of a problem than with green wood where you actually squeeze water out. You start out snug, and the turning stresses make the side grain compress, while the end grain doesn't. You end up with 2 jaws holding the wood tight, and the other 2 not. Rotate the bowl 45 degrees off the end grain (end grain centers between two jaws, not on one jaw) and that will give you a better grip. Some times with really sloppy wet wood, you need to tighten up during turning anyway.

Check to see if your chuck jaws are screwed down tight to the chuck. I have had mine work loose, and that changes your grip.

If your gouge is bouncing as you get near the center of the bowl, that is most likely from you pushing the gouge through the wood faster than it wants to cut. This is a touchy/feely thing where you can 'feel' if the wood is cutting properly. Your handle hand is the driving force for that cut, not both hands.

robo hippy

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#4

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

Stuart Johnson

John I've watched your videos a number of times but there is a disconnect between watching the video and the shop. I'll get there.

I've known from the beginning there is not a problem with the gouge but with what I'm doing. Two things I'm hearing so far and will work on are:

1. I'm trying to push the tool faster than it wants to cut.

More than likely I'm used to the V gouge and automatically adjust the feed rate

properly.

2. Paying attention to how the grain is oriented in the chuck and not crunching down when tightening it is important.

I don't remember seeing anything about the grain orientation before but it sure makes sense.

Thanks for the help.

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#5

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Stuart, you did not indicate how deep a bowl you are working on nor the nose angle of the gouges you are using. Is it possible that you are trying to push a shallow angled nose around too tight a curve near the bottom of the bowl? If so, try re-grinding a gouge to a nose angle of 60 degrees or so and grinding back the heel for additional clearance and trying again. Just a thought.

Dennis

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#6

maybe the chuck not gouge

Darryl

Stuart which Nova chuck are you using? If it is the one with the hex adjustment it might be worth looking at the chuck itself. I found that the gears on the "gimbal" that tightens the chuck were wearing. An inexpensive replacement of that fitting solved a similar loosening problem. Bob the Tech in Florida (teknatool) will be able to assist in getting the correct part. Cost about $11.00 or so.

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#7

Steve Kubien

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

Steve Kubien

I would be leaning heavily on what has already been written but I will add that I am fairly useless with a U-shape flute, especially on the inside of bowls. My V's are my go-to gouges for 95% of my bowl work.

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#8

Steven Antonucci

The answer lies at your finger tips.

steven antonucci

I teach a lot of new turners how to cut a bowl, and it almost alway lies in whether or not you are on the bevel. Even a dull tool will cut remarkably well if the bevel is rubbing. I try to illustrate the movement of the handle to make sure that they know where it needs to be at the top of the bowl, down the side wall, and around the bottom.

If you aren't struggling to make these motions, the odds are that you are doing them wrong. They are highly unnatural and involve shifting your weight without moving your feet or changing your cutting pace or the size of your shaving. When I teach, I start the cut and then proceed to make the cut one handed to show how little pressure it take and how important the bevel is, then I show the students that they can do it to by making them cut one handed.

And then they go back to doing it their own way :)

S

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#9

Mike Mills

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

Mike Mills

Hi Stuart,

First, a disclaimer, some people swear they have 50mm Nova jaws which are dovetailed on the inside and I do not doubt them.

That said, I have two Supernovas, a G3, and a SN2; all came with 50mm jaws and none are dovetailed on the inside.

It is easy for the eye to fool a person with a true dovetail outside and lip inside.

Open the jaws on your chuck and take a steel straight edge (ruler, or machinist square), place flat on the base and notice the gap/dovetail.

There is a true dovetail on the outside on mine. Not so on the inside.

If you go to the info received with you chuck and go to Forming Spigots� it MAY say this��. All of mine do.

FORMING SPIGOT:

The 50mm standard jaw has a thin lip or shoulder at the front face. This is designed to bite into the timber as the jaws are tightened. DO NOT CUT A RECESS FOR THE LIP TO FIT INTO, AS THIS WILL REDUCE GRIPPING POWER.


If you go to Nova�s website and lookup the dovetail tool you will notice it is only profiled to cut a dovetail for expansion holding (recess).A few of the very largest jaws do have interior dovetails.

The picture shows the jaws I have. The inside gap is about 1mm (1/24"?). The length of the �lip� is only about 3 mm of the 12mm length.

In my sketch, the wood at A must be crushed before B even makes contact. A good reason why you may have to retighten�.as you crush more you tighten more until you get the proper fit.

Of course with green wood you may still have to stop and tighten a little as you may be able to compress the entire tenon.




Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#10

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

Carole Valentine

Stuart,

The grain orientation on the tenon is probably one of the most valuable things that Russ Fairfield ever taught me, and he taught me a lot.

And with green wood you need to check your chuck tightness often...at least I have found that I do, but as someone else said don't crank it down for all you are worth.

When I make my tenons for my Nova chuck, I use a skew that is sharpened at the correct angle for the dovetail. I come in (from the tailstock end) with the point of the skew, along the edge of the tenon and then continue to let the skew flatten the shoulder. Gives me a flat shoulder with a very crisp transition from shoulder to tenon.

Oh, and I prefer the V gouge over the U. Probably just because that's what I learned with. I do use a different grind for the inside of the bowl...more blunt and shorter wings. Just my two cents worth.

Re: U-Shape vs V-Shape Gouge Problem

#11

Stuart- you will find the Thompson ....

JamieDonaldson

...U flute to be more rounded than some other brands, and Doug's V is between some other brands of U and V. I don't like tight V's like P&N, but Doug's V is a go to flute shape for me. The Thompson U can be very aggressive at removing lots of wood if you're not careful, and I think you found that out!